Posted on 09/20/2005 6:41:34 AM PDT by ValerieUSA
Coffee cups featuring a quote by a gay author about growing up homosexual have been pulled from Baylor University's on-campus Starbucks.
Aramark, which as the contractor for Baylor dining services oversees the coffee outlet, pulled cups from the campus store earlier this month after a university staff member sent out an e-mail complaining about the appropriateness of the quote at a Baptist university, Baylor officials said.
The e-mail was sent on to Baylor dining services, which consulted with Starbucks' district office, which said it fully supported a decision to take the cup out of circulation to avoid offending others, Baylor officials said Monday.
“My understanding is it was a decision made by Baylor dining services staff, and I've not yet been able to trace it back to any Baylor administrators telling them point-blank to pull the cup,” Baylor spokesman Larry Brumley said.
He added, “I think they were trying to be sensitive. Obviously, Baylor is a Baptist-affiliated institution, and Baptists as a denomination have been pretty outspoken on the record about the denomination's views about the homosexual lifestyle.”
The action was spurred by the fact that some of the store's coffee cups contained a quote from novelist Armistead Maupin. He is best known for a six-book series titled Tales of the City, which is about life in San Francisco in the 1970s and 1980s.
The quote on the cup reads:
“My only regret about being gay is that I repressed it for so long. I surrendered my youth to the people I feared when I could have been out there loving someone. Don't make that mistake yourself. Life's too damn short.”
The cup is No. 43 in a series of cups being used chainwide by the Seattle-based coffee giant. The cups are part of a campaign called “The Way I See It,” which features quotes from a variety of notable figures. They range from the musings of electronic musician Moby to the thoughts of figure skater Michelle Kwan.
Sanja Gould, a spokeswoman with Starbucks' corporate office, said the company sees the program “as an extension of the coffeehouse culture – a way to promote open, respectful conversation among a wide variety of individuals.”
Gould said cups with the Maupin quote has been in circulation since July. She said the cups were placed randomly in the cases shipped to the store, and store employees would have to remove the cups manually.
“As far as I know, there weren't many of the cups,” Gould said.
Officials at other Waco-area Starbucks said they are still using the cups.
Linda Ricks, marketing program manager for Baylor Dining Services, said she could not comment on the cups, and referred calls to Aramark's corporate offices, which could not be reached for comment Monday.
At least one other group has expressed its dissatisfaction with the Maupin cup.
Concerned Women for America, a national Christian women's organization, says Starbucks is promoting a homosexual agenda with the cup. The group also has expressed concern about the campaign as a whole, saying most of the quotes are liberal, according to a report in the Seattle Times.
Members of the local gay community said they are disappointed by the cups' removal.
Cade Hammond, president of the board of directors for the Gay and Lesbian Alliance of Central Texas, said he sees pulling the cups as unnecessarily restrictive. He said the situation reminds him of people who burn books because they don't like what they say.
“You can't restrict information like that,” Hammond said. “It just seems a little backwards.”
Valerie Fallas, president of the Waco chapter of Parents, Families and Friends of Lesbians and Gays, called the action “unnecessary.”
“It's a shame that anybody would do this,” Fallas said. “Whatever you feel, whatever you think about something, discussion is the number one thing to do to educate yourself on an issue.”
Just in case
CLARIFICATION:
I am NOT Valerie Fallas
Probably something about doing precisely the same routine over and over for years as if it were something new and expecting the world to give you the highest award for ingenuity.
Isn't it tragic that here in the United States, students can still CHOOSE to attend a private religious university with specific standards rather than an anything-goes public institution?
Baylor is a private Christian college.
This is the date that the local Waco newspaper carried the story.
oh yes, I know that! LOL
And that is a good reason to think that keeping this particular cup from the hands of the students is a desirable thing?
I'm sorry, I'm not a big fan of this type of restriction, these kids see messages like that every day, and it would be far better for the college to educate the students as to how to recognise invalid or useless statements, than it is to simply pretend you can keep them from hearing them.
It wasn't a question of what the college was allowed to do, I was saying that this was not the right way to handle the issue.
BTW, it doesn't help those who want to argue that the words "Under God" in the pledge should remain because they are just words and people who are offended by them should tolerate the rest of us.
"What dessert did Burger King pull? I hadn't heard about this."
Related thread here:
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1487030/posts
As to the quotes on the cups, I get one of the sleeves to keep from burning my hand, so I don't see the quotes without going out of my way.
Pumpkin spice lattes rock! Starbucks is like the Borg, though. they receive a corporate directive to run seasonal specials and even coffee of the day. All those around me are running with French roast this week. Bleh.
They can see those messages off campus. It wasn't the school that made the decision but the dining services contractors. They made the decision simply on the reality of who pays the bills. It was a free market decision on their part.
Sometimes it's nice to go somewhere where you can get away from the constant crap thrown back in your face. Since this is a private Christian school they don't have to allow a pro gay agenda company if they don't want to. That is the beauty of not attending a public state university.
I usually just order coffee of the day. Straight.
I'm sure I've seen one of those G.O.D. trucks within the last few months. Not as common as they used to be though.
There was a thread on this a few days ago.
"Philosophy.....is the talk on a cereal box [coffee cup.]"
It's PRIVATE University. They can do what they want...AND I'm proud to say that I'm a former Baylor Bear that agrees with this decision.
Glad to hear that Medved is included. Then again, even NPR has one conservative commentator. I'd still be willing to bet that liberals outweigh conservatives mightily among the coffee cup philosophers.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.