Posted on 08/02/2008 5:26:15 PM PDT by Iron Munro
German Andrade for about 15 years lifted, loaded and carried out other physically demanding jobs as an illegal immigrant.
Then came the bucket.
It crashed from a skid loader onto Andrade's left foot at a landscaping work site. Fractures led to a lingering limp, which led to back problems and, said a judge, a 45 percent loss of earning capacity. At the time of the accident, Andrade, a husband and father in his early 30s, was earning $12 an hour.
Andrade's case took a public twist when his Sarpy County employer balked at forking over injury-related workers' compensation - and Andrade took the business to court.
Sun Valley Landscapes argued that because Andrade is an illegal immigrant, he was not covered by workers' compensation benefits. However, a three-judge review panel of the Nebraska Workers' Compensation Court has disagreed.
In a ruling affirming a trial judge's 2007 decision, the panel said that public policy favors the inclusion of illegal immigrants as covered "employees." The judges ordered Sun Valley to cover Andrade's medical bills and lost wages.
The ruling is believed to be Nebraska's highest judicial review of the question of undocumented workers and job-related medical bills and wage loss compensation.
It also represents one of the rare times that both sides of the polarizing illegal immigration debate are on common ground.
Bryan Griffith of the Center for Immigration Studies said his organization - which opposes amnesty for illegal immigrants and favors more restrictive immigration policy - supports the panel's decision. So does the Immigrant Rights Network of Nebraska and Iowa.
Griffith said shady employers would be more inclined to hire an exploitable, illegal work force at lower wages if they knew they weren't going to be held accountable for workplace injuries.
"If they hire a legal work force to begin with, none of this would be there," Griffith said of the case.
It was unclear from court documents when Sun Valley learned Andrade was not authorized to be employed, although Andrade's attorney said it was after he had worked a while for the business.
Norm Pflanz of the Nebraska Appleseed Center's Immigrant Rights Network said the panel's decision encourages safe work conditions overall.
"If all workers were not covered under workers' compensations laws," he said, "it would diminish protection for all of us."
Andrade's attorney, John Corrigan, called the court's order a win for the public as well as his client. He said the general public might be left picking up emergency medical tabs if injured illegal immigrants were deemed not to fall within the workers' compensation statute.
Corrigan dispelled any notion that workers' compensation is a "public benefit."
"The government doesn't pay for it, employers pay for it," he said. "It's an insurance policy the employer buys."
Glenn Morton, administrator of the Nebraska Workers' Compensation Court, agreed. The state requires employers to carry workers' compensation insurance, he said, or face criminal penalties.
"The premiums are part of the employer's cost of doing business," he said.
John Iliff, the attorney for Sun Valley Landscapes and its insurance carrier, declined to comment or say whether an appeal was planned. A call to Sun Valley was not returned.
The July 23 decision by Judges Michael K. High, John R. Hoffert and Ronald L. Brown affirmed a 2007 ruling by Judge James R. Coe.
It ordered Sun Valley to pay $305 a week for 36 weeks for temporary disability and $144 a week for 263 weeks for lost earning capacity. The landscaping company also must cover $29,000 in medical bills and other related services that in the future may be necessary.
Corrigan said that since Nov. 9, 2004, when the bucket fell onto his client's foot, Andrade has been unable to perform similarly demanding work.
The attorney said that Andrade is believed to still be in the Omaha area but was unavailable for comment.
Based on a previous Nebraska Supreme Court ruling on a more narrow slice of the Workers' Compensation Act, the threejudge panel declined to award Andrade any retraining or vocational rehabilitation benefits.
Such a benefit to an unauthorized worker not on a path to become legal would be contrary, the panel wrote, to the statutory purpose of returning an injured employee to suitable employment.
Andrade, the judges noted, had been illegally in the country since 1988 and had "demonstrated no intent despite contrary testimony" to become an authorized worker in the U.S.
Corrigan said the Supreme Court in the past case had declined to address the broader questions of lost wages and medical bills for injured illegal immigrants. He said most employers and insurance companies don't object to such coverage even for undocumented workers.
In arguing against awarding the benefits to Andrade, Sun Valley said his unlawful status made him legally unable to enter into a contract of employment.
To that, the court noted that the word "aliens" is expressly included in the state's definition of employee. It said that by failing to modify the word aliens with the adjective "illegal" or "legal" and by failing to otherwise exclude illegal aliens, the Legislature intended to include illegal aliens within the Workers' Compensation Act's definition of employee.
Sun Valley also argued that Andrade should not be awarded loss of earning benefits because his illegal status is the inhibitor to him getting a job.
The court's response: "If his capacity to work has been diminished, that disability will continue whether his future employment is in this country or his homeland."
In their order, the three-judge panel wrote that the Nebraska Workers' Compensation Act insures an employee against accidental injury at work and also protects the employer. Allowing such benefits to injured illegal workers may actually help achieve the goals of the 1986 federal law that bans companies from knowingly hiring an illegal work force, the panel said.
"Without the protections of the statute," the judges wrote, "unscrupulous employers could, and perhaps would, take advantage of this class of persons and engage in unsafe practices with no fear of retribution, secure in the knowledge that society would have to bear the cost of caring for these injured workers."
No.
The ILLEGAL immigrant was lucky our country didn’t kick hin out back to his country, where he had apparently ZERO earning power.
I’m not surprised.
And what’s worse, I read a post further up the thread that homeowners need to be sure to check workman’s comp coverage from any contractors that do work on their property - employers leaving their clients vulnerable if a worker gets hurt.
Jeez.
Only problem is that its illegal to employ someone without a valid ID. At least thats what they tell us dumb american citizens.
Suddenly, that cheap labor ain't looking so cheap.
“Suddenly, that cheap labor ain’t looking so cheap.”
It has never been cheap for the taxpayer. It is cheap for the business owner who shares his profits from slave labor with politicians who facilitate the modern day slavery. I believe it will cost our country several dollars for each dollar someone saved.
Cheap fruit and vegetables (questionable now anyways) are not worth the price future generations will be saddled with for this insanity!
I know a orthopedist in Dallas that recently preformed knee replacement surgery on a man from Mexico. The patient had injured his knee earlier when a cow had kicked him. His employer in Mexico paid cash for the surgery.....
Good. I hope this keeps on happening. I’ve heard of other stories like this. Illegals should not be hired.
“His employer in Mexico paid cash for the surgery.....”
So not all the good employers are here in the states, and not all the bad ones are elsewhere.
Not nearly enough to cover what it is going to cost to pay for the judgment against the employer.
I always thought so. If the employer can save enough money hiring illegals - when using post-tax dollars - then more power to him, and he’s free to hire away.
Let the market decide...
I agree, but not so much because I'm worried about the illegal. I just want the employers of illegals to pay up, and I want the illegals deported.
Send him home, and let the employer pay the bills there. If Home is Mexico, they certainly will be a lot less than in the southern suburbs of Omaha.
For the AFIRE ping list.
Sun Valley Landscapes argued that because Andrade is an illegal immigrant, he was not covered by workers’ compensation benefits.
***It’s these types of companies that are pushing for the open borders policy. They don’t care about the impact upon society nor their own workers.
I agree with the ruling. I don’t see what documentation the employee used to be hired therefore I will not hold the employer responsible for hiring him. I don’t want employers being immigration cops anymore than I want employers to be bookkeepers for the government. The government can verify the documentation or change the laws. I think employers should show total cost of employment so workers can see what is actually taken from their actual pay.
Must've been his best runner..
j/k...;)
You mistakenly think illegals are rushing to get into the court system.
I adjusted WC claims for almost 5 years in California and had similar situations. The illegals sometimes come here planning to file a claim and take their settlement back to Mexico where the money goes a lot farther. I had some SSNs come back with 10 or more names tied to it from all over the country. I turned claimants and employers in for fraud with no results. I had video of an illegal working for a different employer and an idiot judge ruled that the claimant credibly testified that it wasn’t him in the video! I had depositions from several claimants that the employer paid them under the table. This reduced the premium and is employer fraud. The whole system is corrupt.
The hiring of contractors caused a heated discussion between my husband and me last year. We wanted to put new energy efficient windows in this old farm house. I wanted the best windows and licensed and insured contractors to install them. He wanted cheap labor. Since I was paying for them I prevailed. I hired professionals and made it very clear that there would be no illegals on my property. They said they never used them. I went over all the paperwork and small print. They did a wonderful and professional job and it was worth every penny.
I like to save money like everybody else but not when it comes to major home improvements. Our farm is paid for and I’m not taking any chances on losing it due to lawsuits by contractors.
The article says Andrade worked for 15 years. I did not see where it stated he worked for Sun Valley for 15 years.
A bit like America's "peculiar" institution, which netted huge profits for plantation owners for generations but was paid for through the suffering of others.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.