Posted on 04/02/2009 6:07:17 AM PDT by Rummyfan
Did you hear the one about the queer, the Muzzie and the pre-op tranny?
No? Well, youre unlikely to anytime soon. The British government, fresh from recent proscriptions on religious and racial hatred, is pushing ahead with legislation that will criminalize homophobic jokes.
Ive been trying to recall the last time I heard a homophobic joke in a public forum. You have to go back a ways. At Vegas, Dean Martin used to have a bit of business where hed refill his tumbler and ask Frank, How do you make a fruit cordial? And Sinatra would go, I dunno. How do you make a fruit cordial? And Dino would say, Be nice to him.
But these days, no matter how cordial you are, its never enough. On the BBC comedy show Little Britain, a weekly glimpse of the hellhole of Hogarthian depravity that is the United Kingdom, there is a recurring character whose catchphrase is that hes the only gay in the village a Welsh village, I believe, so his claim would seem to be statistically improbable, if youll forgive a bit of Welshophobia - or is it Cymruphobia? Or Cymruhomophobia? Anyway, he doesnt actually have any gay sex and he gets inordinately jealous if some real live practicing gay comes passing through and threatens his unique status. But one could argue that his determination to be the only gay in the village testifies to the social cachet homosexuality now enjoys. On the other hand, one could argue something else entirely. On the other other hand, once youve attracted the attention of Constable Plod and his crack humorological investigative unit, youre probably best to cop a plea and settle for misdemeanor hatemongering and three points on your license.
Down the leftie end of Fleet Street, various columnists, justifying their support for the legislation, or at least its goals, have tutted their disapproval of gay stereotyping in comedy. Limp wrists. Camp walks. Judy Garland references. I write as the token heterosexual Judy Garland fan (please, no tittering) on the Macleans payroll, and as a chap whos sung with Liza Minnelli on TV (oh, okay, titter mercilessly, but no guffawing), yet I confess to some misgivings about the state demanding upon pain of a seven-year jail sentence that the citizenry pretend theres nothing the red-blooded knuckle-dragging English soccer yobbo likes better than listening to Judy singing The Man That Got Away before he nuts you in the head, knees you in the bollocks and tosses you through a chip-shop window. To its credit, the House of Lords inserted a so-called free speech amendment to the bill, but the Justice Secretary, Jack Straw, has decided to repeal that, announcing that there are no circumstances in which the right to free speech can justify homophobic behavior.
And why stop there? Representatives of the transgendered and the disabled were also invited by the government to grab a piece of the joke-police action. Interestingly enough, last week Barack Obama became the first US president to do a retard gag on national TV. Referring to his bowling score (129) during an appearance on The Tonight Show, the Kibbitzer-in-Chief cracked that it was like the Special Olympics. Ha-ha! What a wag that Obama is when he unplugs the teleprompter and kicks loose a little. How do you make a fruit cordial? Appoint him your GLBT Outreach Coordinator.
If my past experience of Mr Obamas notoriously touchy courtiers is anything to go by, its undoubtedly racist to suggest that the President is disablist. Likewise, Gloria Steinem and other feminists argued that Bill Clintons support for abortion entitled him to go around dropping his pants to any female subordinates who tickled his fancy (I paraphrase, but not much). But, that said, I do wonder how things might have gone had Obama essayed the same jest on a BBC talk show. Robin Page, the chairman of Britains Countryside Restoration Trust and a columnist with The Daily Telegraph, spoke at a rally opposing the governments anti-hunting laws at a Gloucestershire country fair in 2002. If you are a black vegetarian Muslim asylum-seeking one-legged lesbian lorry driver, he began, I want the same rights as you. A jocular reference to various approved identity groups by a member of an unfashionable one (country folk). Mr Page was subsequently arrested and, upon declining to answer questions without the presence of counsel, thrown in a cell. Dont worry. He eventually cleared his name after five years.
Her Majestys Constabulary: The joke police in every sense.
Thats the problem. Even if you think its a good idea for the state to regulate speech, the only troops available to do it are blundering coppers and hack bureaucrats. Last year, as readers may recall, I had the curious experience of having the tone of my jokes examined in a Vancouver courthouse by the geniuses of the British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal. Hitherto, such forensic dissection has been limited to the more obscure literary critics. But not anymore. Following their week-long deconstruction of Steyns tone, the BCHRT announced that for its next show trial it would be turning to the tone of Guy Earle, a stand-up comic whose late-night putdowns of some lesbian hecklers were allegedly homophobic.
Maybe it would be easier just to ban all jokes, except for official government-licensed rib-ticklers.
Who was that lady I saw you with last night?
That was no lady, that was my Gloucestershire Comedy Court probation officer.
Knock-knock.
Whos there?
Hugh.
Hugh who?
Human Rights Tribunal Joke Investigative Unit. Come out with your hands in the air, not fluttering around your hips as if its Carmen Miranda night at the Gay Stereotype Lounge.
Why did the chicken cross the road?
To take part in a demonstration against poultrophobic humour.
How do you make a fruit cordial?
Be nice to him. Or else.
Sometimes you have to pick the lesser of two evils, and, if its a choice between offensive gags or massive expansion of state power, no self-respecting citizen should find it difficult working out which is the lesser evil and which is the greater threat. You dont like the Presidents pathetic joke? Hoot and jeer at him. Obama could use more of that. The best response to his suggestion that his 129 bowling score put him in Special Olympics territory came from the Special Olympics bowler Kolan McConiughey who pointed out hes scored a perfect 300 on three occasions, and hed be happy to take on Mister Hopeychange any time he wants. That aside, I thought it was a revealing remark: As one of my Quebec readers put it, in Leno veritas. Away from the Telepromptered hopeychangey touchyfeely mush, this President is not cool so much as cold. The PC niceties are skin deep, and this wont be the first time he gives us a glimpse of the harder man underneath. Unlike Clinton, he doesnt feel your pain, and he doesnt care if you know it.
Still, if Obama really feels the urge to do crip shtick, I wouldnt criminalize it. In Britain, Canada and Europe, the state advances too easily from regulating behavior to policing ideas to criminalizing language. Its almost too cute an irony that one of the United Kingdoms few remaining principled champions of free speech is the creator of Mr Bean, a man who barely utters a word. The comedian Rowan Atkinson said he didnt think he was at risk of prosecution for telling a gay joke but I dread something almost as bad a culture of censoriousness, a questioning, negative and leaden attitude that is encouraged by legislation of this nature.
Ah, but, as the computer wallahs say, thats not a bug, thats a feature. If the pen is mightier than the sword, then criminalizing words is a way of disarming potential opposition, of inculcating a reflexive self-censorship in the citizenry. And, after all, self-suppression is the most cost-effective of tyranny. Political correctness isnt merely the blasphemy law of our time. It makes communication impossible. It renders a people literally illiterate: The conventions of language used by functioning societies throughout human history - irony, indirect quotation, period evocation, and, yes, even comic stereotype - are all suddenly suspect. What a strange fate to embrace. In London, the Lord Chamberlains power to censor West End plays was finally abolished in 1968: It was widely accepted by then that there was something absurd in a palace courtier ruling that your script could have three Bastards! but not four, and that two specific references to sodomy had to be replaced with one vague allusion to heavy petting. Yet, four decades on, Britons now think it entirely normal for police constables and timeserving bureaucrats to function as literary critics determining the intent behind a throwaway jest.
To hell with it, and to hell with sensitivity training. The only way a multicultural society can live in freedom is with what the Toronto blogger Kathy Shaidle calls insensitivity training: We all need to develop thicker skin and rub along without government monitoring. CSI Catskills is a totalitarian concept, and only a bunch of fairies would fall for it.
And just to clarify: Im not saying youre a fairy if you have sex with other men.
I am saying youre a fairy if you think the state should police our jokes.
Did you click the link I sent? That’s the link I was referring to.
Attorney; Now doctor, isn't it true that when a person dies in his sleep, he doesn't know about it until the next morning?
Witness; Did you actually pass the bar exam?
Witness; The autopsy started around 8:30pm.
Attorney; And Mr Denton was dead at the time?
Witness; If not, he was by the time I finished.
Witness; No.
Attorney; Did you check for blood pressure?
Witness; No.
Attorney; Did you check for breathing?
Witness; No.
Attorney; So, then it is possible that the patient was alive when you began the autopsy?
Witness; No.
Attorney; How can you be so sure, Doctor?
Witness; Because his brain was sitting on my desk in a jar.
Attorney; I see, but could the patient have still been alive, nevertheless?
Witness; Yes, it is possible that he could have been alive and practicing law...
Witness; Yes.
Attorney; How many were boys?
Witness; None.
Attorney; Were there any girls?
Witness; Your Honor, I think I need a different attorney. Can I get a new attorney?
No but I will now.
Thanks for posting. That was obviously an article I missed. Unfortunately, true and very scary.
LOL! :^D
I hear you. I sympathized with the maintenance crew who, basically, had to do the same. And yet they felt sorry for us stockers who "had to throw all those boxes around". Go figure.
How many socialists does it take to change a light bulb?
None. That is a job for the working class.
Yep!
Zachary!
And also this one—the Black Knight calls Arthur a “pansy”—homophobic if I ever heard it.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ONRnvoBXizY&feature=rec-HM-fresh+div
Just for grins and, proving, once again, that Yeats has left the planet (...and that not all Irish are 'poets'), I submit the following:
Nice ‘write’ Seadog, and so true.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.