Skip to comments.Catholics Support Death Penalty
Posted on 06/18/2021 5:19:04 PM PDT by ebb tide
Nearly two-thirds of Americans favor capital punishment, according to a recent Pew Research Center poll of over 5,000 adults. While White Protestants top the list of those favoring it, 58% of Catholics likewise approve of it.
Dennis Prager: "Your whole being cries out for some justice and fairness in this world."
The only groups found opposing the death penalty are atheists and agnostics.
The 14% of American Catholics who strongly oppose the death penalty share their convictions with two of the last three popes.
Jeremy Irons: "The death penalty targets the economically disadvantaged, those who can't afford good legal counsel; those without a voice in society."
Pope St. John Paul II recognized its legitimacy in principle but said it should be administered only as a last resort when necessary to protect the innocent. Pope Francis went even further, adding the word "inadmissible" — an ambiguous term that avoids whether it's intrinsically or extrinsically evil.
Reporter quoting Pope Francis: "The death penalty is inadmissible."
If an act is intrinsically evil it's wrong in and of itself and can never be performed for any reason. If extrinsically evil, changing circumstances could justify the act. No pope has ever declared civil authority's choice to redress murder by capital punishment is intrinsically evil.
Reporter: "Benedict XVI urged the bishops of the Philippines to continue in their efforts against the death penalty."
Pope Benedict XVI taught Catholics may have legitimate disagreements on when or if capital punishment should be applied. Unlike abortion and euthanasia, the Church's developing doctrine on the death penalty is not dogma and can change.
I think that was proven during the Reformation.
In our state the death penalty is hardly ever used because it is insanely expensive to take someone all the way from arrest to the chair (or needle nowadays). Most just get life with no parole. The law does remain on the books, however.
It always seems odd to me that liberals tend to oppose the death penalty. And they say we should not take someone’s life regardless of whatever heinous crime has been committed. But those same Liberals are in favor of abortion on demand and taking the baby’s life.
Although the death penalty should be more widely used, even just having it on the books, and even occasionally used probably persuades some felons to accept life without parole without a fight.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.