Machine needed one of these.
Posted on 03/20/2006 8:26:10 PM PST by saquin
A baby boy died after an untrained doctor pressed the wrong button on his bypass machine because it was a less "horrid" colour than the other, an inquest heard yesterday.
Four-month-old Thomas Smith was on a heart and lung bypass machine when Simon McGuirk, a cardiac surgical registrar, accidentally turned it off.
Mr McGuirk said that he did not know whether to press the orange or blue buttons to restart the machine, so opted for the blue. It sent the machine into reverse, sucking blood from Thomas's body. He died a short time later.
The inquest heard that Thomas had been admitted to Birmingham Children's Hospital for an operation to cure two holes in his heart.
The operation was a success but a ventilator he was on stopped working, he suffered a heart attack and was switched to the bypass machine.
Mr McGuirk told Birmingham coroner's court that he was cleaning up some blood that he had spilt on the machine when he accidentally lifted the lid and it stopped working.
He said that he had been holding a metal line clamp at the time and that this may have interfered with a magnetic clasp keeping the lid shut. "I don't know how or why [it happened]," he said.
"It was thought it might have been the metal clamp causing the loss of magnetism or me lifting it without my knowing."
He said that Thomas's blood pressure had dropped the moment that the machine stopped and that, as soon as this happened, he called for help.
Once resuscitation measures were in place, Mr McGuirk said that a nurse had telephoned a member of staff who knew how to restart the machine and relayed instructions to him.
Mr McGuirk said that there were two sets of coloured buttons on the machine, one blue, one orange. "I was indicated to press two buttons at the same time to restart the machine," he said.
"She didn't know which colour they were. In view of that I went for two blue which I thought was a less horrid colour than the orange."
Mr McGuirk said that this had sucked blood from Thomas instead of sending it to him and that he had immediately switched the machine off.
"I should have pressed the two orange buttons, which would have pushed the blood from the circuit to Thomas," he said.
"In deciding which set of buttons I was meant to press I took a stab in the dark. It was a 50-50 chance."
Mr McGuirk said that it had been an error on his part for which he took full responsibility but that Thomas had not suffered any damage as a result.
The baby's mother, Lisa Weale, 35, from Longbridge, Birmingham, said that after the bypass incident she was told that the duty doctor was not qualified to monitor the machine. She was further told that the hospital did not have the resources to ensure there was always somebody on duty who was.
"[The doctor] was unaware how to use the machinery, as were most of the team," she said.
The inquest continues.
More beauties of socialized medicine.
Machine needed one of these.
I wonder if his teachers graded his papers with purple or green markers?
God bless the poor parents of this child. I'm not sure it's fair to blame socialized medicine for this....there are idiots in all countries. Let's all say a prayer for Little Thomas and his parents.
The story is a bit convoluted and twisted but it begs the question - "where was the perfusionist?".
Seems like old Simon really stepped in it - but in a sense it wasn't his fault - there should have been a perfusionist present.
Mr McGuirk said that it had been an error on his part for which he took full responsibility but that Thomas had not suffered any damage as a result.
Did the kid die? or not?
Perhaps, but if he wasn't sure what he was doing, couldn't he take a peek at the manual?
Yup. you said first
IIRC, similarly bad user interfaces led to the accident at Three Mile Island.
Why didn't the equipment say something clever like "on", "off", or "power"? Reminds me of the Simpsons episode where Homer has to save the town and he uses inny-minny to pick the right button.
So-called international, all-language buttons drive me crazy. Your computer, your snowblower, your lawnmower, your weedwhacker, your x-ray machine. None of them have buttons that say "on" or "off" any more, because that might confuse a Hispanic and it would mean that you would have to put different buttons on your machines if you sell them in different countries.
All very well, but if you need to hit a button in a hurry, there's no instinctive recognition which one is which. Labeling them "On" and "Off" might seem to make more sense, but evidently that would cost export manufacturers more, and offend the language police.
ROTFL!!
"I went for two blue which I thought was a less horrid colour than the orange."
...this had sucked blood from Thomas instead of sending it to him
"I should have pressed the two orange buttons, which would have pushed the blood from the circuit to Thomas
The logical choice would have been orange, which one would associate with an influx of blood. But McGuirk's decision making process seems to be based on what would look good with his shirt.
Umm, don't see me as a wet blanket here... but a dead child resulting from an LCD approach to medicine is not a laughing matter.
The point here is that lowered expectations result in lowered results. In health care, lowered results are death.
Feel free to flame away.
Bump!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.