Skip to comments.
Bush Surge vs. Reid Surge - Reckless rhetoric can kill.
National Review Online ^
| April 23, 2007
| Mackubin Thomas Owens
Posted on 04/23/2007 8:59:59 AM PDT by neverdem
|
April 23, 2007, 0:40 a.m.
Bush Surge vs. Reid Surge Reckless rhetoric can kill.
By Mackubin Thomas Owens
When Nancy Pelosi, the Speaker of the House of Representatives, trekked to Damascus not too long ago to meet with the thug dictator of Syria, it occurred to me that she was essentially taking a page from a scene in The Godfather — the one in which Sonny dissents from a decision made by his father, Don Corleone, during a meeting with a representative of another mafia family. The representative — an assassin for the Tattaglias — immediately concludes that if the Don is eliminated, Sonny will take his place and cooperate. And sure enough, shortly thereafter, the Tattaglias attempt to assassinate the Don.
If “Sonny” Pelosi’s Syrian trip was ill-advised because of Assad’s likely perception that if he can wait out the Bush administration, he can make a better deal with the Democrats, how much worse was the widely reported statement last week by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid? According to news reports, Reid told journalists “I believe ... that this war is lost, and this surge is not accomplishing anything, as is shown by the extreme violence in Iraq this week.”
America’s enemies in the Middle East certainly took note of Pelosi’s trip: the Arab press was full of favorable reports of the Speaker’s pilgrimage to Damascus. The Middle Eastern press has also, not surprisingly, taken note of Reid’s comments (which he tried to take back later in the day). So in addition to feeding defeatism in the United States and demoralizing the troops who are in Iraq (or soon to be on their way there), Reid has most likely encouraged our enemies in that unhappy place.
Our enemies know that the war that counts is the one for the American mind. If we believe that the war is lost, they win. They have an incentive to keep fighting and to kill as many people as they can. In a gun battle with American troops, the insurgents lose. So they concentrated on killing as many Iraqis as they can in the hope and expectation that the news will demoralize the American public.
Lincoln noted that in a democratic republic, “public sentiment” is critical. During the Civil War, Robert E. Lee was an assiduous reader of Northern newspapers. By 1864 he understood that the only hope for the Confederacy was that war weariness in the North would lead to Lincoln’s electoral defeat. The Confederates put a great deal of hope in the “Copperheads,” the so-called “Peace Democrats” who did everything possible to obstruct the Union war effort.
During Vietnam, the Tet Offensive of 1968 was a military defeat for the North Vietnamese communists, but a public-relations victory that helped turn the American public against the war. In audiotapes released by the insurgents over the last couple of years, their leaders such as the late and unlamented Abu Musab al-Zarqawi have demonstrated that they understand the lessons of Tet very well.
There’s no way to know for sure, but I believe that the bomb attacks in Iraq that caused such carnage in recent days are the expected consequences of the Democrats’ efforts to undercut the president’s new team and the changed strategy represented by the so-called “surge.” We know what the Bush surge is. I think a good name for the increasing body count in Iraq is the “Reid surge.”
As the debate over funding continues: Watch your rhetoric, senators.
— Mackubin Thomas Owens is an associate dean of academics and a professor of national-security affairs at the Naval War College in Newport, R.I. He is writing a history of U.S. civil-military relations. |
|
TOPICS: Editorial; Foreign Affairs; Politics/Elections; War on Terror
KEYWORDS: dhimmicrats; islamophilia; reidsurge; tokyorose; treason; waronrepublicans
1
posted on
04/23/2007 9:00:03 AM PDT
by
neverdem
To: neverdem
And in both situations, the Democrats paid a heavy heavy price when the fog cleared. They can preach gloom and doom and the need to retreat
But, if they get their way, the remorse finally sets in, like the remorse some Republicans felt when they found that sitting on their hands in 2006 wasn't such a good plan after all.
Americans hate to be humiliated. We haven't actually accepted the Democrat position and pulled out in a spasm of fecklessness and cowardice.. And, all of this talk about getting "in" for the "wrong" reason is able to distract folks from the consequences of defeat.
But, in the fullness of time, if these people succeed in defeating the United States via betrayal in the Congress, the consequences will flow for generations just like they did after the Civil War and after the Vietnam War.
2
posted on
04/23/2007 9:10:53 AM PDT
by
dalight
To: neverdem
I think a good name for the increasing body count in Iraq is the Reid surge.More accurately "the Reid/Murtha/Pelosi surge."
3
posted on
04/23/2007 9:12:17 AM PDT
by
smoothsailing
("Freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction"--President Ronald Reagan)
To: neverdem
The Surge is Working, it is exposing who our real enemies are.
Pray for W and Our Troops
4
posted on
04/23/2007 9:14:26 AM PDT
by
bray
(The Surge is Working against both Enemies of America)
To: neverdem
I think the writer is correct.
Reid's words have emboldened the enemy and given them hope which has resulted in a spike of Iraqi-on-Iraqi murders.
When these Senators speak, people get murdered.
5
posted on
04/23/2007 9:18:48 AM PDT
by
what's up
To: neverdem
Theres no way to know for sure, but I believe that the bomb attacks in Iraq that caused such carnage in recent days are the expected consequences of the Democrats efforts to undercut the presidents new team and the changed strategy represented by the so-called surge. We know what the Bush surge is. I think a good name for the increasing body count in Iraq is the Reid surge. >
To: neverdem
I think the war in Boston is lost, and it is time, given the unacceptable escalation of the murder rate there, to pull our policemen out of Boston. Clearly, they are not wanted there, and the people of Boston should be made to stand up for themselves, as long as we make sure they are disarmed first. The War On Poverty’s another Quagmire, but that’s for another day.
7
posted on
04/23/2007 9:29:12 AM PDT
by
Humble Servant
(Keep it simple - do what's right.)
To: All
8
posted on
04/23/2007 9:39:54 AM PDT
by
PsyOp
(Any dangerous spot is tenable if brave men will make it so. - John F. Kennedy.)
To: neverdem
You can’t argue with his point. Reid explicitly said that “winning and losing” in Iraq is defined solely by how many innocent civilians are killed by the insurgents. If they kill lots of civilians, the war is “lost”, I guess if they stop killing civilians, then we have “won”.
So any civilian deaths in Iraq should be blamed on Reid, for defining that as victory for the insurgents.
To: neverdem
I believe that the bomb attacks in Iraq that caused such carnage in recent days are the expected consequences of the Democrats efforts to undercut the presidents new team and the changed strategy represented by the so-called surge.The Dems' words aren't helping us and their words aren't neutral. That leaves one option...
the words of *Nansiip el Osi and Hari Riid* are handicapping America, in the war on terror.
Heads of the political arm of Al Qaeda in America, the party known as *Al Demo Qrati*.
10
posted on
04/23/2007 1:09:59 PM PDT
by
syriacus
(Princeton's Peter Singer-"It's OK to kill flawed infants." Cho-"It's OK to kill flawed students.")
Disclaimer:
Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual
posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its
management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the
exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson