[Diana in Wisconsin]

[Magnum44]

Hopefully we will have another Trump pic on the bench before this is heard in Oct.

[Lurkinanloomin]

They didn’t define “shall not be infringed” in the Constitution....../s

[bravo whiskey]

What does NYC consider a loaded gun? No magazine? No round chambered?

[Georgia Girl 2]

NY is some kind of cray cray!

[JimRed]

...the upstate homeowner could not get a permit to keep a second handgun there.

Any permit or licensing requirement is a clear violation of the second amendment. That needs to be clarified once and for all. What do they fail to understand about "shall not be infringed"?

[antidemoncrat]

SCOTUS can review the 2nd amendment over and over and it’s ok with Democrats but don’t you ever think about re-considering ROE vs Wade.

[budj]

"...poses any threat to public safety...">

Legally carried guns by law-abiding citizens are a protection of public safety.

[umgud]

They should also look at “licensed firearms!”

[Lazamataz]

I have a good feeling about this. SCOTUS seldom takes a case without a good possibility of an overturn, and the lower court sided anti-gun.

[FLT-bird]

I think we all see now who was holding up 2nd Amendment cases from being heard by the SCOTUS so that Leftist dominated Circuit Courts could get away with issuing rulings that are clear infringements of the 2nd Amendment and which are contrary to Heller 1 and Heller 2.

[frog in a pot]

It said petitioners had not shown there was inadequate access to one of the seven firing ranges in the city, that petitioners could not rent a firearm if they wanted to go to a range elsewhere, or that the upstate homeowner could not get a permit to keep a second handgun there..

I.e., petitioners failed to prove they were innocent.

[Vaquero]

Where is Ruth Buzzi Ginsberg??? She gonna phone it in?? Go to work, Ruth, or RESIGN.

[slumber1]

Someone explain to me how the city of New York has any jurisdiction over what a citizen does outside the city limits. If the city’s authority doesn’t stop at the city limits how far into the state or country are they allowed to legislate

[onedoug]

My Constitutional rights are from God, not men.

[zeugma]

I hate articles like this that never mention the case name.

[shanover]

The left hates guns but loves killing babies. What’s the difference between killing a baby with a gun or “medical instrument?” Gun control and baby control are the foundation of the left’s hold onto power.

[TangledUpInBlue]

Setting the entire issue aside for a moment....

How can the City legislate against ANYTHING going on outside the City?

[fella]

I hope that they finally get around to defining the term “Shall Not Be Infringed”.

[1Old Pro]

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit ruled for the city.

Bizarre