Posted on 02/17/2022 5:38:20 AM PST by Kaslin
Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor’s recent comparison of human beings to machines revealed far more of modern liberalism’s pathologies than she likely intended. It exposed the reductionist and materialistic heart of the liberal project.
Sorry, Madame Justice, but humans are not machines. With proper maintenance and a source of earth-generated power, machines can operate indefinitely. They have no need of rest and no need of meaningful interactions with other machines. They can just keep producing material things (including the rearranging of electrons) 24/7 indefinitely.
Time was that that the heart of American liberalism beat in synchrony with human hearts. And the reason liberalism worked was that it was constrained and undergirded by the robust, Judeo-Christian culture that surrounded it through most of American history. Private property and individual freedom incentivized economic growth, but the rule of law that rested on Biblical values channeled that freedom and the prosperity it generated for the common good while restraining the animal spirits of greed and selfishness to which all humans are prone.
The father of Classical Liberalism, John Locke, himself acknowledged the God of the Bible and said that there are limits on liberty. He said that men and women are not free to destroy themselves or others. But that is exactly what extreme liberalism has been attempting to do.
Today our liberal political economy is suffocating Americans with never-ending pressures to consume, clogging their homes with too many material things that wear out too fast, overburdening their lives with too many frenetic activities, and offering them too few periods of peaceful, contemplative rest.
Unlike machines, humans are flesh and blood. Although they face mortality in this world, they are eternal spiritual beings. They need nourishment and rest. They need refreshing time off to spend with family and friends. And they need to be in communion with God for spiritual maintenance and enjoyment.
Scripture tells us that God created humans on the Sixth Day. And after that arduous effort, God Himself rested on the Seventh Day. And God tells us that humans need to rest on the seventh day, the Sabbath, too.
For the first couple of hundred years that Christians lived on the North American continent, they kept observing the Sabbath as they had done in the old country. The Sabbath was ordained by ecclesiastical authorities and eventually enforced by secular governments in America through a series of statutes that came to be known as “Blue Laws.”
Why they were called “Blue” is still a mystery, but the fact is that every state in the Union had them on the books, and enforced them, until the late 20th century. A few of them are still in effect in a handful of states.
What was life on the Sabbath like under Blue Laws? Well, it meant that Sundays were quieter. Set apart from the other six days of the week. Shops, bars, and restaurants were closed. Maybe a few pharmacies were open for a few hours for emergencies, and first responders had to work, but most everything else was shut down.
Certainly no one went to work—businesses and factories were closed. Places of worship were open, of course, as were parks and other places for recreation. In 2022, the closest we might come to that kind of shut down is at Thanksgiving and, maybe, on Christmas Day.
Today more than ever Americans need a break, once a week, every week from the madness of 21st century life. Time off from to-do lists and emotionally manipulative online rabbit holes. Poor and lower income Americans, especially, need that break, even more that the rest of us. A break from the burden of menial, backbreaking work in a 24/7 economy.
America needs to reestablish those Blue Laws—to force the liberal economy to take a breather.
American children need a break, too, especially having suffered so much from pandemic measures. They need to play. And they need quality, explicitly non-productive, time with their parents, extended families, churches, and friends.
Proponents of ending Blue Laws in past decades argued that the Sunday Sabbath could be a “moveable feast” and that it could be observed on any day of the week. But that missed the point, which was that to benefit one and all and to be predictable for planning purposes everything had to come to a halt on Sunday. Of course, another benefit was that church attendance would increase. Certainly, no honest person living through the moral and spiritual chaos that defines daily life today in the USA could object to that.
Imagine shutting down social media, online pornography—and even Amazon—for 24 hours once a week. Those modestly paid workers at Amazon and elsewhere would get to spend more time with their families and, by limiting their labor supply, their wages would go up. And the many corrosive effects of the metaverse could be at least somewhat mitigated.
Critics of the old blue laws complained that, over the years they were in effect in the 18th, 19th and 20th centuries, politicians granted so many carve-outs, waivers, and exemptions that they became unfair.
That would certainly be one of several issues to deal with in the legislative process of re-establishing them. But the benefits of Blue Laws ultimately outweigh any temporary or minor downsides. And politicians may find that campaigning to establish a truly restful and refreshing weekend will be a hit at the polls this fall.
Mmmmm, no.
Mmmm, yes.
“Do not say, “Why were the old days better than these?” For it is not wise to ask such questions.”
Ecclesiastes 7:10 NIV
Can’t have that, people actually going to church, parks, creating a stronger family and stronger communities.
North Dakota is/was like this. It takes a little getting used to, but Sundays are really quiet and calm.
Big fat no. We would have to go to a non-tech society and be completely non-competitive. If you want to force people to rest, that’s one thing, but forcing nearly everyone to take Sunday off (what about people whose Sabbath is *not* on Sunday?) had a lot of problems that the author is simply glossing over whilst wearing his rose-tinted blinders.
No. Having government interfere with businesses, e.g. when they are allowed to be open, is either corporatist or fascist, depending on one’s perspective. Neither is beneficial.
I agree with what you said.
Until COVID I thought “Blue Laws” were antiquated but I have changed my opinion, I think the author is correct. BTW-I’m old enough, 68 today, to remember many of these.
Yes, they could be problematic especially if you had an event planned for Sunday and you forgot to stop by the liquor store on Saturday but all in all it was much better then.
Another problem with today’s America, too much legal immigration from disparate countries due to the Fatassed Ted Kennedy changing immigration policies in the 60’s. It worked as designed.
Americans should grow the hell up and stop asking government to legislate personal moral standards that we are perfectly capable of adopting for ourselves. And that statement covers a lot of ground that goes way beyond just Blue Laws.
Start with yourself, then get your own family on board. Find a job that doesn’t require Sunday work. If you’re the boss, then set that rule for yourself and your entire company. Stay the hell away from shopping malls on Sundays. Heck — Don’t even log on to Amazon or any other retail sites on Sundays.
I do my part by taking this one step further and going out of my way to patronize business establishments that are closed on Sundays. I must confess, however, that it’s not difficult to do when you’re surrounded by Mennonites and Amish who — unlike the simpering, pathetic Christians who seem to show up in the media these days — would set themselves on fire before they’d ever open for business on a Sunday.
Sunday is not the Sabbath, Saturday is. Sunday is the first day of the week, Saturday is the seventh.
Eliminating Blue Laws was the right thing.
It would be no different than if the gov’t enacted Ramadan laws.
Workers now have more flexibility in their schedules than ever before. Work from home, 4-10 hour days rather than 5-8 hour days, etc.
Let the market decide what is best and let workers choose the employer that matches their personal needs.
Such things should be about Individual Liberty, not collective mandates.
No.
If a store wants to be open on Sunday, that’s their business.
If a person doesn’t want to shop on Sunday, then don’t.
When I was a kid on Long Island, I remember going into a pharmacy with one of my parents on a Sunday.
The pharmacy area was open, but the aisles of the pharmacy were roped off with those movie theater style rope lines.
Even as a kid, I thought it was weird.
Imagine that, national Sunday legislation. Who would have thought...
Yep. Chick-fil-A doesn’t need a government mandate forcing them to remain closed on Sunday, a corporate decision that has cost them billions of dollars in lost sales.
They’ve taken this path on their own free will.
Which sabbath? Saturday or Sunday? Saturday sabbath is not just for Jews.
I do miss quiet Sundays but don’t believe you can legislate this in a truly free society
There are lots more accurate and fitting phrases that could be used to describe Sonia Sotomayor following her comments.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.