Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Roberts Is Pressed on End-of-Life Care
NY Times ^ | 8/10/05 | Sheryl Gay Stolberg

Posted on 08/09/2005 10:16:10 PM PDT by Crackingham

Terri Schiavo, the brain-damaged Florida woman whose case provoked Congressional action and a national debate over end-of-life care, became an issue on Tuesday in the Supreme Court confirmation of Judge John G. Roberts Jr. when a Democratic senator pressed him about whether lawmakers should have intervened.

The senator, Ron Wyden of Oregon, said that Judge Roberts, while not addressing the Schiavo case specifically, made clear he was displeased with Congress's effort to force the federal judiciary to overturn a court order withdrawing her feeding tube.

"I asked whether it was constitutional for Congress to intervene in an end-of-life case with a specific remedy," Mr. Wyden said in a telephone interview after the hourlong meeting. "His answer was, 'I am concerned with judicial independence. Congress can prescribe standards, but when Congress starts to act like a court and prescribe particular remedies in particular cases, Congress has overstepped its bounds.' "

The answer, which Mr. Wyden said his aides wrote down word-for-word, would seem to put Judge Roberts at odds with leading Republicans in Congress, including the Senate majority leader, Bill Frist, and the House majority leader, Representative Tom DeLay, who both led the charge for Congressional intervention in the Schiavo case this spring. Mr. DeLay said at the time that the federal judiciary had "run amok."

SNIP

Mr. Wyden said that he asked Judge Roberts whether he believed states should take the lead in regulating medical practice, and that the nominee replied that "uniformity across the country would stifle the genius of the founding fathers."

Mr. Wyden said, "I came away with the sense that he was somewhat sympathetic to my notion that there should be a wide berth for states to take the lead."

(Excerpt) Read more at nytimes.com ...


TOPICS: Constitution/Conservatism; Culture/Society; Government; News/Current Events; Philosophy
KEYWORDS: 109th; johnroberts; roberts; ronwyden; schiavo; scotus
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021-34 next last

1 posted on 08/09/2005 10:16:10 PM PDT by Crackingham
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: Crackingham

Please consider the source FReepers before you dislocate your knees.


2 posted on 08/09/2005 10:17:36 PM PDT by Extremely Extreme Extremist
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Extremely Extreme Extremist
Please consider the source FReepers before you dislocate your knees. You got it! Crackhead is flooding the site with post like this!
3 posted on 08/09/2005 10:27:46 PM PDT by F-117A
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: Howlin; Miss Marple; PhiKapMom

Slimes trolling through the city dumpsters again.


4 posted on 08/09/2005 10:30:19 PM PDT by Extremely Extreme Extremist
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: F-117A
Yup, methinks Crackhead is a previously banned FReeper
5 posted on 08/09/2005 10:31:55 PM PDT by MJY1288 (Whenever a Liberal is Speaking on the Senate Floor, Al-Jazeera Breaks in and Covers it LIVE)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: Crackingham
"Mr. Wyden said that he asked Judge Roberts whether he believed states should take the lead in regulating medical practice, and that the nominee replied that "uniformity across the country would stifle the genius of the founding fathers."

So he's a federalist? Maybe a vote to overturn Raich-Wickard? And this is bad?
6 posted on 08/09/2005 10:39:46 PM PDT by U.H. Conservative (http://unhyphenatedconservative.blogspot.com/)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Extremely Extreme Extremist
"His answer was, 'I am concerned with judicial independence. Congress can prescribe standards, but when Congress starts to act like a court and prescribe particular remedies in particular cases, Congress has overstepped its bounds.' "

Good thing Congress didn't do that in the Schiavo matter; instead Congress legislated a de novo review in federal court under the exigent circumstances of starving her to death.

I've already read the tea leaves with Roberts and all systems remain go.

7 posted on 08/09/2005 10:41:39 PM PDT by Kryptonite
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: Crackingham
"His answer was, 'I am concerned with judicial independence. Congress can prescribe standards, but when Congress starts to act like a court and prescribe particular remedies in particular cases, Congress has overstepped its bounds.' "

Too bad some 'Freepers' will disagree with this, but a healthy respect for the separation of powers elevates the nominee in my estimation.

8 posted on 08/09/2005 10:42:36 PM PDT by cryptical
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: U.H. Conservative
Mark Levin, Ted Olsen and Robert Bork all say he is an originalist, Their opinions mean much more to me than ANYTHING the NYT's has to offer about Justice Roberts.

Seminar posters who flood this site with this Liberal tripe, like the one who posted this thread, will not succeed

9 posted on 08/09/2005 10:44:55 PM PDT by MJY1288 (Whenever a Liberal is Speaking on the Senate Floor, Al-Jazeera Breaks in and Covers it LIVE)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 6 | View Replies]

To: Crackingham
Mr. Wyden said, "I came away with the sense that he was somewhat sympathetic to my notion that there should be a wide berth for states to take the lead."

If there is a silver lining to the cloud, it would be that Roberts would not be sympathetic to Uncle Sam forcing a permissive euthanasia policy nationwide. That a state could exist that does not have such a permissive policy and one could go live there if one does not want to chance dying in a state with a permissive policy.

10 posted on 08/09/2005 10:46:41 PM PDT by HiTech RedNeck (No wonder the Southern Baptist Church threw Greer out: Only one god per church! [Ann Coulter])
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Extremely Extreme Extremist

Apparently it was a closed meeting between Wyden and Roberts, so who knows what was said exactly.

Wyden meets with Supreme Court nominee Roberts

http://www.kgw.com/sharedcontent/APStories/stories/D8BSJMHG0.html

Wyden, a Democrat, met with Roberts for nearly an hour Tuesday at Wyden's Senate office.

The meeting was closed, but Wyden said later that he asked Roberts about Schiavo,

Wyden, who is undecided on Roberts' nomination, said Roberts told him he could not comment on the Schiavo case directly.

But Roberts did answer when Wyden asked if he thought it was constitutional for Congress to intervene in an end-of-life-case with a specific remedy. In the Schiavo case, many lawmakers advocated reinserting a feeding tube to help her live.

Roberts told Wyden he was concerned with judicial independence. Congress can prescribe standards, Roberts added, "but when Congress starts to act like a court and prescribe particular remedies in particular cases, Congress has overstepped its bounds."

Wyden said he considered the answer significant, "because the question I was asking has applicability" to the Schiavo case.

Offering a remedy "is what Congress was doing in the original version of the Schiavo bill," Wyden said, adding that Roberts "would not look favorably on Congress rushing to override the right to be left alone."

====


11 posted on 08/09/2005 10:47:00 PM PDT by FairOpinion
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: Extremely Extreme Extremist
"I asked whether it was constitutional for Congress to intervene in an end-of-life case with a specific remedy," Mr. Wyden said in a telephone interview after the hourlong meeting. "His answer was, 'I am concerned with judicial independence. Congress can prescribe standards, but when Congress starts to act like a court and prescribe particular remedies in particular cases, Congress has overstepped its bounds.' "

Roberts effectively side stepped the question.

His answer was 100% correct.

In regards to the Schiavo case, Congress only required that other judges review the case. Congress did not mandate a specific decision. It only hoped that the judges would perform their due diligence and examine the case to ensure that real justice and not formulaic justice was served on Shiavo's behalf.

It was properly within the scope of Congress to ask for such a review, just as it was properly within the scope of the courts to perform the review as they saw fit, and to decide as they saw fit.

The independence of the court was maintained. The balance of powers worked as designed.

It is sad that common sense did not prevail. That the husband no longer had a vested interest in keeping her alive, and should've divested himself of the guardianship. That Terri's wishes were not clear. That if Terri was not in a persistant vegetative state, then to allow her to die would've been murder. Or, that if she was in a PVS, then she was beyond caring about her dignity, and that it would've been more important to Terri that her parent's be allowed to care for her, so they could maintain a link with her, and maintain their hope - than to have them completely cut off from involvement in her care, and eventually to have them callously discarded by the courts as irrelevant.

12 posted on 08/09/2005 10:49:36 PM PDT by coconutt2000 (NO MORE PEACE FOR OIL!!! DOWN WITH TYRANTS, TERRORISTS, AND TIMIDCRATS!!!! (3-T's For World Peace))
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: Crackingham

So he's pro-states rights and anti-Congress? The horror. Where can I sign a petition for his impeachment and replacement with Dershowitz?


13 posted on 08/09/2005 10:53:20 PM PDT by rebelyell7
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: FairOpinion

Wyden himself acknowledges that his big newsmaking query is limited in relevance only to a draft of a bill Congress never passed, and the Slimes concludes that Roberts was "displeased" with the law actually passed by Congress and that he's at odds with Frist and Delay.

Some *news*. Created out of thin air.


14 posted on 08/09/2005 10:56:02 PM PDT by Kryptonite
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 11 | View Replies]

To: Crackingham

Good to hear, if true.


15 posted on 08/09/2005 10:59:39 PM PDT by Sandy
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Kryptonite
but when Congress starts to act like a courtAnd, of course, there's the matter of when the courts act like Congress.
16 posted on 08/09/2005 11:18:11 PM PDT by My2Cents ("The essence of American journalism is vulgarity divested of truth." -- Winston Churchill)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

To: Crackingham

You'd think killing Terri Schiavo would be enough for them, but they demand the right to dance on her grave.


17 posted on 08/09/2005 11:27:20 PM PDT by Malesherbes
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Jim Robinson; MJY1288

FYI:

Crackingham, since Feb 22, 2005

He rarely posts comments; he posts many, many articles. THESE ARTICLES WERE ALL POSTED JUST TODAY.

Is he's flooding FreeRepublic with articles he's posting in order to dilute articles posted by other FReepers? Is this legit?

Russian criminal probe over sub
S. Korean man dies after 50 hours of computer games
Baghdad Mayor Is Ousted by a Shiite Group and Replaced
Ohio Critics of G.O.P. Start Battle to Change Election Process
'Intelligent design' smacks of creationism by another name
Suit: Residents harassed into Bible study
Supreme Court asked to hear witch case
Eminent Domain
Secondhand smoke studies fuel call for public ban
Women who work it find it doesn't work. Flirting can lead to smaller paycheck.
Gov. Bush Criticizes NCAA Ban on Seminoles Nickname
Lutherans Discuss Easing Restrictions on Gay Clergy, Couples
The ACLU's 30 Years War
Justice right to worry about death penalty
Labor Since The Overpass
John Bolton: Finally Headed to the U.N.
Mortgaged to the House of Saud
Now is the time for legislative guidance from the White House
Fighting for our children isn't easy
Dragnet out for fugitive and wife: Both escape in hail of gunfire that killed a guard
The War in Iraq: A wounded soldier wonders if he's done the right thing.
U.S. looking to East Europe for new military bases
Specter to press Roberts on interstate commerce cases. Senator asks for nominee's opinion.
Troop Requirements: Plausible fiction
Military Options: Is Iran next?
Schwarzenegger Redistricting Rejected
N.Y. fell for her, but will US voters?
Supreme Court Justice Says He's Worried About Political Criticism
Conservative Group to Oppose Roberts Because of Work on Gay Rights Case
Group: Climate change pushing wildlife north
Pregnant Woman in Islamic Dress Assaulted, Called 'Terrorist B-tch' (CAIR promotional press release)
Military Families to Join Cindy Sheehan in Crawford
Christian Groups Press Bush About North Korea
Evidence of female circumcision surfaces in Iraq
One Mother in Crawford
Convergent Evolution Found in Poison Frogs


18 posted on 08/09/2005 11:29:30 PM PDT by patriciaruth (They are all Mike Spanns)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Crackingham
The only position that matters to me is what he thinks of the decision in Kelo v. New London. If he can't muster the courage to vote WITH O'Connor, than forget about him standing firm against abortion or flag burning.

Just give me some more Originalists.

PLEASE!!!!!

19 posted on 08/10/2005 12:09:26 AM PDT by ca-dreamer74 (Known Blog-Pimp.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Crackingham

How did Wyden vote, in the Schiavo issue.

My understanding is, three Senators voted,
those three do not include Wyden.


20 posted on 08/10/2005 2:06:45 AM PDT by greasepaint
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021-34 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson