Posted on 03/12/2016 11:32:20 AM PST by Steelfish
The Geography of Trumpism NEIL IRWIN and JOSH KATZ MARCH 12, 2016
When the Census Bureau asks Americans about their ancestors, some respondents dont give a standard answer like English or German. Instead, they simply answer American.
The places with high concentrations of these self-described Americans turn out to be the places Donald Trumps presidential campaign has performed the strongest.
This connection and others emerged in an analysis of the geography of Trumpism. To see what conditions prime a place to support Mr. Trump for the presidency, we compared hundreds of demographic and economic variables from census data, along with results from past elections, with this years results in the 23 states that have held primaries and caucuses. We examined what factors predict a high level of Trump support relative to the total number of registered voters.
The analysis shows that Trump counties are places where white identity mixes with long-simmering economic dysfunctions.
The places where Trump has done well cut across many of the usual fault lines of American politics North and South, liberal and conservative, rural and suburban.
What they have in common is that they have largely missed the generation-long transition of the United States away from manufacturing and into a diverse, information-driven economy deeply intertwined with the rest of the world.
Its a nonurban, blue-collar and now apparently quite angry population, said William Frey, a demographer at the Brookings Institution. Theyre not people who have moved around a lot, and things have been changing away from them, but they live in areas that feel stagnant in a lot of ways.
SEE GRAPH The 10 Variables Most Closely Linked to a Countys Support for Donald Trump A correlation of 1 means the variable is a perfect indicator of Trump support.* Negative correlations are shown in red.
(Excerpt) Read more at nytimes.com ...
In other words, the poorly educated and often mocked low info voters.
A generation ago, people would call them blue collar stiffs.
My father, who never finished grade school, was that kind of guy.
Puerile! Address the “substance” of the article.
So it is abundantly clear that you do not consider yourself to be American. Now I understand. Thanks for clearing that up for us.
I say "outstanding"! If you insist on being seen as African...or Irish...or whatever then you need to *be* in Africa,or Ireland,or where ever.As Teddy Roosevelt once said there's no room in this country for hyphenated Americans.
From a statistical standpoint, those correlations are so low, both the positive and negative, that they are meaningless. They could have done a correlation with car color and Trump supporter and hit the same “correlation” levels.
Theodore Roosevelt,October 1915
People whose ancestors have been here for many generations don’t have a single ancestral nation with which to identify. Me, I have an English surname, but ancestry from: England, Scotland, Ireland, France, Germany, Switzerland, Czechoslovakia, and several native tribes. The only answer to give to such a question is “American.” There is no other country to which I can turn, for identity or anything else.
There are some good rejoinders in the article's comments, though.
Don ya wanna know who’s really supporting Trump?
Nazis and white racists! Cue the George Wallace meme.
No one supports a Nazi and a white racist, you know.
If you’re a Leftist, you know Trump is addressing his supporters in code.
Every one knows what he really means.
Well, when some of our ancestors were Massachusetts Bay Colony settlers, and our ancestry contains a mix of ethnic groups from every continent--"American" is a pretty good description.
Same situation here, but my earliest were Jamestown, VA. Beat you by two decades, lol.
Now we have Southerners voting for a “New York” values Yankee.
Here you go: a collection of correlations, mathematically strong but substantively meaningless. Although I'm sure I could think of a way to tie together Nicholas Cage movies and drownings...
Can you explain you logic that escapes us all? At least the others offered a thoughtful appraisal of the news story.
Imagine the disgraceful attitudes they will get from Hilary/ Bernie supporters?
And do you think Hillary’s inner city support has not been bypassed by the wonderful modern society?
Won’t be finding many Muslims who just identify as American.
When given the box to check I always check “Native American” which I am, my parents were, my grandparents were and my great grandparents were too I think. So dammit, I am one too!
Same story for my family. Some of my ancestors were here since time immemorial, some came from the British Isles before the Revolution, and some came here from Africa in chains.
I don’t know what else to call myself, but American.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.