Posted on 08/24/2006 9:56:44 AM PDT by dukeman
REMEMBERING 9/11 FIVE YEARS LATER
SARASOTA COUNTY -- Five years ago, Tyler Radkey was one of 16 second-graders at Emma E. Booker Elementary School reading the book, "My Pet Goat," to the president of the United States.
Like his classmates, Tyler, then 7, didn't understand what was happening when Bush's face turned red, after an urgent whisper in his ear, and why he suddenly had to leave the room.
His first inclination was that Bush had to use the bathroom "really bad."
When they learned later that morning what had happened, the young students struggled to grasp the historical moment. Many had never heard of the World Trade Center.
But over the past five years, Tyler and his classmates have grown up and they now have a more mature understanding of Sept. 11.
With a crush of attention they have come to expect as another 9/11 anniversary approaches, the former Booker Elementary students were brought together by the school district Wednesday for interviews with the media, including the Herald-Tribune, the Associated Press, CNN and ABC.
The students reflected on events of five years ago and spoke of President Bush's leadership, the security of the nation and the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.
"I think about (the terrorist attacks) every day, and I don't think I should have to be scared walking around," said Byron Mitchell, who was a fifth-grader in the library when Bush addressed the nation on Sept. 11 and is now a high school sophomore.
Natalia Jones-Pinkney, who was selected to ask the President a question on Sept. 11, said if she had the opportunity again she would want to know: "Are we ever going to be safe again?"
"It doesn't feel safe all the time," said Natalia, now 12.
Tyler's views have changed as well. After he shook the president's hand, he said, he was impressed with Bush. But after years of watching the news coming out of Iraq and Afghanistan, Tyler has a different opinion.
"He can do a better job," said Tyler, now a seventh-grader at Booker Middle School. "Since he came (into office), there's been wars and people killed and other awful things. It's just not right."
Not all the students were critical of the president.
While Bush has been criticized for waiting nearly seven minutes to take charge after he was told the nation was under attack, students who were there defended his reaction.
"He did what he had to do," said Stevenson Tose-Rigell, who was in fifth grade and in the media center with Bush on 9/11. "You can't judge a man on seven minutes. It's not like he could get from Sarasota to New York City in seven minutes to save someone."
The footage of the President Bush continuing to read with students at Emma Booker Elementary after learning about the attacks was widely publicized in Michael Moore's film, "Farenheit 9/11." But some of the students haven't seen the film. Tyler said his parents don't want him to watch it, though he plans to see the movie when he's older. Teacher Sandra Daniels, who was leading the class, won't comment on Moore's film, but says she thinks Bush did the best he could that day under the circumstances.
Being a part of the historic day appears to have only slightly influenced the students' future aspirations.
Stevenson wants to be a entrepreneur, a musician or an athlete. He no longer strives to be a banker in New York City. Tyler would like to play football or work as a defense attorney; he's pretty certain he would never sign up for the military.
"I wouldn't risk my life for something dumb like a war," Tyler said.
The students and their families also seem to have a sense of pride about Booker Elementary's role in Sept. 11. Tyler's mother has a picture of him reading to Bush hanging on her bedroom wall. Stevenson has the picture of him siting behind the President in a safe place.
But the children struggle to understand their place in history and how a day that was supposed to be a celebration of their improved reading scores changed so quickly.
"I got to be a part of history," said Stevenson. "Not that it's a good thing, but it happened."
Yet it is a day that will probably connect the students forever, some say.
"I feel we are all bonded because we shared that experience," said Michael Andrews, 15, a sophomore at Booker High School. "We all have the same feeling -- why did this happen -- and that feeling will keep us together."
Their former second-grade teacher Daniels agrees.
"It's their life. They were there," Daniels said. "They are in the pictures with President Bush and on the news. They ought to be celebrated for their work in reading and what happened the rest of the day -- that's the part that hurts."
Make these kids watch United 93.
Do any of these kids have non-hyphenated last names?
Future FReepers of America.
This Tyler kid is shaping up to be a worthless punk if he doesn't get an attitude adjustment.
Cindy wannabe?
When I was eight my (since dehippified) parents asked me if I wanted to go to a disarmament rally in Central Park.
I asked them what it was about and they told me it was to get America and the Soviet Union to give up their nukes.
I told my folks that if we gave up our nukes, the Soviet Union would just lie about giving up their nukes and nuke us anyway, so I told them I didn't want to go.
I apparently was never a liberal.
Out of the mouthes of babes.
NO JUST ANOTHER PUNK WHO WILL BASK IN THE LIBERTIES & FREEDOMS PROVIDED THE UNGRATEFUL GRUNT BY THE PATRIOT, ALL THE WHILE QUESTIONING & CRITICICISING THE MANNER IN WHICH THESE FREEDOMS ARE PROVIDED. ANOTHER WORD FOR A liberal OR A pacifist!(oops sorry @ caps lock)
These kids are still quite young and it seems most of them don't have an appreciation of the price of freedom.
I hope many of us FReepers remember to get this message out of the story. These are children, and they deserve to be allowed to be children. In the days following 9/11, had you asked most children what they thought about it, they'd tell you that they wanted to know when cartoons would come back.
By the magic of television, at that moment, I saw our President continue reading to the children without batting an eye. At first I thought he was exhibiting extraordinary control, then I wondered if he just wasn't surprised, and now I think the camerawork with the news story lied to the viewers.
Age has almost nothing to do with the. The majority of Americans no longer has an appreciation of the price of freedom.
Good point! As a small boy I remember complaining about all the TV news coverage of JFK's assassination because it interfered with my cartoon viewing.
The conspiracy kooks and Bush haters say that Bush was just being told what he already knew was going to happen, that's why he didnt move right away.
The last poll I saw over on DU shows over 70% of the moonbats believe Bush either made 9/11 happen on purpose or let others do it by doing nothing to stop it. That is, indeed, stunning.
Good. We don't want him. Just sit back and watch the world's finest military save your arse, kid, whether you like it or not.
And before anyone goes off on "well, he's just a kid, and he has a right to say what he wants", I'll point out that at this rate, he will grow up, barring an intervention, into the same type of frothing leftist that we deal with everyday, the enemy within that must be defeated POLITICALLY; also, of course the kid can say what he wants, perhaps someday he'll realize that it's because people fought wars (which he calls "dumb") so that he could have and keep the right to speak freely; and yes, he has the right to speak. So the hell do I.
(btw, this is not a rant against you, dukeman. i just get rolling sometimes.)
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.