Posted on 09/25/2005 9:26:09 AM PDT by Heartofsong83
Linda McQuaig argues that proposed $7 billion in tax cuts would be better spent on 250,000 homeless
LINDA MCQUAIG
An amazing thing happened last spring. Fearing it was about to be toppled, the minority Liberal government of Paul Martin gave in to NDP leader Jack Layton's demand that almost $5 billion in corporate tax cuts be cancelled and the money spent instead on things Canadians desperately want — including housing, public transit and the environment. And the country didn't collapse.
Economist Mike McCracken notes that the $5 billion in corporate tax cuts would have mainly ended up in the coffers of the big banks and the oil and gas companies, the ones reaping huge windfall profits these days as world energy prices soar.
Somehow these companies have managed to struggle by without those extra billions from Canadian taxpayers.
That's an important lesson for us; it suggests we could go further down this path.
Since the federal government started generating surpluses in 1998, it has been absolutely awash in cash — a fact played down by government and business commentators, lest ordinary Canadians get a glimmer of what could be achieved if the money were put to some real national purpose, like rebuilding the social and physical infrastructure of the country.
Instead, between 1998 and 2003, about $152 billion of the surplus went to tax cuts, and $61 billion went to debt reduction, for a total of $213 billion.
That utterly dwarfs the roughly $40 billion of the surplus that went to increased social spending, notes Armine Yalnizyan, an economist with the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives in Ottawa.
This amounts to a lot of squandered opportunities.
Here's just one example. As part of its tax-cutting, Ottawa plans to raise the threshold at which income tax applies, from $8,000 to $10,000.
Most tax cuts benefit the well-to-do, but this measure was touted as benefiting the 5 million Canadians earning less than $10,000 a year.
Yet almost none of these people pay any income tax, so they will receive no benefit from the measure.
The measure will, however, cost the government about $7 billion, because it means all taxpayers will pay slightly less tax. Next year, for instance, each taxpayer will save $16 — enough for a large pizza, notes Yalnizyan.
There's nothing wrong with a large pizza. I'd like one myself. But I'd happily forgo it, if Ottawa would instead put some of that $7 billion into, say, a national housing program, so that the 250,000 Canadians currently homeless or almost homeless would have a secure place to raise their children.
That, in the long run, would make a bigger difference to all of our lives than even a large pizza.
Meanwhile, the Liberal government plans to reintroduce those $5 billion corporate tax cuts.
The NDP should serve notice that if the Liberals do this, they better prepare to head out on the hustings soon with a good explanation for why there's a pressing need to hand over such a large chunk of our hard-earned surplus to the banks and the big oil companies.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Linda McQuaig is a Toronto-based author and commentator. lmcquaig@sympatico.ca.
They think they have a right to your paycheck, and then they act this way when we fight to keep it.
(Denny Crane: "Sometimes you can only look for answers from God and failing that... and Fox News".)
She's a card-carrying NDP member.
As a fellow Canadian, I can only urge you to stop reading the Red Star!
It's crazy-making enough up here.
How can someone be "almost" homeless?
If you gave each one of them a place to live, they'd tear them up in a week.
I put that here just for us to barf!
RE: "And the country didn't collapse."
This writer sounds disappointed. Just give the socialists enough time and other peoples money dear and it will come.
tell ya what linda...you and YOUR ILK give up your tax cuts. We'll keep ours you Idiot you.
Good Lord she's a scary looking creature. I know it's a cartoon but my Lord....it's close...too close.
Good Lord she's a scary looking creature. I know it's a cartoon but my Lord....it's close...too close.
This little item gleaned in fact from a Toronto newspaper and I am almost certain it was Linda's rag. A profile was done on Toronto's famous/infamous Seaton House. It is a refuge for the night for "the homeless". It has been stated that some poor souls would rather freeze than go there. Such is the awful goings on within.
The nick name by it's denizens for certain of their peers are the "million dollar men". These are men who are a constant drain on resources- vis ambulances,police attendances, hospital, detox and counselling.
Two men in their late thirties cost between them in- I think in two years, $371,000 in resources used up. An idea was floated to buy a farm in New Brunswick for them. I do not know if this happened though. One man liked the idea. Roughly quoted."You know, I could quite like going back to NB where I was born. I could see myself getting back to the land. I could see myself being set right".
The figures will check out- For two men? Ah lovely Linda. You are a soldier in the trenches of compassion. You do not care probably, about the whole mess of 'em. Linda, it is a bottomless pit.
This little item gleaned in fact from a Toronto newspaper and I am almost certain it was Linda's rag. A profile was done on Toronto's famous/infamous Seaton House. It is a refuge for the night for "the homeless". It has been stated that some poor souls would rather freeze than go there. Such is the awful goings on within.
The nick name by it's denizens for certain of their peers are the "million dollar men". These are men who are a constant drain on resources- vis ambulances,police attendances, hospital, detox and counselling.
Two men in their late thirties cost between them in- I think in two years, $371,000 in resources used up. An idea was floated to buy a farm in New Brunswick for them. I do not know if this happened though. One man liked the idea. Roughly quoted."You know, I could quite like going back to NB where I was born. I could see myself getting back to the land. I could see myself being set right".
The figures will check out- For two men? Ah lovely Linda. You are a soldier in the trenches of compassion. You do not care probably, about the whole mess of 'em. Linda, it is a bottomless pit.
Double post- sorry, but sure I hit it right. Needed to wait longer to refresh.
Our great society is a cesspool full of lazy, brain-neutered numbskulls.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.