Posted on 01/07/2018 5:30:38 AM PST by MarvinStinson
Humanities professors say organization evading moral, professional duties
Dozens of humanities scholars cancelled their membership with their field's leading professional academic organization ahead of its annual convention, in retaliation for the group refusing to impose boycott, divestment, and sanctions against Israel.
The defecting professors wrote to the Modern Language Association—published in the days leading up to the conference being held this week in New York City—that they will not be renewing their membership, due to the organization "disgracefully" voting in June against BDS and in favor of a statement denouncing academic boycotts.
Timothy Reiss, a professor emeritus of comparative literature at New York University, wrote he was leaving the organization he had been a part of for over 50 years "sadly but easily."
"I have to resign from a professional organization that has abrogated its moral, and professional, duties," wrote Reiss, characterizing censure of Israel as "the great moral issue of our time."
Many accused their anti-BDS colleagues of being bigots, with Bill Mullen, a professor of American studies at Purdue University and prominent BDS activist, calling objection to boycott in favor of open dialogue a "profoundly racist, ethnocentric vote and rationale."
Rajini Srikanth, a professor of English at the University of Massachusetts-Boston, attributed "appalling racism" to those who oppose BDS.
"Witnessing the dance of anti-Palestinian racism dressed up as deep concern for the academic freedom of Israeli academics was truly nauseating," she wrote of the summer session at which the final vote took place.
Cynthia Franklin, a professor of English at the University of Hawaii, wrote she was leaving because "for an organization like the MLA to find itself unable to support an ongoing non-violent, anti-colonial struggle is deeply hypocritical, and also racist and nationalist."
Julie Rak, a professor of English at Canada's University of Alberta, wrote that anti-BDS scholars who proposed that the Palestinian Authority and the terror organization Hamas, which controls Gaza, should be held responsible for Palestinian oppression—and not Israel—represented the "xenophobia and racism" within the MLA.
Rak also claimed the anti-BDS members "received funding from the Government of Israel to pay for memberships in order to ensure that the [anti-boycott] vote was ratified." Though the Israeli government has invested millions of dollars in combatting BDS, no proof could be found for Rak's allegation that any MLA members had their dues covered by those funds.
Some of the disgruntled professors noted Palestinian scholars' lack of academic freedom, attributing responsibility for those conditions to Israel, despite documentation of severe and violent suppression of academic freedoms in the Palestinian territories by Palestinian political and university officials, as well as by students affiliated with terror organizations.
Scholars also accused the MLA of manipulating the voting process to the detriment of BDS, by mandating official voting procedure and moderating debates. They claimed the MLA delegate assembly had stifled and silenced dialogue on BDS, though the organization had held sessions to discuss the issue for two years prior to the 2017 vote.
The letters were published on the website of the peer-reviewed humanities journal Critical Inquiry, and reproduced by MLA Members for Justice in Palestine, where they were accompanied with a template for a resignation notice other BDS supporters were encouraged to send to the organization's leadership.
Two of the now-former MLA members served on the Executive Council. In a long-winded letter, Lenora Hanson, an assistant professor of English at New York University, and David Palumbo-Liu, an endowed professor of comparative literature at Stanford University, said they had been elected on platforms highlighting BDS.
"The fact that we were elected on the basis of our platforms was a sign that a significant number of MLA members supported our commitments and convictions," they wrote.
A leader in the MLA's anti-BDS movement, Cary Nelson—jubilee professor of liberal arts and sciences at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign and former president of the American Association of University Professors—said Palumbo-Liu "lies" about running on a boycott platform.
"He claimed he was running on behalf of grad students," recalled Nelson of Palumbo-Liu's campaign.
Nelson suggested Palumbo-Liu acted prior to his executive appointment in the same way that boycott activists at the American Studies Association had allegedly hidden their anti-Israel associations in order to gain leadership positions ahead of that professional organization's successful pro-BDS vote in 2013.
Some of those resigning welcomed the recent election of Judith Butler as president of the MLA for 2020-21.
Butler has long been among the most passionate academic supporters of BDS. She serves on the advisory board for the pro-boycott Jewish Voice for Peace—a far-left organization that has feted a convicted Palestinian terrorist—and this week published a blog post at the MLA for Palestine website reiterating her strong support of BDS as a "movement for freedom."
Butler, a comparative literature professor at University of California-Berkeley, will fill the post of second vice president through January 2019, ascending automatically to the vice presidency and finally presidency of the MLA over the next two years. MLA officers are elected by the organization's 24,000 members.
According to Nelson, Butler's win reflected MLA members' respect for her work in gender theory, not her positions on Israel.
"As president, she will have to display reasonable neutrality. Of course, the BDS crowd is cheering her election, but they are mistaken if they think much to their benefit will come of her presidency," he added.
Nelson dismissed the resignations as "a symptom of defeat, a publicity stunt, a last ditch effort to capture press coverage."
"It will have no effect on the MLA save to deprive the anti-Israel coalition of some of its leaders. Some will no doubt rejoin the next time an anti-Israel resolution comes up for debate," he said.
"That said, the opponents of Israel will regroup and return to fight another day," he added.
In that vein, the MLA Members for Justice in Palestine contingent will hold an event Friday night at the NYU English Department on "new tactics and solidarities" to employ in pro-Palestine activism in academia.
Pretty much all of what they teach you can learn by yourself. Just be sure to get a library card and use it often.
Your incident you cite is just the tip of the iceberg.
The MLA became a focus of Leftist Wet Dreams over much of the last 50 years, since the late sixties as I recall. It has been a joke of an organization for all that time.
Since the sixties, the Leftists and counter-culture mavins of all universities have had to have a place to rally and this poor vestige of an academic association has been the rally point.
I hate when ‘news sites’ get the headlines wrong.
Let me help here - this is what it should read:
“Dozens of MLA members quit because their organization refuses to call for the Extermination of Jews in the Middle East”
Much better...
The anti-semites are lost in their own little world. Good riddance.
How did the organization refuse their demands in the frst place? That’s unusual courage for an academic organization.
They live in an alternate reality.
As Scott Adams would say, they are seeing in an entirely different movie in their minds.
Thanks MarvinStinson.
Julie Rak, a professor of English at Canada's University of Alberta... claimed the anti-BDS members "received funding from the Government of Israel... and David Palumbo-Liu, an endowed professor of comparative literature at Stanford University, said they had been elected on platforms highlighting BDS... A leader in the MLA's anti-BDS movement, Cary Nelson—jubilee professor of liberal arts and sciences at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign and former president of the American Association of University Professors—said Palumbo-Liu "lies" about running on a boycott platform. "He claimed he was running on behalf of grad students," recalled Nelson of Palumbo-Liu's campaign. Nelson suggested Palumbo-Liu acted prior to his executive appointment in the same way that boycott activists at the American Studies Association had allegedly hidden their anti-Israel associations in order to gain leadership positions ahead of that professional organization's successful pro-BDS vote in 2013.
Cynthia, you are either a hypocrite or historically ignorant.
Islamic colonialism pre-exists European colonialism and is/was far more violent.
Prior to Islam marching out of the Arabian desert all of North Africa was Christian or Jewish. Then came the Islamic bandits that murdered and raped its way across North Africa and in to Southern Europe. Spreading Islam by the sword. Taking slaves and murdering all males over six years old.
So, if you are to be true to your words and stated ideals the Israeli homeland would take historical and moral precedence over the Palestinian homeland (which never existed).
If you are against murder, rape and slavery you must be against Islam. If you are feminist you must be against Islam. If you are pro-democracy you must be against Islam. If you are pro religious freedom you must be against Islam.
Make up your mind do stand by your words or are you just anti-Semitic.
You’re not kidding. Why spend or borrow tens of thousands of dollars every year for yourself or your children to be “educated” by leftist racists like this! There are so many examples of great people throughout history who self taught themselves the skills needed to succeed!
Clearer...Thanks!
Like getting into a fist fight with Tar Baby. Don’t even think about it.
Most humanities PhDs do not get jobs as humanities professors because supply greatly exceeds demand.
“The anti-semites are lost in their own little world. Good riddance.”
If they are anti-semites, how do you square that with the fact that any number of them are Jews?
When handed the keys to Gaza, these Arabs trashed and looted the advanced agricultural and commercial structures which the benevolent Israelis bestowed upon them.
The so-called "Palestinians" are an amalgamation of primitive, uneducated, and inbred tribal cultures.. Not one of their heads contain normal "wiring". They are genetically defective from conception, and by custom and breeding, incapable of compromise or good will.
I believe that Reiss is (or was born) Jewish.
Calling out idiots like Timothy Reiss, a professor emeritus of comparative literature at New York University, is the great moral issue of our time.
Some people are just too dumb and evil...
You need to learn what a Jew is.
Atheists are not Jews.
Looks like these idiots are poster children for why college may not be a good idea any more. My gosh, such a thought would never have entered my mind, but all these “professors” ranting completely fabricated nonsense based on nothing but propaganda show what kind of “education” parents can look forward to their children having now. I have a feeling that new colleges teaching technical skills like chemistry and electrical engineering are going to pop up, places where people can attain job skills without the political libtard brainwashing.
If you'd like to be on or off, please FR mail me.
..................
Apparently a lot of racists in this organization. Or are the bigots the ones who left.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.