Posted on 10/21/2005 11:17:02 AM PDT by Tolik
Summary: During Richard Nixon's first term, when I served as secretary of defense, we withdrew most U.S. forces from Vietnam while building up the South's ability to defend itself. The result was a success -- until Congress snatched defeat from the jaws of victory by cutting off funding for our ally in 1975. Washington should follow a similar strategy now, but this time finish the job properly.
[CHAPTERS]:
SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT
...The war in Iraq is not "another Vietnam." But it could become one if we continue to use Vietnam as a sound bite while ignoring its true lessons.
...It is time for a reasonable look at both Vietnam and Iraq -- and at what the former can teach us about the latter...
STAYING THE COURSE
VIETNAMIZATION AS THE MODEL
THE PRETEXT FOR WAR
MARKETING THE MISSION
BUILDING A LEGITIMATE GOVERNMENT
INSURGENTS AS ENEMIES
LIMITED WARFARE
AT WHAT COST?
SHORING UP OUR ALLIES
...In Vietnam, the voices of the "cut-and-run" crowd ultimately prevailed, and our allies were betrayed after all of our work to set them on their feet. Those same voices would now have us cut and run from Iraq, assuring the failure of the fledgling democracy there and damning the rest of the Islamic world to chaos fomented by extremists. ...They forget the immediate costs of the United States' betrayal. Two million refugees were driven out of the country, 65,000 more were executed, and 250,000 were sent to "reeducation camps." Given the nature of the insurgents in Iraq and the catastrophic goals of militant Islam, we can expect no better there.
...if we fail now, a new standard will have been set. The lessons of Vietnam will be forgotten, and our next global mission will be saddled with the fear of its becoming "another Iraq."...
(Excerpt) Read more at foreignaffairs.org ...
...The president must articulate a simple message and mission. Just as the spread of communism was very real in the 1960s, so the spread of radical fundamentalist Islam is very real today. It was a creeping fear until September 11, 2001, when it showed itself capable of threatening us. Iraq was a logical place to fight back, with its secular government and modern infrastructure and a populace that was ready to overthrow its dictator. Our troops are not fighting there only to preserve the right of Iraqis to vote. They are fighting to preserve modern culture, Western democracy, the global economy, and all else that is threatened by the spread of barbarism in the name of religion. That is the message and the mission. It is not politically correct, nor is it comforting. But it is the truth, and sometimes the truth needs good marketing. ...
Print ready format The foreignaffairs.org is a MUST EXCERPT website :^(
A long one for your weekend reading
This ping list is not author-specific for articles I'd like to share. Some for the perfect moral clarity, some for provocative thoughts; or simply interesting articles I'd hate to miss myself. (I don't have to agree with the author all 100% to feel the need to share an article.) I will try not to abuse the ping list and not to annoy you too much, but on some days there is more of the good stuff that is worthy of attention. You can see the list of articles I pinged to lately on my page.
You are welcome in or out, just freepmail me (and note which PING list you are talking about). Besides this one, I keep 2 separate PING lists for my favorite authors Victor Davis Hanson and Orson Scott Card.
Didn't know Laird was still around. Good points. We let the idiots control our nam policy in the end, bad move for everyone.....well....except the north vietnamese.
Makes you wonder what side they were on.
Mel Laird took over a Pentagon that was racked by 8 years of mis-management by then 'wiz-kid' Robert McNamara who has been apologizing for US power since.
Laird is still alive?!! He must be in his 90's by now!
I want to be as clear minded in my 90's...
It was also the appeasers who were and have been "emboldened".
It's unbelievable that for the second time in a half century, I have to watch THE SAME PEOPLE try to destroy this country, THE SAME WAY they did 35 years ago.
They don't forget. They don't care. Their side was the one doing the driving out, executing and reeducating.
Laird is just jealous that he did not get a fat communist beer contract like McCain and his daddy in law got.
All the President has to do is fight the battle at home for Iraq. This is where the real Iraq war is being fought , for the hearts and minds of America.
Why are we in Iraq? The people need to know that this war is every bit as long term as the Cold War. The people also need to know why that is, because many Dems have not figured it out, having opted to follow the path of the knee jerk invoking liberal mass media.
We are preventing the rise of Shiites to national power across the belt of the world, from Ankara to Istanbul. Can you imagine an axis of nations run by Islamofascists , ready to gut the soft underbelly of Europe ( already started), with nuclear arms and control of the worlds oil supply?
The Prez needs to deliver that message BIG TIME.
Enough posing for the PC Liberals in America, who occupy both parties. The strategic case needs to be made, and we need to fight the battle at home that WAS NOT fought during the Viet Nam War...and we need to win it at ALL costs.
I think that the Pentagon is doing a lousy job of PR. For every casualty there are 98,000 success stories we never hear. I watvched gen Myers testify before a senate committee where Johjn McCain ws angrily asserting his superior knowledge. I looked at it and thought, which one is the real hero, the one who got shot down or the one who became join chief? If we do not celebrate the true heros then guys like McCain and Kerry can continue to claim to be heros when threy bail out ofter 4 months.
And now you want to do it again in Iraq and the middle east...
His son was at the same school as my brother so I wouldn't think he'd be that terribly old?
I just Googled, Melvin Laird was born in '22.
The Prez needs to deliver that message BIG TIME.
**
You are so right. But it must be so hard for him to try to get the message out through the MSM filter.
My homeboy grandpa's neighbor..
Too bad his Vietnam War protestor niece had to marry
the Vietnam War Protestor we now have in the Governor's mansion though...
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.