Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Why Didn't They Shoot the German? (This is good)
americanthinker.com ^ | Robert Arvay

Posted on 09/30/2017 4:19:11 AM PDT by RoosterRedux

I was watching a World War II movie in a theater, with an Asian immigrant friend, when I learned a lesson in culture that no university could have taught better. In one battle scene, there is a cease-fire order, and a German soldier approaches the British position, under a white flag of truce. The British commander steps forward, completely vulnerable, but the Germans do not shoot. There is a brief exchange of words, as the Germans demand surrender, and the British commander declines. Both men then return to their positions, and the deadly fighting resumes.

My friend in the theater leaned toward me, and quietly asked, why didn’t they shoot the German?

I was both amused and horrified at the question. It was unthinkable that one would shoot a man under a white flag, so unthinkable that it was literally laughable. I actually did laugh.

My answer was, they can’t shoot him; he’s under a white flag.

My Asian friend was perplexed for a moment, and then got it. So, this is how Western people fight wars.

This incident sticks in my memory all these years later, because it enlightened me to a profound truth. Not all cultures are equal. In that same war, the Japanese, for example, had utterly no regard for our white flags, unless it suited their purposes. Their concept of honor was utterly unlike ours. To them, it was the white flag of surrender that was dishonorable, and anyone who surrendered, friend or enemy, was a pariah. Suicide was preferable.

(Excerpt) Read more at americanthinker.com ...


TOPICS: News/Current Events
KEYWORDS:
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-2021-4041-6061-75 next last
To: rfreedom4u
My uncle was a Soldier on Okinawa. To this day he despises the Japanese and never talks about his experience other than to say “bad things happen in war. The best you can do is to get over them and move on.”

I had an uncle who was a B-25 pilot in the Pacific Theater during WWII. He was shot down over China and his whole crew survived six months behind enemy lines while the Chinese helped them get to General Chang's lines. The Japanese knew they were alive and tried everything to get them. Whenever the Japanese found evidence of my Uncle's presence at a village they killed everyone in the village and burned it down.

My uncle loved the Chinese people and hated the Japanese until the day he died.

41 posted on 09/30/2017 7:08:06 AM PDT by OldMissileer (Atlas, Titan, Minuteman, PK. Winners of the Cold War)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 25 | View Replies]

To: Clutch Martin

I agree with the WWII vet.

All victories have a price.


42 posted on 09/30/2017 7:10:25 AM PDT by karnage
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 11 | View Replies]

To: Vendome

I disagree re the “good guy” muslim.

VIRTUALLY ALL of those suffering from ‘sudden jihad syndrome’-—those who lived among us prior to it before attacking us-—were considered as friendly by t heir neighbors..........

Until they were NOT!


43 posted on 09/30/2017 7:12:17 AM PDT by Flintlock (The ballot box STOLEN, our soapbox taken away--the BULLET BOX is left to us.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: PUGACHEV

yes


44 posted on 09/30/2017 7:15:52 AM PDT by vooch (America First Drain the Swamp)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 12 | View Replies]

To: Lonesome in Massachussets
Another factor was that U.S forces were physically and emotionally exhausted by long hard fighting, and hac very little tolerance for or patience with misunderstandings caused by language barriers. It is really a lot easier to shoot a prisoner than search him, and escort him to the rear.

It happened in the ETO as well, and in that case, there were a fair number of Americans who spoke some German and Germans who spoke some English. The Germans were all over the place when it came to behavior- some of them had no compunction about shooting medics, etc, while others were "correct" to the point where they put themselves on the line. When Germans went past the established boundaries, they generally got it back good and hard.

(Incidentally, about a year before my dad passed away he told me about a situation involving an ETO vet uncle that touched on some of the points brought up in this thread. Dad did not tell me how it ended - I don't know if my uncle actually ever told him the ending - but there was no good outcome possible.)

Mr. niteowl77

45 posted on 09/30/2017 7:20:14 AM PDT by niteowl77
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 21 | View Replies]

To: Lonesome in Massachussets

“Take them to the rear,” was usually code for “get them away from the front line and kill them.”

Hacksaw Ridge has some illustrative scenes.


46 posted on 09/30/2017 7:33:21 AM PDT by PLMerite ("They say that we were Cold Warriors. Yes, and a bloody good show, too." - Robert Conquest)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 21 | View Replies]

To: Clutch Martin

Bump. Key word, resolve.


47 posted on 09/30/2017 7:50:11 AM PDT by VRW Conspirator (Enforce the Law. Build the Wall.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 11 | View Replies]

To: Gay State Conservative

I bet that’s part of it.

Then again, after watching “Blackhawk Down”, “Saving Private Ryan”, etc... what does a person really want to say?

My dad is a Korean War vet. Drafted and ended up in the DMZ. All my years of growing up he had PTSD, and he and Mom are relieved now, that there’s finally a word to describe what happened to him. I’ve promised to help him write a book so I’m recording his stories. He says he wants to talk about Korea, to give a picture of what it was - and that it would be ugly. But the words and stories he comes up with can’t convey that. The only references he’s made so far (after over a year of recording his stories) that come close to conveying it were his talk of the smell, and his talk of wanting to see a particular place where many Americans had died. He mentioned in passing a couple days ago that (IIRC) 56,000 Americans were killed in Korea.

But he wants to write the book to describe “community”. His generation survived the Depression because they each had a cow and chickens, and my grandma owned the store and offered credit to those who she knew couldn’t pay - saying no child would starve to death if she could help it. His stories truly reflect that the community was a family.

It’s everything that today’s society under the politicized culture and weaponized government is not.

I do feel like I’m living in a war zone, and as I watch the America I love die and realize it will die because of the deep state and the lack of those willing to fight the deep state, I’ve lost interest in talking about truth. There’s nobody willing to hear it or do anything about it so what’s the point of talking? We’ve long since passed the point where evidence and truth made any difference to the culture-at-large.

The old-time stories are the only place where life makes sense these days.


48 posted on 09/30/2017 7:53:09 AM PDT by butterdezillion
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 39 | View Replies]

To: OldMissileer

I’ll bet it was fed well before the pictures.


49 posted on 09/30/2017 8:07:32 AM PDT by robroys woman (So you're not confused, I'm male.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 30 | View Replies]

To: RoosterRedux

Stephen Ambrose (IIRC) wrote in one of his books that an ambulance full of American wounded took a wrong turn and ended up at a German roadblock.

The officer looked at the white-faced driver, checked inside, saw it was full of wounded and told the driver to turn around and get the Hell out of there.

About an hour later another vehicle came down the road, stopped, dumped off some large boxes, turned around and hauled posterior.

After waiting for the boxes to blow up, some guys (probably expendables) were sent out to see what was in them. It turned out it was full of American cigarettes.

Never saw anything even remotely comparable to that happen in the Pacific.


50 posted on 09/30/2017 8:23:42 AM PDT by Oatka
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: butterdezillion

That is one of the things my father talked about; albeit briefly.

The smell.


51 posted on 09/30/2017 8:32:24 AM PDT by wheresmyusa (FTUN)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 48 | View Replies]

To: RoosterRedux
....My Asian friend was perplexed for a moment, and then got it. So, this is how Western people fight wars....

Tell him that's why the Angle-Saxons rule.

569 --- spread to England

1492 --- spread to North America

1989 --- spread to the eastern communist world

No stopping now.
Next: spread to the rest of the world via the 'new' Anglo-American power.
52 posted on 09/30/2017 8:39:46 AM PDT by Koracan
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: robroys woman; exDemMom; OldMissileer
In the '70s a Cal Tech student brought his adult tigress to campus daily. She accompanied him to each class, but her favorite time was the lunch hour. He'd sit on the grass in the quad, and a dozen+ preschoolers would climb all over her--she just loved that. At the end of each day he had the hardest time pushing her into his van.
53 posted on 09/30/2017 9:05:40 AM PDT by Hebrews 11:6 (Do you REALLY believe that (1) God IS, and (2) God IS GOOD?)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: robroys woman; Hebrews 11:6
One of our Commander's Calls:


54 posted on 09/30/2017 9:41:32 AM PDT by OldMissileer (Atlas, Titan, Minuteman, PK. Winners of the Cold War)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 49 | View Replies]

To: Theoria
German and Jap men both sit to piss. Never figured that one out.

Sitzpinkler is a term of ridicule and contempt, not respect. So no, most don't...

55 posted on 09/30/2017 9:48:52 AM PDT by Moltke (Reasoning with a liberal is like watering a rock in the hope to grow a building)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 28 | View Replies]

To: jalisco555
"Japanese never surrender"


56 posted on 09/30/2017 10:04:08 AM PDT by aquila48
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies]

To: Moltke
The fact that Sitzpinkler is in the vernacular only proves my point.
57 posted on 09/30/2017 11:52:44 AM PDT by Theoria (I should never have surrendered. I should have fought until I was the last man alive)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 55 | View Replies]

To: aquila48

When they do they do so completely. My dad was among the first into Japan after the surrender. Initially everyone was confined to base out of fear that lone Americans would be killed if they wandered off. Very quickly the occupation authorities realized there was no danger. The Japanese fought like lions but when the emperor said surrender they all obeyed.


58 posted on 09/30/2017 1:03:06 PM PDT by jalisco555 ("In a Time of Universal Deceit Telling the Truth Is a Revolutionary Act" - George Orwell)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 56 | View Replies]

To: niteowl77
General Omar Bradley famously said that he was sick and tired of hearing reports of German snipers surrendering. The Germans would leave small contingents to cover their retreat, and when their ammunition ran out they would surrender. It was an effective tactic for the Germans. One ETO vet I knew well said that after Malmedy they did not take SS prisoners, and German troops who surrendered with an empty magazine were ordered to "run for it", though they never got far.

I don't know about "take them to the rear" being a dog whistle for "shoot them". For one thing, prisoners can be a valuable source of intelligence. (Many Japanese who surrendered were seething with resentment towards their officers, and willingly gave as much information they could.) The following snippet is from the memoirs of Major Dick Winters (Band of Brothers) T/5 Leibgott's parents were Austrian, and he spoke fluent German. He hated Nazis so badly that his fellow soldiers assumed he was Jewish, which he was not.

My casualties were one man dead and four wounded. Tech/5 Joseph D. Liebgott had been slightly wounded in the arm, but he was ambulatory so I assigned him the mission of escorting seven German prisoners to the rear. Liebgott had earned the reputation of being one of Easy’s best combat soldiers, but we had all heard stories that he was very rough on prisoners. Liebgott was one of Easy Company’s killers, so I deemed it appropriate to take a bit of caution. When he heard me say, “Take the prisoners back to the battalion command post,” he replied, “Oh boy! I’ll take care of them.” In his exuberance Liebgott stood up and paced back and forth and he was obviously very nervous and concerned.

I stopped him in his tracks. “There are seven prisoners and I want seven prisoners turned over to battalion.”

Liebgott was highly incensed and started to throw a tantrum. Somewhat unsure of how he would react, I then dropped my M-1 to my hip, threw off the safety, and said, “Liebgott, drop all your ammunition and empty your rifle.” There was much grumbling and swearing, but he did as I had ordered. “Now,” I said, “you can put one round in your rifle. If you drop a prisoner, the rest will jump you.” One of the German prisoners, an officer, evidently understood this exchange. After he understood my orders, he relaxed and sat down. Liebgott returned seven prisoners to battalion headquarters that day—I personally checked with Nixon.


59 posted on 09/30/2017 1:05:05 PM PDT by Lonesome in Massachussets (Psephomancers for Hillary!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 45 | View Replies]

To: aquila48

Of course my dad exaggerated a bit. Still it’s a fact that not a single unit of the Japanese army surrendered as such. Individuals yes but never whole units. Think of the German Sixth Army, the American Philippines garrison or the British garrison in Singapore. They all surrendered as units. The Japanese never until the total surrender occurred at the end.


60 posted on 09/30/2017 1:10:58 PM PDT by jalisco555 ("In a Time of Universal Deceit Telling the Truth Is a Revolutionary Act" - George Orwell)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 56 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-2021-4041-6061-75 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson