Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Why Ted Cruz is a "natural born citizen" [A legal, historical and constitutional argument]
Washington Post ^ | 01/08/2016 | By Randy Barnett

Posted on 01/08/2016 9:09:04 AM PST by SeekAndFind

Linking to this succinct but powerful essay by Paul Clement and my Georgetown colleague Neal Katyal, Jonathan usefully summarizes the legal argument for why Ted Cruz, who was born in Canada to an American mother, is a "natural born citizen" under Article II, section 1 of the Constitution, which provides:

No Person except a natural born Citizen, or a Citizen of the United States, at the time of the Adoption of this Constitution,shall be eligible to the Office of President; neither shall any Person be eligible to that Office who shall not have attained to the Age of thirty five Years, and been fourteen Years a Resident within the United States. (emphasis added)

As he concludes in his post: "Under U.S. law, the fact that Cruz was born to a U.S. citizen mother makes him a citizen from birth. In other words, he is a ‘natural born citizen' (as opposed to a naturalized citizen) and is constitutionally eligible." To the evidence elicited by Clement and Katyal, I wish only to add that this conclusion is also theoretically justified by a proper conception of popular sovereignty.

The term "natural born citizen" had no existence or independent original meaning prior to the moment it was included in the Constitution the United States was founded. It was adapted by the framers [of the Constitution] from the well-known British concept of the "natural born subject" of the sovereign monarch.

England had numerous and changing legal rules governing exactly who was and who was not a "natural born subject," which can be used to muddy the waters. But one consistently applied rule is particularly germane: The offspring of the King were natural born subjects of the King regardless of where they were born, whether on English territory or not.

(Excerpt) Read more at washingtonpost.com ...


TOPICS: Constitution/Conservatism; Culture/Society; Editorial; News/Current Events; Politics/Elections
KEYWORDS: canadian; citizenship; cruz; ineligible; naturalborn; naturalborncitizen; tedcruz
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-40, 41-60, 61-80 next last

1 posted on 01/08/2016 9:09:04 AM PST by SeekAndFind
[ Post Reply]

To: SeekAndFind

Read


2 posted on 01/08/2016 9:11:24 AM PST by sauropod (I am His and He is mine.)
[ Post Reply]

To: SeekAndFind
NOTE: David Upham, associate professor of politics at the University of Dallas., reached the same conclusion, albeit tentatively, for the same reason back in March. In Ted Cruz: A Probable Natural-Born Citizen of the American Republic
3 posted on 01/08/2016 9:11:42 AM PST by SeekAndFind
[ Post Reply]

To: SeekAndFind

Show me his mother’s birth certificate.


4 posted on 01/08/2016 9:12:26 AM PST by heights
[ Post Reply]

To: SeekAndFind

Why is any of this needed.


5 posted on 01/08/2016 9:12:28 AM PST by A CA Guy ( God Bless America, God Bless and keep safe our fighting men and women.)
[ Post Reply]

To: heights

RE: Show me his mother’s birth certificate.

Let’s say it cannot be produced.... is it to be concluded that she was not American?

Would indirect evidence help? Say, his GRANDMOTHER/GRANDFATHER’s birth certificate?


6 posted on 01/08/2016 9:15:04 AM PST by SeekAndFind
[ Post Reply]

To: A CA Guy

RE: Why is any of this needed.

See post #4 above...


7 posted on 01/08/2016 9:15:23 AM PST by SeekAndFind
[ Post Reply]

To: heights

Show me his mother’s birth certificate.
********************************************
Ahh...have we seen Donald Trump’s father’s birth certificate? Have you yet demanded to see that?


8 posted on 01/08/2016 9:16:09 AM PST by House Atreides (Cruzin' [NO LONGER --and Trumping'] or losin'!)
[ Post Reply]

To: heights

Let’s see your mother’s birth certificate,


9 posted on 01/08/2016 9:17:16 AM PST by fatnotlazy
[ Post Reply]

To: SeekAndFind

Would indirect evidence help? Say, his GRANDMOTHER/GRANDFATHER’s birth certificate?
*************************************************************************
Careful, you’re giving the anti-Cruz jihadists ideas. The next thing we know they may be asking to see the maternal Great-Grandparents’ birth certificates. The feverish activities of the Cult of Personality members knows no bounds.

only partially /sarc


10 posted on 01/08/2016 9:19:51 AM PST by House Atreides (Cruzin' [NO LONGER --and Trumping'] or losin'!)
[ Post Reply]

To: heights

Is it your belief that the US consulate, when recording Ted Cruz’s birth in Canada as a US Citizen, just took her at her word that she was a US citizen. Perhaps anyone could just walk up to the Consulate and say “I was born in the USA, Eh!” and they take them at their word.

How do you think he got his US Passport? He was not Naturalized into a Citizen?

Just how many levels of documentation are going to be required?

Dated a month after his birth on Dec. 22, 1970, it shows that Rafael Edward Cruz was born to Rafael Bienvenido Cruz, a “geophysical consultant” born in Matanzas, Cuba, and the former Eleanor Elizabeth Wilson, born in Wilmington, Del.

Her status made the baby a U.S. citizen at birth. For that, U.S. law required at least one parent who was a U.S. citizen who had lived for at least a decade in the United States.

She registered his birth with the U.S. consulate, Frazier said, and the future senator received a U.S. passport in 1986 ahead of a high school trip to England.

http://www.dallasnews.com/news/politics/headlines/20130818-ted-cruz-born-a-citizen-of-canada-under-the-countrys-immigration-rules.ece


11 posted on 01/08/2016 9:22:30 AM PST by thackney (life is fragile, handle with prayer)
[ Post Reply]

To: heights

How old is his mother? Maiden name? At the very least she should show up in Census documents if she is old enough for the ones that are public. I would like to see what is recorded


12 posted on 01/08/2016 9:23:26 AM PST by RummyChick
[ Post Reply]

To: SeekAndFind

Timeline of Cruz:

https://www.scribd.com/doc/256409078/Cruz-Citizenship-Timeline-documented

Well written FR article explaining the meaning of ‘natural born citizen’:

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/news/2840767/posts

I think there’s a legal issue here that’ll present a problem if challenged. Courts though punted on Obama and said, “Let the political process decide who is eligible.”

If you don’t think the Clintons will litigate this if it’s not resolved, you don’t know the Clintons’ m.o.


13 posted on 01/08/2016 9:25:35 AM PST by TigerClaws
[ Post Reply]

To: SeekAndFind

14 posted on 01/08/2016 9:29:33 AM PST by The Iceman Cometh (Trump & Cruz - Together, a Better America!)
[ Post Reply]

To: sauropod

The “authoritative” articles linked to, one of which was actually referred to as ‘concise’, are lengthy.

The article referred to as “four supreme court cases define ‘natural born citizen’” begins by saying “let’s cut through all the opinion and speculation ...” and then spends half-dozen pages on the four cases. No cutting through here.

So, it’s becoming clear why the Cruz citizenship question is played around with so much, namely, because the answer is indeed not known.


15 posted on 01/08/2016 9:30:01 AM PST by cymbeline
[ Post Reply]

To: SeekAndFind
Since everyone who was a citizen at the time of adoption is dead we can remove the grandfather clause wording. We are left with “No Person except a natural born Citizen [...] shall be eligible to the Office of President;”

Why does the Constitution speak of “citizens” and separately of “natural born citizens”? Why is the word “natural” inserted? It is a matter of allegiance.

A person can be a “citizen” if they were citizens or subjects in some other country first but have come here and met the naturalization requirements. Also, if one is the offspring of a citizen and a non-citizen, then one is a US citizen. However, in both these cases it can be argued that the person might choose allegiance to their former country or to the country of the foreign-born parent or at least the allegiance might be considered divided. That is, there is no natural allegiance of the offspring to one or the other parent’s country. It is this divided or alienated allegiance that the Constitutional provision is designed to prohibit.

If, however, both of one’s parents are themselves US citizens, then one is a “citizen” as well as a “natural born citizen”. The “natural born citizen” is one who at birth has no natural allegiance to any other country and the Framers felt could be trusted to be loyal to the US and not act as a foreign agent. [footnote: Also, in their time, the rules of royal succession held sway throught much of the world and the Founders wished to forstall any potential claims by the crowned heads of Europe or their scions to sovereignty in the US.]

Note that native born is not the same as natural born. Native born simply refers to the place of one’s birth, i.e., one’s nativity. The term does not speak to the legal circumstances of a birth, merely to its location.

16 posted on 01/08/2016 9:30:45 AM PST by Paine in the Neck (Socialism consumes EVERYTHING)
[ Post Reply]

To: SeekAndFind

The authors use Cruz to protect Obama.


17 posted on 01/08/2016 9:30:52 AM PST by Ray76
[ Post Reply]

To: thackney

Cruz can make all those documents public and resolve this.

Why is he keeping them under seal?

His mother became a Canadian citizen. Did she ever renounce her citizenship here? Did she pay both U.S. and Canadian taxes (file returns)?

Regardless, some interpret ‘natural born citizen’ as requiring both parents to be citizens of the U.S. Originally it was determined based on the father’s status and we know that wouldn’t make Cruz a NBC.

It’s a ‘probably a NBC’ at this point. But there’s a possibility someone like Scalia would look at the framers and say Cruz isn’t qualified as a NBC.

To say it’s a ‘conspiracy theory’ is to parrot what we were told when we raised the issue with Obama.

Either we are a nation of laws, or we make up the rules as we go along based on what candidate we support. I prefer to live in a Constitutional Republic.


18 posted on 01/08/2016 9:31:29 AM PST by TigerClaws
[ Post Reply]

To: Ray76

That’s a good point re Obama.

If it is revealed after he’s out of office that Obama was, in fact, born in Kenya and not a NBC, it’ll have fallout politically and legally.

None of the law professor types like Cruz. They are laying covering fire for the eventual truth about Obama.


19 posted on 01/08/2016 9:32:59 AM PST by TigerClaws
[ Post Reply]

To: RummyChick

Census document and some other info

https://peskytruth.wordpress.com/2013/09/14/who-is-ted-cruz-really/


20 posted on 01/08/2016 9:33:11 AM PST by thackney (life is fragile, handle with prayer)
[ Post Reply]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-40, 41-60, 61-80 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson