Liberals have their own Tar Baby references.
Posted on 05/17/2006 11:42:31 AM PDT by Caleb1411
A classic "Bloom County" cartoon of the 1980s has Opus the penguin sitting on a park bench watching a host of people pointing out things about each other that they find offensive, till they all realize, "Life is offensive!" At which point they all run off screaming in horror. Opus sums up the spectacle thus: "Offensensibility."
Offensensibility is something afflicting many in our society, and it's an especially volatile combination with cultural illiteracy. Just ask new White House Press Secretary Tony Snow. His first outing went well by many accounts; however, one thing he said set off the easily tripped alarms of the race-baiters of the American left. Snow was responding to a question about the surveillance issue, and he said:
"I don't want to hug the tar baby of trying to comment on the program — the alleged program — the existence of which I can neither confirm nor deny."
The race-baiters immediately set to work pretending to be outraged about Snow's use of the phrase "tar baby" and hoping it would, well, tar the White House with imputed racism. One group fortunate enough to be listed by Google News, styling itself "Think Progress" (they apparently left off "While Wishing to Oppress"), provides an excellent example of the attempt to gin up controversy; the comments are exemplary.
The problems with this issue are many:
One: The figure of the tar baby comes from American lore, as Snow even pointed out to one particularly ignorant press member who asked him to "put into English the phrase, 'hug the tar baby.'" In point of fact, it hails from African-American lore, the famous Brer Rabbit tales from which we've also kept "Don't throw me in that briar patch!" They're wonderful tales that impart object lessons with good humor and memorable imagery.
The tar baby was a trap devised by Brer Fox to catch Brer Rabbit, and once the rabbit got his paws on the tar baby, he was stuck. It was made of exceptionally sticky pitch, so the more Brer Rabbit tried to extricate himself from it, the more stuck in it he became. The tar baby became an apt metaphor for a situation that you can't get yourself out of once you get involved in it; the lesson is, don't get involved in it at all, stay away.
Two: Snow used the "tar baby" imagery explicitly with that object lesson in mind. Even if certain people have used the phrase "tar baby" as a racial slur, Snow certainly was not and should not be held accountable for others' misuse of a term that he knew well and used in the proper context. In this sense the "tar baby" issue is just like the "niggardly" controversies (a "Think Progress" poster made this point, although of course to mean Snow was just as "racist" as the persons who said "niggardly") in which people who used words in their proper contexts are punished for having small-minded ignoramuses in their audiences who didn't know those words and couldn't think of anything better than to misconstrue them in a racial context.
Three: By using African-American lore in a White House press corps briefing and expecting, however wrong he was, that the press would recognize it, Snow is legitimizing it — well, it is already legimitate; I mean signaling that it is legitimate Americana, suggesting it is something all Americans should know, recognizing its cultural importance. That is 180 degrees removed from the racist tinge the race-baiters wish to give it.
Four: Tony Snow has used this imagery before, as have numerous other opinion writers. Google the terms "Iraq" and "tar baby," for instance; you'll find the proper, contextual use of the phrase spanning the range of American political opinion (over 53,000 hits, too).
Five: Finally, doesn't it seem a rather small-minded, racist way of thinking to equate "tar baby" with a smear against blacks since tar is, you know, so black? That's as stupid as suggesting the term "sugar daddy" ought to be regarded a smear against whites, since refined sugar is so white.
Some people wake up offended that the sun came up again..........
Years ago Chevy Chase and Garrett Morris had a very funny SNL skit in which they lobbed ever more outrageous racial epithets at one another in the context of a pscyhological word-association game. Perhaps these reporters could benefit from seeing it.
You would think they would be ashamed to reveal their ignorance of American literature. We read these stories in grammar school.
It was Chevy Chase and Richard Prior.
Snow is just smarter than them that all. :)
sorry
Prior=Pryor
http://media.putfile.com/SNL---Richard-Pryor-Chevy-Chase-FUNNY
and they use "tar baby"
And I am laughing right now as you reminded me of that. (Dead honkey!)
That was, indeed, very funny.
Tony Tony Tony. First off, just because these people are in the WH Press Corps, don't expect them to be either well read or understanding. Any such use of any such word that even sounds bigoted will be picked up upon and heralded as proof of racism, even when it's obvious it wasn't meant in such a manner. And please remember: these people now hate you. They're not just jealous of your successes, or irritated that that a journalist took this job, they hate this White House, and any such Spokesman in particular.
Pryor, Morris... should I say it?
so long as you don't mind offending people. Though they did have similar hair styles.
Because, it should be all too obvious to any thinking person in this day and age that the use of "tar baby" by a Republican is going to bring out the liberal race baiters.
For the record, the word in Bloom County was "Offensensitivity".
And "I'm offended at your offendedness"!!! ;-P
Liberals have their own Tar Baby references.
It wasn't an issue when Dan Rather used the phrase "tar baby" in an interview with Rumsfeld from 2 years ago:
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2003/09/05/eveningnews/main571901.shtml
Rather: Mr. Secretary, just this week there have been quotes in the paper, rank and file Americans, saying are we into a tar baby situation? Are we into quick sand? Is this going to be another quagmire? This is the way people talk around coffee in the morning. I want to give you an opportunity to respond to those deep concerns.
Is that the one with "DEAD Honkey"?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.