Posted on 05/12/2006 5:37:44 PM PDT by Jedi Master Pikachu
American society has often been described as a melting pot but in recent years, it has also attracted other definitions such as "tomato soup" and "tossed salad".
For centuries, the US has attracted people in search of a share of "the American dream" from all corners of the world.
In fact, US history is one of immigration.
In 1620, about 100 English colonists, so-called "Mayflower Pilgrims" left for America seeking religious freedom.
They landed near Plymouth, Massachusetts, marking the start of the first successful European migration to North America, which had been inhabited by Amerindian people for more than 16,000 years.
The immigration flow to the US first accelerated after the French Revolution, and during the 19th century, population pressure, fragmentation of land in rural Europe and famines drove millions of Europeans to the New World.
Throughout the 19th and 20th Centuries, American ports teemed with German, Chinese, Irish, Italian, and Polish immigrants.
Until 1882, the US government practised an open door immigration policy, but at the end of the century, it began trying to control immigration by excluding prostitutes, criminals, alcoholics, and Chinese, among others, from coming to the country.
Fortress America?
During the 20th Century, the US government kept fine-tuning its immigration policies.
A group of immigrants arriving at Ellis Island in New York Some 16m people passed through Ellis Island from 1892 to 1924
Under the national origins quota system, established in 1921, admission to the US largely depended upon an immigrant's country of birth.
Seventy percent of all immigrant slots were allotted to citizens of just three countries: UK, Ireland and Germany.
But these went mostly unused, while there were long waiting lists for the small number of visas available to those born in eastern and southern Europe.
In 1965, the nationality quotas were abolished, which is seen to have inaugurated a new era of mass immigration, particularly from Mexico and Latin America.
In an effort to curb illegal immigration, in 1996 Congress passed legislation which marked a turn towards tougher policies for both legal and illegal immigrants.
It increased the categories of criminal activity for which immigrants, including green card holders, could be deported, and imposed mandatory detention.
As a result, more than one million individuals have been deported since 1996.
While critics of illegal immigration are pushing for even tougher laws, mass demonstrations across the US have shown that such a strategy will not be accepted by a large section of the population.
The immigrants' campaign groups argue that a country built by immigrants will fail to function without them.
Melting pot
Americans take pride in their "melting pot" society (a term coined by an immigrant, Israel Zangwill) that encourages newcomers to assimilate into the American culture.
But the melting pot imagery has been contested by the idea of multiculturalism, the "salad bowl theory", or as it is known in Canada, the "cultural mosaic", whereby the immigrants retain their own national characteristics while integrating into a new society.
Some go further. Harvard political scientist Samuel Huntington says that large-scale Latino immigration poses a threat to American identity.
Mexican Americans feel increasingly comfortable with their own culture and often contemptuous of American culture Samuel Huntington According to Professor Huntington the reality of American history is best described as tomato soup: the blending of new ingredients adds spice without compromising the essential character of tomato.
"Contributions from immigrant cultures modified and enriched Anglo-Protestant culture of founding settlers.
"The essentials of that founding culture remained the bedrock of the US identity, however, at least until the last decades of the 20th Century," Mr Huntington writes in his controversial 2004 book Who Are We. The Challenges to America's National Identity.
He sees the gravest threat to American identity in Mexican immigration which, according to him, is splitting America in two.
"As their numbers increase, Mexican Americans feel increasingly comfortable with their own culture and often contemptuous of American culture", he says.
Sense of history
But are the Mexican-dominant areas of the US really consolidating themselves into a culturally and linguistically distinct and economically self-reliant bloc within the US, as Professor Huntington states?
Immigrants come and change America and are changed by America Douglas Rivelin Douglas Rivelin from the National Immigration Forum contests Mr Huntington's view of Latinos as different from other immigrant groups.
"I was astounded that someone so smart could write such a book," he says.
"He is totally missing what is going on in the US. The same thing could have been written in 1924 about Irish or other immigrants, and it would have been equally wrong."
"Bagels and pizzas and spaghetti were new things at one time... immigrants come and change America and are changed by America."
And well they should it is shameful that they are ready to give up their identity,citizenship and culture for a few bucks. Shame on them!! And to insist on citizenship even tho they really don't care about it is unfair to us. This is not a healthy environment for anyone so deport all of them!
Yes, it appears on the surface that most illegals are here for the economic benefit and are not interested in either being legal or deserting their own country which allows them to live quite nicely after working here for a number of years.
Tacos, enchiladas and burrtos are good too. But they need to be LEGAL!
True, but too many cooks spoil the broth.
We have never been a melting pot. Blacks, American Indians, and Mexican-Americans remain distinct racial groups. Until recently, even WHITE people were segregated (Anglo, Italian, Jewish). The whole "melting pot" concept was socialist anyway ("all united in the class struggle) and an INVENTION of early 20th century propaganda.
I'll disagree with this. Speaking from Los Angeles I can say many, maybe most LEGAL Mexican assimilate very well. I see them literally everyday in their souped up expensive custom pickup trucks at Best Buy buying a big flat screen TV.
ILLEGALS gon't assimilate.
How about we get rid of just the ones who refuse to assimilate then?
Respectfully, you can't make comments about all Mexican Americans. As such, your comment is wrong. There are usually exceptions to the rule.
Your comment on how immigrants should be legal is correct.
Some one should remind the BBC that you don't really become an American till your willing to shoot a few old country blood cousin's, in defense of your new "new country-Melting pot" brother American's........The BBC of the 21 Century just seem to remind me of that fact
The concept of there being races of humans (in the modern sense of race) is a socio-cultural construct, not strongly based upon science or genetics. Americans can be simply Americans. Some can be of a dark complexion with a tight, curly 'fro; some can be of a pale complexion with round eyes; some can have slanted eyes, etc. There CAN be one American race (using the old sense of race as nationality or ethnicity (grouping people based on a common culture)).
Note Mexican immigrants, not illegal aliens. immigrants are taken to be legal.
as if things were that easy. Having protesters wave around American flags suggests that at least some are willing to mislead.
This article doesn't really say anything.
Re: 12 you are absolutely correct. Just as there can be an AMERICAN Civilization (Teddy Roosevelt thought that there was).
About this comment 16, agreed. There is an American Civilization, and it should be protected.
You called me a liar, what exactly am I lying about?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.