Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Caves pose unusual challenge for Army
Washington Times ^ | Thursday, October 11, 2001 | Rowan Scarborough

Posted on 10/11/2001 12:18:56 AM PDT by JohnHuang2

Edited on 07/12/2004 3:47:43 PM PDT by Jim Robinson. [history]

U.S. commandos set to begin search-and-destroy missions against terrorists in Afghanistan must be prepared for a new kind of combat

(Excerpt) Read more at washtimes.com ...


TOPICS: Extended News; News/Current Events
KEYWORDS:
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-2021-4041-6061-74 next last
To: JohnHuang2
Some of the larger bunkers will probably have to have powered ventilation systems, and may have air-reprocessing equipment for the living quarters. That means diesel generators for power, with ventilation shafts to provide air for the motors. Torching these shafts will suck all the O2 out and stall the motors, but they can be re-started as soon as there is air again. Might be better to dump ether down the shafts without lighting it, and let the motors suck it up.
41 posted on 10/11/2001 7:38:11 AM PDT by tacticalogic
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: realpatriot71, No Truce With Kings
"Cave nukes would actually be a pretty good idea...

Cave nukes will be the ONLY solution, shy of expending our Special Forces lives!

Afghan terrain is well suited to tunnel complexes superior to the clay-laterite we encountered in Viet Nam. These were put in place with industrial means, as opposed to manual labor, too.

I'm not a defeatist, I want them to use ground penetrator nukes and do this right, not spill a bunch of our blood rooting them out. We have way too much more that needs to be taken care of elsewhere. We can't be sucked into a long, bloody drawn-out battle of tunnel warfare that kills a bunch of our Special Forces! It would be foolish to expend their lives, when we have the nukes required at our disposal.

On a good note, the ground would contain the blast, making really small yeilds extremely effective. Most of the fallout will stay in the ground, too!

42 posted on 10/11/2001 7:40:07 AM PDT by Bill Rice
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 39 | View Replies]

To: Bill Rice
Exactly my point! :-)
43 posted on 10/11/2001 7:48:40 AM PDT by realpatriot71
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 42 | View Replies]

To: JohnHuang2
If I had my way, we'd be filling those caves and tunnels with napalm and fuel air explosives and torching the rats out."

Works for me.

44 posted on 10/11/2001 7:49:01 AM PDT by wattsmag2
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Skooz
Great quote. I also like the Corp of Engineers, "The difficult we do immediately, the impossible takes a little longer." Reich Minister Ridge reminded me of this one the other day.
45 posted on 10/11/2001 7:51:56 AM PDT by Republic of Texas
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 22 | View Replies]

To: JohnHuang2
Whats the problem with caves? Just cave in the entrance and bury them alive
46 posted on 10/11/2001 7:52:50 AM PDT by Grig
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Bill Rice
"Cave nukes will be the ONLY solution, shy of expending our Special Forces lives!"

I agree. But do we have the political will to use nukes?
I think the President and his team will only use nukes in response to weapons of mass destruction --
or to save the lives of many thousands of troops that might otherwise be killed.
This may be more pollitically acceptable in the Arab world.

47 posted on 10/11/2001 8:00:51 AM PDT by petbop
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 42 | View Replies]

To: Bill Rice
Yes, I've read about the Tunnels in Nam too. BUT WITH ALL DUE RESPECT, from all I've seen they weren't better or worse than Iwo Jima. Iwo Jima in part Convinced us to use Nukes in WWII.


48 posted on 10/11/2001 8:13:34 AM PDT by bluetoad
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 40 | View Replies]

To: Grig
Well, for woodchucks we just toss in a railroad flare and seal the entrance. That flare will burn for hours, eventually sucking up the oxygen. Of course a big cave will need a really big flare. That's what the SeeBees are for!
49 posted on 10/11/2001 8:20:35 AM PDT by gridlock
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 46 | View Replies]

To: bigjoesaddle
"THis might sound silly, but can't they train dogs to go in the caves with cameras on their heads?"

Better yet, place a fan at the cave entrance and allow my dog to break wind inside. Guaranteed surrender! lol.

50 posted on 10/11/2001 8:21:38 AM PDT by verity
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 19 | View Replies]

To: aristeides,Thorn11cav,chapita,harpseal,sneakypete,SLB,Squantos
Excellent point about the value of intell, which might be taken from cave strongholds intact. Such intell could provide directions to other cave complexes.

And of course, the forcibly conscripted Taliban POW/defector will be our best fountain of intell. A lot of these "Taliban in name only" were taken at gunpoint after seeing family members killed and sisters raped by the "real Taliban".

When these guys come over to our side, and are given some clean clothes and hot meals and medical treatment for chronic sores and illnesses they all have, they will be gung ho to lead our specops troops straight to the Taliban leadership.

With "our" former Taliban guiding us, the "real Taliban" will not be able to hide, even if they put on filthy rags and try to pass as refugees. We are going to have plenty of "Chieu Hois" or "Kit Carson Scouts" in this war, and they will be decisive if we play it right.

In Viet Nam, (from what I heard from the guys who were there) a SEAL specialty was the fast reaction op based on FRESH intell gained from prisoners and defectors. Intell on current meeting places of VC was acted on before the VC even knew that "old Tran" had been captured. SEALs went back on ops often the very same night or next night after the POW was taken, and made terrific hits.

If our specops troops are allowed to conduct IMMEDIATE follow-up ops based on HOT intell, we will do wonders.

But if the "chain of command" insists on all intell being chewed on for days all up the line before the attacks are conducted, they will find empty caves or (worse) our planes will blow up houses now filled with refugees.

Point is, the HOT intell must be acted on ASAP, and not be allowed to grow cold before permission is granted to launch the next raid, just because 25 REMF officers insist on putting their "chop" on every mission.

51 posted on 10/11/2001 8:24:06 AM PDT by Travis McGee
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 16 | View Replies]

To: JohnHuang2
Said a Navy source, "It's time to get down and dirty. We have to send in ground troops of some quantity and root the bad guys out of the caves and tunnels. If I had my way, we'd be filling those caves and tunnels with napalm and fuel air explosives and torching the rats out."

We already know that these people actually hate us, they don't want to conquor and co-exist, they want to utterly distroy us. I think this is the only way to handle the situation. It will also cause the others, outside of Afganistan to pause. If they don't, I'm in favor of using the same tactics against them.

Face it folks, it's not our foreign policy, it's not our religion, it's not that they think we back Israel (Bush wanted to completely stay out of it), it's that they have to hate. The world will never be safe as long as they are allowed to exist. This isn't something we wanted, they've proved it themselves over the past few week.

I have no problem with the Muslim people, I'm not talking about them, I'm talking about the extremists who have stirred this pot to the point it has become a dangerous brew for the entire world.

52 posted on 10/11/2001 8:30:16 AM PDT by McGavin999
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Travis McGee
From what I remember the good snatch and grabs were always based on hot intel. SOP was the job was done before we got the go/no go order from the REMF's. Old intel meant a cluster f*ck of great magnitude. The intel I would hope for would be some contacts for the dirty war phase and some lists of USA contacts.

Unfortunately that means someone is going to have to go into the tunnels and caves. Also they will hopefully get more prisoner intel.

Stay well - stay safe - stay armed - Yorktown

53 posted on 10/11/2001 8:35:25 AM PDT by harpseal
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 51 | View Replies]

To: JohnHuang2
Said a Navy source, "It's time to get down and dirty. We have to send in ground troops of some quantity and root the bad guys out of the caves and tunnels. If I had my way, we'd be filling those caves and tunnels with napalm and fuel air explosives and torching the rats out."

I would imagine this cave fighting will be a no holds barred deal. Particularly if heavy causalities start to roll in. These cave deals are probably booby trapped to the max. And in a war zone, it's unlikely that serious rescue operations will be mounted in hot zones.

It could get rough.

54 posted on 10/11/2001 8:43:37 AM PDT by TKEman
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: harpseal
I think we will get plenty of "chieu hoi" defectors from folks we grab on the outside. Maybe they can point out cave complexes, but since we don't want to occupy the country, I'd support using any means to extinguish all life inside without putting our troops at risk.

IOW, let Janet Reno run that phase.

55 posted on 10/11/2001 8:48:13 AM PDT by Travis McGee
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 53 | View Replies]

To: JohnHuang2
new kind of combat — cave warfare

These people really get to me. New?

Heck, the Japs were experts at caves in WWII.

Get some of those old marines that my Dad was landing on the beaches from his LCI (and since my Dad is still amongst us, healthy, alert, etc ... I have to figure a bunch of them are still among us) and have them train our guys if nothing else.

They used special flame throwers and other devices. A horrible way for those in the caves to die ... but better than letting them kill our guys by applying less obtrusive or extreme methods. The Japanese soldiers came to fear it greatly ... but they fought hard and died hard anyway.

IMHO, we need to allow these terrorists the opportunity to do the same ... die hard.

56 posted on 10/11/2001 8:52:07 AM PDT by Jeff Head
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: JohnHuang2
. If I had my way, we'd be filling those caves and tunnels with napalm and fuel air explosives and torching the rats out

Sounds like a plan.. I'll go for that.

57 posted on 10/11/2001 8:52:54 AM PDT by Texas Mom
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Travis McGee
I also would support any means to exterminate the occupants with one humble exception I want to get the intel that will lead to all the other rat holes. i also would not be surprised if some documentary evidence linking OBL and the former occupant of 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue were to be discovered in one of these rat holes. I have no evidence just my suspicions.

Check this link Shippers: Government Prior Knowledge - Pending Attack

Stay well - stay safe - Stay armed - Yorktown

58 posted on 10/11/2001 9:21:07 AM PDT by harpseal
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 55 | View Replies]

To: bluetoad
"...from all I've seen they weren't better or worse than Iwo Jima."

WITH ALL DUE RESPECT, It was the japs proving their fanaticism there that convinced us to use nukes, NOT their tunnels. I don't think Iwo Jima's caves held a candle to the tunnel complexes in Viet Nam. Cu Chi alone had 250 Kilometers of interconnected tunnels!

If Iwo Jima's complexes did compare, we didn't learn too much about tunnel warfare, considering all the expensive stuff that didn't work in Viet Nam. We tried blowing or plugging them up, pumping in gases and chemicals, sprinkling the entrances with stuff that killed them or helped us track them, we tried devices that sniffed out urine. We even tried using bedbugs that were supposed to get excited when they smelled sweat. (They couldn't tell WHOSE sweat they smelled!)

That book I keep harping about was an excellent read about all the "high tech" things the Army Warfare College (or some such name) developed and experimented with.

But it all came down this - the only thing that REALLY worked was a guy armed with a knife, small revolver, flashlight, and a rope tied to his leg, so they could drag him back out if something happened. These guys has a SET!

Most of those tunnels in Cu Chi are still there, except for the ones that were exposed by the arc light missions towards the end of our involvement. By that time, we had already been defeated by the pinkos at home.

BTW-My link doesn't go to the book, it goes to material from it with pictures that made it appear to BE the book.

59 posted on 10/11/2001 9:22:27 AM PDT by Bill Rice
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 48 | View Replies]

To: Jeff Head
They used special flame throwers and other devices. A horrible way for those in the caves to die ... but better than letting them kill our guys by applying less obtrusive or extreme methods. The Japanese soldiers came to fear it greatly ... but they fought hard and died hard anyway.

IMHO, we need to allow these terrorists the opportunity to do the same ... die hard

Fill up a cave with a little propane and offer them a cigarette. Actually, in Vietnam we had a M113 with a flame thrower on it, used plain old mogas and comressed air. I don't think I have a picture of it, but will try ot find one. Nickname "Zippo" was not original, but functional.

60 posted on 10/11/2001 9:32:09 AM PDT by SLB
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 56 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-2021-4041-6061-74 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson