Posted on 09/06/2022 6:31:29 PM PDT by SoConPubbie
As the war in Ukraine rages on and the people living there suffer as their leaders stubbornly resist any rational diplomatic settlement to end the crisis, it is important to take a closer look at the idea of Ukrainian territorial integrity. As Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky intransigently stated when discussing possible negotiations to end the conflict, “Our priorities in the negotiations are known. Ukraine’s sovereignty and territorial integrity are beyond doubt.” President Biden and other American political leaders have vociferously declared “the commitment of the United States to Ukraine’s sovereignty and territorial integrity.” But if we are supporting a war to defend the territorial integrity of Ukraine, we should carefully examine the basis of these claims. A tiny island in the Black Sea can help to give some historical perspective to the issue.
At the beginning of the war, on February 24, 2022, Russia seized control of Snake Island in the Black Sea. The Ukrainian propaganda machine quickly capitalized on the incident, reporting that when the Russian warships told the island’s garrison by radio to surrender, the ‘heroic’ Ukrainian defenders replied, “Russian warship, go fuck yourself.” The media reported that the defenders all died heroically defending the island, and Zelensky announced that he would posthumously award them with the nation’s highest honor, “Hero of Ukraine.” Of course, like other similar reports, such as the ‘Ghost of Kiev,’ this was nonsense. None of the Ukrainians died when Russia took control of the island.
Ukrainian nationalists like Zelinskiy have long used Snake Island as a symbol of their national sovereignty. When he held a press conference on the island in the summer of 2021, the Ukrainian president declared, “This island, like the rest of our territory, is Ukrainian land, and we will defend it with all our might.” But is there any truth to the claims of Snake Island being Ukrainian territory? To understand the real issues here, we need to look at the history of the island.
Snake Island is located 45 kilometers from the coast of Romania. Historically, it belonged to the principality of Moldavia, which united with its sister principality, Wallachia, to form modern Romania in 1859. The island is basically a small rock in the Black Sea, with a surface area of only 170,000 square meters or .17km, but it is strategically important. It has no source of fresh water or resources to allow for permanent habitation.
The Ancient Greeks and Romans called it the White Island because of white marble ruins found there. The island is first mentioned in writings from 777 B.C. According to Greek mythology, the Goddess Thetis asked Neptune, the God of the Sea, to raise an island from the sea to honor her son Achilles, the hero of Troy. The remains of Achilles and Patrocles were said to have been brought to the island by Thetis to be placed in a sanctuary. The Greeks built a large temple here to honor Achilles. The temple is mentioned by the Roman poet Ovid who was exiled to Tomis on the Black Sea Coast (modern-day Constanța in Romania).
The fifteenth-century Nuremberg chronicle affirms that the Romanians had made use of the island since ancient times, following the formation of the Romanian people after the Roman conquest of Dacia in A.D. 106. The island first became part of the Romanian state of Wallachia when Mircea the Old, prince of Wallachia, inherited the region known as Dobrogea from his father-in-law, Dobrotici, in 1389. During the fifteenth century, control of the island shifted back and forth between the Romanian principalities of Wallachia and Moldavia, coming under the rule of Stephen the Great (1457-1504), the remarkable prince of Moldavia, during the second half of the century.
The first foreign occupation of the island occurred in 1484 when it was seized by the Ottoman Empire as it aggressively expanded into the region. The Turks captured the Moldavian ports of Chilia and Cetatea Alba, and Moldavia lost its fleet. During the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, control over the island shifted back and forth between the Ottomans and the Russian Tsars as both continued to occupy the Moldavian territory.
The modern name “Snake Island” comes from numerous water snakes that inhabited the island. A famous naval battle between Russia and the Ottoman Empire, the Battle of Fidonisi (meaning Snake Island in Greek) occurred here on July 14, 1788, ending in a Russian victory.
The Treaty of Bucharest in 1812, ending another Russo-Turkish War, was disastrous for Moldavia as Russia seized Bessarabia, almost half of the principality, situated between the Prut and Dniester rivers, along with Snake Island. The border between Russia and the Ottoman Empire was then fixed at the Chilia branch of the Danube. In 1829, the Treaty of Adrianople moved the border to the St. George branch, giving Russia effective control over the mouth of the Danube. Turkey then took back control of the region at the end of the Crimean War in 1856, regaining southern Bessarabia and Snake Island.
The Romanian War for Independence in 1877 saw Russia retake southern Bessarabia while Romania regained control of Dobrogea, the mouth of the Danube, and Snake Island. The island was bombed by the Germans when they invaded Romania during World War I, destroying the lighthouse that was later rebuilt by Romania.
The end of World War I, saw the completion of Romanian national unity, as Bessarabia along with Transylvania voted, through popular assemblies, to join Romania in 1918. The Versailles Treaty ending the war confirmed these decisions and also reaffirmed Romanian control over Snake Island. For the first time since the brief unification of the historic Romanian lands under Michael the Brave in 1600, the lands inhabited by the Romanian people were united, and the formation of modern Romania was complete.
Tragedy, however, struck in 1940 when the Soviets, who had negotiated a deal with Nazi Germany to carve up Eastern Europe between them, issued an ultimatum to Romania and seized control of Bessarabia and northern Bucovina in the eastern part of the country. What followed was genocide. In 1940, over 350,000 Romanians were deported or murdered by the Russian and Ukrainian Soviet leaders. In an effort to defend its people and reclaim its territory, Romania was compelled to join with Germany in its attack on the Soviet Union in 1941.
The Germans administered the island during World War II, but Snake Island again fell under foreign domination when it was seized by the Soviets on 28 August 1944. The Soviets also retook control over Bessarabia and northern Bucovina. They divided up the Romanian territories they occupied, rewarding the Ukrainian Soviets with the territory of northern Bucovina and southern Bessarabia, while creating a fictitious Moldavian Soviet Republic in the remaining territory. As they imposed their brutal rule over the region, the genocide continued. By 1953, almost 2.5 million Romanians had been killed or deported from these regions by the Stalinist regime.
On 4 February 1948, Romanian Prime Minister Groza ceded Snake Island to the Soviets by means of a secret protocol that was, however, never ratified by the Romanian parliament. Soviets installed a military base on the island to maintain air and sea control over the mouth of the Danube. The water snakes that gave the island its name were exterminated during the Soviet occupation. The island became more important economically after 1980 when oil and natural gas reserves were identified in the continental plates surrounding the island.
With the collapse of the Soviet Union, Snake Island, along with Bessarabia and northern Bucovina, now came under Ukrainian occupation. The government of Ukraine continued the policies of its Soviet predecessor, oppressing the Romanian population in those territories, and denying them the right to use their native language in education and other official capacities. The Ukrainian government has also continued the policy of its Soviet predecessor in falsely claiming that Romanians and Moldovans are distinct ethnic groups to try to foster division among them.
Unfortunately, for the Romanian people, a series of corrupt and inept governments have ruled the country in the post-communist era. Desperate for acceptance into NATO and to appease the West in hope of economic benefits, in 1997, the Romanian government under Emil Constantinescu signed a treaty recognizing the Ukrainian occupation of Romanian territory and ceding Snake Island to Ukraine in exchange for its demilitarization. Pressure from the United States led to the ratification of this treaty ceding Romanian territory to a foreign power, which the eminent Romanian historian Florin Constantiniu rightly referred to as a “disastrous treaty” for Romania. Many consider it an act of treason by the Romanian government.
The appeasement policies by leaders in Bucharest did not end Ukrainian aggression against Romania. Ukraine tried to pretend the Island was inhabited to extend its territorial water rights to 20km around the island in an effort to deny Romania access to natural resources. Fortunately, the International Court of Justice intervened in 2009, allowing Ukraine only a 12-mile limit around the island, which the court declared to be a rock in the sea, instead of an inhabited island as Ukraine falsely claimed. Still, the damage to Romanian interests because of the government’s appeasement policy with Ukraine was significant.
The history of Snake Island and that of the Romanian territories occupied by Ukraine demonstrates the difficulty of taking claims of Ukrainian territorial integrity seriously. Ukraine is made up of many lands taken from other nations in the illegal Soviet annexations during World War II. For Ukraine to be able to rightfully ask for other nations to respect its territorial integrity, it should first have worked with its neighbors to restore those territories it had illegally acquired as an heir to the Soviet regime. In addition, its treatment of minority populations, particularly the Romanian minority in the occupied territories, does not lend any justification to claims by Ukrainian leaders of being adherents of democracy. In the end, the absurdity of the international media fawning over the ‘heroic defense’ of Snake Island reveals itself as nothing more than praising two imperialist powers, Russia and Ukraine, for fighting to control Romanian territory over which neither has a legitimate claim.
K.B. Ungureanu is a senior researcher at the Center for Romanian Studies, an independent academic and cultural institute based in Palm Beach, Florida, with the mission to promote knowledge of the history, literature, and culture of Romania in the world.
Death to Russian imperialist animals and their cheerleaders in the United States. My paternal ancestors had to put up with these savages for centuries and it sickens me to see Americans carrying the water for a cockaroach like Putin.
Its kind of funny how they are post tons of articles cheerleading the invasion but when you call them on it they claim they just want America to stay out of it.
ALL territorial integrity, anywhere on Earth, is a myth.
You get to keep what you can successfully defend. When the time comes that you can’t defend it, the jig is up.
'nuff said.
Do be aware Ukraine was never a sovereign nation until 1991. It was ( is) Polish territory, Russian territory, Romanian, etc….at the current rate, it should be carved up and given to it’s historic owners ( which I suspect will happen to some degree).
Problem fixed. RIP 1991-2023.
You get to keep what you can successfully defend. When the time comes that you can’t defend it, the jig is up.
—————-
Historically correct. So maybe the corrupted, immoral, weak EU is carved up to its pre-1938 borders? Just saying.
How about we love these unloveables instead. Death, hatred, and envy are the fuel of Marxism. Let us instead resist evil and follow the opposite of Marxism, the way of the Cross.
Ukraine for Ukraine People! The Black Sea IS Ukrainian! All Russians should be expelled! Not one word of Russian should be printed, or spoken in that sacred land. An Iron Democracy must be established over all the hearts and minds of the People. Anyone who dislikes President Zelenskyy is a Putin dog and should be expelled! Ukraine must be admitted to the EU today and NATO as well, ready to crush Russia forever. All Russian controlled lands on the Black Sea must be given to Ukraine! The Russian Navy leave at once (or better yet, be sunk). A new day is coming—all who have died will not have died in vain.
Vai de mine! Fuarte informativ. Si autorul e Magyar (glumesc — Ungereanul).
Translation:
Wow! Very informative. And the author is Hungarian (I joke - Ungereanul = “The Hungarian” in Romanian)
Well said.
Well Poland hadn’t been a nation for quite sometime before Versailles in 1919. It was divided among Germany, Austria Hungary, and Imperial Russia. Soviet Russia attempted to retain its portion and more in 1919-20. Ukraine BTW was recognized as a nation state by the UN along with Belorussia,in 1946, and were members of the General Assembly and Ukraine did a few turns on the Security Council.
No nation in this fight has clean hands. I say a plague on both your houses. We should end our involvement and offer mediation as we should have done before the war started.
How about we love these unloveables instead. Death, hatred, and envy are the fuel of Marxism. Let us instead resist evil and follow the opposite of Marxism, the way of the Cross.
———
Exactly, why is no nation calling for Peace? The ONLY person I heard was Trump calling for Peace, negotiations……the entire EU, US, Russia, war, war, war…the conflict between Ukraine and Russia has all the Biblical hallmarks of “ Evil destroying Evil”.
Soooo...Ukraine has been a sovereign nation since 1991.
The treaty for Snake Island was signed in 1997, six years later.
So what?
I am not sure if I need to do a Heil Hitler salute to you or call you comrade!
—————
Plenty of video footage showing Ukies doing just that, even their children. There is no denying the Neo Nazis are firmly implanted in the Ukies government and military.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.