Posted on 02/11/2025 7:04:19 AM PST by daniel1212
Karoline Leavitt blames Biden for egg shortage, but killing infected birds was Trump’s policy, too .
If Your Time is short
About 108 million commercial egg-laying chickens have died since a highly pathogenic avian influenza outbreak began in 2022, either from the virus or culling, Agriculture Department data shows.
Depopulation of a farm’s chickens, most of which would die anyway, takes place to prevent the virus’ spread.
Depopulation is not a new strategy unique to former President Joe Biden’s administration. It also was USDA policy during President Donald Trump’s first term.
See the sources for this fact-check
President Donald Trump promised to lower prices for groceries, including eggs. But one crack in his plan is that egg prices haven’t fallen since he took office Jan. 20.
White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt, in her first on-camera press briefing Jan. 28, blamed that on former President Joe Biden’s "inflationary policies."
Leavitt said the Biden administration and the U.S. Agriculture Department "directed the mass killing of more than 100 million chickens, which has led to a lack of chicken supply in this country, therefore a lack of egg supply, which is leading to the shortage."[...]
White House Deputy Press Secretary Anna Kelly referred PolitiFact back to Leavitt’s press briefing comments.
Egg prices rose under Biden — from $1.60 per dozen in February 2021 to $4.10 in December 2024 (his first and last full months in office), Bureau of Labor Statistics data shows. The Agriculture Department’s January food price outlook said egg prices could rise about 20% more this year.
A spokesperson for Expana, a company that tracks consumer prices, told Axios that a dozen large eggs costs more than $7 in some U.S. regions.
Since Feb. 8, 2022, when the virus was detected in a commercial flock, more than 147 million birds, including chickens, turkeys, ducks and geese, have died, the USDA said.
USDA data shows 108 million egg-laying chickens died since 2022, including 13 million in 2025. It’s not clear how many were euthanized or died of the virus.
As of Jan. 29, bird flu has also been detected in dairy cattle, affecting 944 herds in 16 states, U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention data shows. Humans have also tested positive for the virus — 67 confirmed cases have been reported in the U.S. and one person has died, the CDC said.[...]
"If the birds are dead, the virus dies along with them," Russ Daly, a veterinarian for the South Dakota Department of Health and a South Dakota State University professor, said.
Chickens that contract the bird flu virus have little chance of survival; 90% to 100% of them die, usually within 48 hours, the CDC said.
Waiting for the chickens to die naturally allows more viral load into the atmosphere, making it more dangerous for the farm workers and other people who come in contact with the farm, Jada Thompson, a University of Arkansas agricultural economics and agribusiness associate professor, said.
Is this policy new?
Several veterinary professors told PolitiFact that depopulation or "stamping out" of sick birds is a long-standing policy and pointed to a 2015 bird flu outbreak during the Obama administration.[...]
A 2016 USDA report shows that depopulation in 2015 resulted in 50 million birds killed.
A USDA bird flu response plan, updated in May 2017 during Trump’s first administration, incorporates policy guidance based on lessons from influenza outbreaks during the Obama and first Trump administrations. It said "rapid depopulation of infected poultry is critical to halt virus transmission and must be prioritized."
During a March 2017 bird flu outbreak, a USDA report said, "nearly 253,000 birds were depopulated." [...]
Our ruling
Leavitt said there’s an egg shortage because the Biden administration "directed the mass killing of more than 100 million chickens."
Leavitt’s statement is partially accurate but leaves out important details and context. We rate it Half True.
For their part, so-called "Politifact" craftily tends to use outlandish claims, or one specific of a claim order to refute all of it.
Consider a Politifact refuation of a claim that, "Chicken farm fire that killed 12 million birds intentionally set."
The actual claim was from a Feb. 17 Instagram post
"Chicken farm in Texas with 12 million chickens destroyed by fire."... "Over the past two years, someone has destroyed hundreds of chicken, beef, egg, and dairy production facilities. I don’t know who is doing it but it is far from random. Is one reason that food is getting much more expensive in the US."
Of course, it is rather sad the one would even consider something on Instagram to be worthy of a Politifact check, but it enables them to basically assure us that there is really "nothing to see here."
For on February 26, 2024 Politifact states that,
A 2022 fire that destroyed one chicken house at a Lebanon, Pennsylvania, farm killed about 250,000 chickens. A 2023 fire in a Bozrah, Connecticut, chicken coop killed about 100,000 chickens.
Fires at chicken farms and food processing plants are common. A 2022 National Fire Protection Association report found that from 2014 to 2018, there were about 930 structure fires annually at livestock or poultry storage facilities, which includes barns, stockyards and animal pens. Heating equipment or electrical equipment malfunctions were those fires’ leading causes, the report said.
Birgitte Messerschmidt, the association’s research director, told PolitiFact in 2022 that fires at food production sites are "nothing out of the ordinary."
Animal Welfare Institute data shows that in 2023, more than 480,000 animals were killed in barn fires. That total includes about 300,000 chickens killed in fires at farms in Connecticut and Delaware. In 2020, 1.6 million animals died in barn fires, the institute said. - https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2024/feb/26/instagram-posts/texas-chicken-farm-fire-revives-baseless-conspirac/
However, notice that while barn fires. are common, that those not equate to the number of chickens being lost as being common.
Besides the aforementioned Lebanon, Pennsylvania, fire (https://www.wgal.com/article/lebanon-county-pennsylvania-kreider-farms-poultry-fire/42241178) that killed about 250,000 chickens in 2022, and the 100,000 chickens that were killed on January 30 2023 when a fire tore through the egg farm in Bozrah CT.. (https://www.nbcconnecticut.com/news/local/approximately-100000-hens-killed-in-fire-at-hillandale-farms-in-bozrah-doag/2964707/), there also were,
120,000 chickens killed in fire at Oakdell Egg Farms in Cache County ,April 24th 2024 - https://kutv.com/news/local/120k-chickens-burned-in-oakdell-egg-farms-fire-in-cache-county-smoke-flames-four-alarm-firefighters-lewiston-marshal-extinguish-water-investigation
A Feb. 7, 2025 fire at a facility in western Ohio that was licensed to house about 280,000 young hens raised to lay eggs. - https://www.nytimes.com/2025/02/07/us/ohio-chicken-farm-fire.html
Ignoring some other fires, that is 250,000 100,000 120,000 280,000 = 750,000 since 2022.
And while barn fires are common, that does not mean 750,000+ deaths of chickens over the course of about 3 years is. And politifact does not mention that in over 100 Fires in Animal Farms Every Year, 99% of Victims are chickens (https://arcj.org/en/issues-en/animal-welfare-en/more-than-100-poultry-farms-and-other-livestock-farms-catch-fire-each-year/)
In addition to which, from 2022, "US egg factory roasts alive 5.3m chickens in avian flu cull – then fires almost every worker." - https://www.theguardian.com/science/2022/apr/28/egg-factory-avian-flu-chickens-culled-workers-fired-iowa
May. 28, 2024, Farmers must kill 4.2 million chickens after bird flu hits Iowa egg farm. - https://www.wbtv.com/2024/05/28/farmers-must-kill-42-million-chickens-after-bird-flu-hits-iowa-egg-farm/
At least 36 million egg-laying chickens have been killed in recent months in order to prevent the spread of the bird flu, - https://www.tiktok.com/@abcworldnews/video/7464387695603666206
Add over 36 million to over 750,000+ deaths of chickens over the course of about 3 years and you understand why egg prices are so high.
1/2 truth, LOL
Starting to appear as if we are worse for the chickens than the virus.
Is there an infection map? Why are these cases randomly showing up around the country?
Just like COVID the more they vaccinate, the more mutations they create, some worse than the previous.
The chickes should sue.
So I really don't give a rat's ass what their "ruling" is.
Anyone know why they don’t allow hens that survive the bird flu infection with minimum affect to become breeder hens. That would help establish bird flu resistance in the breeds.
the Biden administration and the U.S. Agriculture Department “directed the mass killing of more than 100 million chickens, which has led to a lack of chicken supply in this country, therefore a lack of egg supply, which is leading to the shortage.”[...]
And if nothing had been done, we would blame the govt for doing nothing.
Now we can blame them for doing something.
A dozen jumbo eggs were $0.69 here at Walmart before Biden. They went up to almost $4.00 a dozen under Biden. They came back down to about $2.50 a dozen then the cage free rule went into effect. Now I can’t find jumbos and am paying $5.50 for a dozen large eggs.
I want to thank the Democrats in Michigan for jacking up the cost of eggs. Just so they can say free range on the carton. I mean it’s good that the 15 chickens standing in the door get to leave if they want. Feel sorry for the other 15,000 stuck in the coop behind them.
The price is not a huge difference but still I eat 6 eggs a day. So my cost in the last four years is up $2.40 a day for smaller eggs. To others who can not afford it that is horrendous. I only spend about $75 a week to feed myself.
I get beef from a local farmer at about $4.00 a pound. I eat a lot of beef eggs and cheese.
And the fact checker says this is only half-true because the Biden Admin had a really good reason for doing what they did.
Doesn't make it half true. Makes it all true.
Depopulation of human beings, all of whom would die anyway, is not a new strategy.
Solution is easy: enforce chicken distancing (3 feet), chicken masks, and a “vaccine” booster every 3 months for rest of chicken’s life. If a chicken refuses to vaccinate or wear a mask they must be ostracized and even fired from job. See the pattern?
Is the /s necessary.
The rules of debate were tossed on the dumpster fire of Biden’s tenure.
By Trump.
The fires did as much, if not more, damage.
Time to put Biden “I did that” stickers on egg crates.
THERE WAS ONE FACILITY FIRE THAT KILLED 1 MILLION BIRDS-—ONE PLACE-ONE FIRE-ALL BUILDINGS.
IIRC-—IOWA
But it is very hard for people to grasp the idea that a government could actively reduce the population for their own nefarious purposes. They have learned nothing from history. Bill Gates hardly makes any attempt to conceal his contempt for the lowlife humans that infect his realm.
Other reports claim OVER 159 MILLION birds.
A NEWLY hatched chick doesn’t lay eggs right away.
They forgot to account for the egg-pooping magic Unicode. Fewer chickens, fewer eggs…no half about it.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.