CNN Uses 'Anonymous Journalist' for Report on Shia Death Squads

NewsBusters ^ | Mark Finkelstein

[governsleastgovernsbest]

Next week marks the fourth anniversary of Operation Iraq Freedom. How does CNN plan to observe the event? An update, perhaps, on General Petraeus’ new strategy to win the war, and the initial positive – if still early – reports from the battlefield?

Please. I did say "CNN." The network is set to run a one hour special: “Death Squads Reveals Links between Shia Death Squads, Iraqi Security Forces.” CNN's report will in significant part be based on the work of an anonymous journalist.

Before considering the CNN report, let's review some of the recent developments in Iraq, as gleaned from MNF spokesman Maj. Gen. William Caldwell's press conference of March 14th:

• Prime Minister Maliki has affirmed that there will be no political interference in security operations. Iraq's leaders have lifted restrictions on Iraqi and Coalition forces that prevented them from going into certain areas, and U.S. and Iraqi troops are now pursuing the enemy in neighborhoods like Sadr City, where operations were once restricted.
• Iraqi and Coalition forces have secured significant sections of Sadr City without a shot fired in anger, an unimaginable achievement just months ago.
• About half of the planned joint security stations have been established in neighborhoods across Baghdad, helping coalition forces develop trust of local residents.
• Sectarian killings have been lower in Baghdad over the past several weeks than in the previous month.
• Sectarian displacement appears to have slowed or even stopped, with increasing numbers of families returning to their homes.

Other recent positive developments:

• More than 700 Shia radicals have been detained by Iraqi and Coalition forces in just the last 6 months.
• The PM and Minister of the Interior have fired or reassigned more than 10,000 personnel from the Iraqi Interior Ministry – people who were working subversively to stoke sectarian violence. http://www.azcentral.com/arizonarepublic/news/articles/0305iraq0305.html
• In Feb., Iraq’s Deputy Minister of Health was arrested by Iraqi security forces and Coalition forces – an action that would be been unthinkable a few months ago.

But if CNN's press release about its "Death Squads" report is any indication, the network doesn't plan to cover the progress that has been made in recent months in its special.

CNN's report also raises a journalistic issue. Its press release states that:

"Death Squads is a co-production of CNN and Channel 4/Quicksilver Media and is reported by a team of journalists: British journalist Deborah Davies, an Iraqi journalist working anonymously and CNN’s John Roberts."

We're all familiar with anonymous sources. But anonymous journalists? We can understand the personal security concerns. But as the only Iraqi on the team, Mr. X is likely the key to some of the more sensitive, and potentially controversial, allegations being reported. Doesn't his anonymity raise a serious credibility issue? Paging Howard Kurtz and Fox News Watch!

Mark was in Iraq in November. Contact him at mark@gunhill.net

[governsleastgovernsbest]

CNN-anonymous-journalist ping to Today show list.

[Army Air Corps]

Does one have to graduate from an anonymous university to become and anonymous journalist?

[ken5050]

Sounds to me like "Tail Wind", Part II

[padre35]

CNN is the same wing of terrorist media that asked Iraqi terrorists for the footage of American soldiers being shot.

I haven't watched CNN for years for a reason.

[P-40]

If that is CNN's standards these days that is sad...even for CNN.

[governsleastgovernsbest]

Unfortunately, for reasons of anonymity, I'm not permitted to answer your question ;-)

[Army Air Corps]

Okay, but are you covert?

[governsleastgovernsbest]

Anonymous and covert. Working, of course, at an undisclosed location ;-)

[Army Air Corps]

Wait, you admitted that you were covert! Who outed you?! We must have an investigation!

[syriacus]

CNN is the same wing of terrorist media that asked Iraqi terrorists for the footage of American soldiers being shot.

They wouldn't have fared too well under a Truman administration.
Full Wartime Censorship Placed on Korean War News, Waterloo Daily Courier, front page | January 9, 1951 | UP

Among other things, correspondents were placed under the jurisdiction of the Army and subject to courtmartial. Correspondents could not criticize the conduct of the war and could not send demoralizing dispatches. Correspondents could not quote officers or report casualties without authorization.

[TBP]

Did the Unknown Journalist wear a bag on his head?

[3niner]

It is obvious that there are a number of enemy journalists in Iraq. I would like to see our forces track them, to find terrorists.

If terrorists were attacked and a journalist or two killed in the process, I would think that most Americans would consider that acceptable collateral damage.