Posted on 04/30/2025 11:02:29 AM PDT by Red Badger
[Note: This article has been updated to include a new response from the office of Hakeem Jeffries.]
HOUSE MINORITY LEADER Hakeem Jeffries was asked Monday whether Democrats should continue to advocate for the return of Kilmar Abrego Garcia, and the other men wrongly shipped to El Salvador, by making the trip to the country to put a spotlight on the issue.
“Our reaction is that Donald Trump has the lowest approval rating of any president in modern American history,” Jeffries responded.
But while Jeffries may be publicly agnostic on El Salvador trips like the one Reps. Robert Garcia, Yassamin Ansari, Maxwell Frost, and Maxine Dexter recently took, privately he sees the trips as having run their course. Two Democratic aides and a lawmaker who spoke to The Bulwark said that the minority leader has discouraged further excursions to the country even as pressure mounts within the party to turn up the heat on Trump for sending 238 men to a notorious prison system known for human rights abuses.
“They want to let the El Salvador stuff slow down,” a senior House staffer said.
Jeffries’s office initially declined to comment. But after the publication of this piece, a spokesperson put out a statement calling it false. The spokesperson, Christie Stephenson, said the item was “thinly sourced,” leaving out that their office did not initially push back when contacted prior to publication.
Stephenson noted that “Jeffries has repeatedly said, House Democrats will never stop fighting for the release of Mr. Abrego Garcia.” And, indeed, after the Supreme Court ruled that the White House had to facilitate Abrego Garcia’s return, Jeffries demanded that the order be “aggressively” and “immediately” enforced. “Mr. Abrego Garcia must be returned immediately before he is killed in one of the most dangerous prisons in the world. Enough with the fake bravado,” Jeffries’s April 14 statement read.
Whether Jeffries believes having House Democrats physically go to El Salvador will help or hinder efforts to get Abrego Garcia back is not addressed either in Stephenson’s statement or his own comments following the Supreme Court decision.
The debate among Democrats over how aggressively they should engage the issue of mass deportations, and the use of El Salvador’s prison specifically, has been simmering for weeks now. And Jeffries’s eagerness to sidestep it suggests that the party is far from a consensus.
While leadership may be more eager to talk about the economy, other Democrats say that there is a moral obligation to spotlight cases like that of Abrego Garcia. And they believe the politics are already turning in their favor.
Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.) was the first to go to El Salvador, noting that Abrego Garcia is a Maryland resident. The senator managed to meet with Abrego Garcia and confirm his health after days of pressuring the Salvadoran government, and after that visit Abrego Garcia was moved from the CECOT prison to another facility. The four House Democrats followed Van Hollen’s lead, hoping to draw attention to the hundreds of other men deported along with Abrego Garcia. Sen. Cory Booker (D-N.J.) reportedly made plans to visit El Salvador to advocate for the detainees there. His office did not respond to a request for comment on whether the trip was still in the works.
The Congressional Hispanic Caucus (CHC) was also working on arranging a trip to El Salvador that would be led by the chair of the caucus, Rep. Adriano Espaillat (D-N.Y.). One House Democrat said Espaillat’s trip was going to piggyback off Booker’s trip, but it was contingent on being given access to Abrego Garcia.
“Adriano didn’t just want to do a trip like the other Democrats did,” the lawmaker said, noting that the Democratic delegation was not given access to Abrego Garcia or any other detainees.
A spokesperson for the CHC told The Bulwark it has been in active conversations with El Salvador about a trip for weeks. Espaillat also attended Salvadoran President Nayib Bukele’s second inauguration last June, along with CHC members Rep. Lou Correa (D-Calif.) and Rep. Vicente Gonzalez (D-Texas).
“The Congressional Hispanic Caucus is working all avenues to ensure Kilmar Abrego Garcia rejoins his family and receives his constitutional right to due process,” said Espaillat.
Espaillat, like other Democrats, has focused on the Trump administration’s assault on due process in sending deportees to El Salvador without any hearings. It’s a line of attack that polls have shown resonates with Americans, as the president’s numbers dive sharply at the 100-day marker of his term.
“For years, Republicans primed the system for abuse and cruelty,” Espaillat said, “and now the Trump administration is crossing every due-process line in the book. But they did not rewrite the United States Constitution—due process is an inalienable right, regardless of status, for anyone and everyone in the United States of America.”
But some Democrats worry about the party growing overly consumed by the Abrego Garcia case. If members in safe seats continue to flock to El Salvador, it could give ammunition to Republicans to use against more vulnerable Democrats.
“One trip was sufficient, it made sense that Van Hollen went, but when the safest possible members go, it gives fodder for the National Republican Campaign Committee to start using it against other Democrats,” a second House staffer said, criticizing the wisdom of the second trip. “They should understand that what they’re doing is going to be hurting us in the long run.”
REP. GABE VASQUEZ’S OFFICE PROVIDED an example of how tricky the immigration issue can be for frontline Democrats. Vasquez represents a New Mexico district that includes a long span of the U.S.-Mexico border. The district’s Cook partisanship rating is even, indicating it’s neither significantly more Democratic nor more Republican than the country at large. In 2024, Vasquez won re-election by about 9,000 votes out of more than 265,000 cast. At a recent town hall he held, a tracker recorded Vasquez’s explanation of why he voted against the Laken Riley Act, a law that orders the detention by ICE of undocumented immigrants over even small violations like shoplifting, and his comments on Abrego Garcia and the violation of due process. Those comments quickly found their way into a Fox News story under the headline “Dem border rep brags about voting against Laken Riley Act,” with a quote from the NRCC.
Vasquez stands by his vote. And he noted that his message goes beyond Abrego Garcia. “We’re seeing innocent people, the spouses of military service members, kids being deported, authorities going into schools, military bases, hospitals, and arresting judges,” he told me. “Trump is taking a wrong turn on his mass deportation force and it’s going to make his position weaker.”
But some Democrats also worry that Abrego Garcia has become a less-than-ideal poster child for opposition to Trump’s immigration policies after it was revealed that his wife sought a protective order against him. She recently said in a statement that she acted out of caution because she had suffered domestic violence in a previous relationship.
“This is not the right issue to talk about due process. This is not the right case. This is not the right person to be saying that we need to bring him back to the United States,” Rep. Henry Cuellar (D-Texas), one of the party’s more conservative members, told Fox News Radio.
Chris Newman, a lawyer for the Abrego Garcia family, fired back at Cuellar and Democrats who said they are worried about the politics of supporting men wrongly sent to El Salvador.
“The trips have proven effective both in the efforts to save Mr. Abrego Garcia’s life and to save Democrats from the quagmire they are in on the issue of immigration,” he told The Bulwark. “What’s needed now more than wrongheaded hot takes like those from Congressman Cuellar is action, and my hope is there will be more members of Congress following the lead of Sen. Van Hollen and Congressmen Garcia and Frost.”
A third Democratic staffer defended the benefits of the Democratic House delegation’s trip to El Salvador despite their inability to meet with detainees.
“While the second trip did not deliver an explicit positive like Van Hollen’s did, it was a reminder for El Salvador not to do anything crazy while they were in the country and the bigger reminder is Trump is not going to be there forever,” the staffer said. “No matter what his hat sales say, he’s not going to get a third term or live to be 100.”
As Democrats remain divided over how much to emphasize the Abrego Garcia case and the detentions in El Salvador more generally, they await firmer guidance from above. Other House Democrats are willing to listen to leadership, a member of Congress said, but if Jeffries has a preference on El Salvador trips, he needs to communicate and make it known.
“As a member of a party you need to be disciplined,” a Democratic lawmaker said. “They say, ‘Get on a plane,’ ‘Don’t get on a plane’—that’s what you do. Nine out ten times you do what they ask. But you can’t take that approach if you’re not having regular communications. . . . You have to be clear in messaging what the plan is and you have to do that regularly if you want to keep people in line.”
One Last Thing
First on The Bulwark: The Immigration Hub is out with a new project timed to Trump’s first 100 days. In reaction to the White House’s stunt of showing mugshots of immigrants they deported, “Disappeared in America: The Faces of Trump’s Immigration Dragnet” documents more than seven hundred individuals—including legal residents and U.S. citizens—who have been detained, disappeared, or deported under the Trump administration.
Share this story with someone who has been closely following Democrats’ response to Trump’s deportations to El Salvador.
Donald Trump has the lowest approval rating of any president in modern American history,”
Liar
Me thinks Hakeem is losing control of his servants.
Democrats are probably hoping to make El Salvador the 51st state. LOL
But he's not an American citizen... So are we now going to "rescue" every imprisoned violent felon on earth from the dangerous prisons that their own nation put them in, "before they are killed"? If not, why not? What's the difference here?
Methinks the Dems are OUT OF MONEY!
The Dems that did go down there stayed in 5 star resort hotels and ate at expensive restaurants on the DNC dime.........................
So, now what?
Has the Maryland Man suddenly become The Tar Baby, wiser heads wish to avoid in topic or in person?
**Congressman Maxwell Frost is nothing but a rabble rouser anyway, who likely prefers filling his weekly schedule on do-nothing air flights to El Salvador, vs working for his constituents in Florida. You know, like those high school kids who are fine with staging ‘Walk Outs’ from school for any feeble Liberal cause, so long as they can skip school.
They’re broke. The grifters who went down there were videoed in 5 star hotels lounging by the pool............
Buy homes in iconic white liberal ‘elite’ communities and place gangbangers and other illegals criminals there for THEIR communities to ‘assimilate’.
Price is no object when you consider how many lives will be saved when these nose in the air elites decides ‘not in my back yard’... Is Obama’s mansion for sale? Maybe a charming Martha’s Vineyard vacation place?
Why end five-star Hilton luxury vacations under the guise of being social warriors?
The DNC is broke as a convict, to coin a phrase................
“Wrongly shipped”...and the lies continue.
Lies. It’s probably the safest prison. They don’t mess around.
I notice the commies didnt care about due process when Obama was deporting over 3 million illegals.also..Trump’s approval rating is just fine..maybe Jeffries should focus on the Dems approval rating which I heard yesterday is 19 percent
You remember when Texas sent a couple of bus loads of illegals to Martha’s Vinyard right???
Not working out for you, huh??
They go to El Salvador for only one reason. For the photo ops of putting on a televised rage display for the clowns and chumps who vote for them. Spanish language TV loves this dramatic crap. They cover everything about immigration on their 6PM news. I saw it quite a few times in the 1990s
NO NO NO. Keep it up democrats. And while you’re at it bring your trannies and pride flags for protests to free the deported gangsters and demand they be brought back to the USA. It is a winning strategy. Every democrat should be there at CECOT
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.