Posted on 03/13/2005 10:55:40 PM PST by elhombrelibre
Blogs.
The very word elicits tension. Or so it seemed at the recent Politics Online Conference 2005, put on last week by the Institute for Democracy & the Internet at the George Washington University. A breakout session titled "Tracking the Buzz through Blogs" demonstrated the intense emotionalism embedded in this new medium, as well as the intellect and diversity of sanity among the men and women (but mostly men) behind the keyboards.
The session's panelists were sane enough: Peter Daou, formerly of the Kerry-Edward campaign, now of the Daou Report, Patrick Ruffini, webmaster for Bush-Cheney '04, Nicco Mele formerly of the Dean campaign, and Ken Deutsch from Issue Dynamics, Inc. Each gave a cogent defense of the medium and discussed its virtues and limitations, with minor polite disagreements peppered throughout their remarks. Mercilessly, each eschewed any political speechifying and treated one another with professional respect.
But during the Q&A, the crowd collectively obsessed about whether bloggers ought to be treated as journalists or not. The controversy stems from a district court judge's recent order that the Federal Elections Commission (FEC) take up the matter of certain loopholes in the so-called McCain-Feingold campaign finance law, which allow for relatively unregulated Internet speech. Bloggers and First Amendment enthusiasts are exercised over the proposition that the federal government might begin to regulate blogs.
The panelists took a generally libertarian view of the question. Let people decide whom to believe, seemed to be the consensus. Trust is king in the blogosphere. Fakers, posers and con artists won't last long. Many attendees, however, were unsatisfied.
"But what about all these anonymous bloggers?" an attendee demanded.
"I know of a case where a guy was posing as 'Libertarian Girl' and he's really a 50-year-old man," offered another.
"I think blogs are dead," piped one surly attendee.
The general response to each of these utterances, and many more like them, was: so what? If you don't like blogs don't read them. The beauty of blogs is in the unfettered way in which they facilitate our First Amendment right. And whether you like it or not, that Amendment protects a blogger's right to be anonymous. And an idiot.
One fellow chose to test the strength of that last assertion. Somehow the subject of Fox News came up and one bloated, goateed attendee went into a frenzy. Snarl-faced and glassy-eyed, he declared, "Fox News isn't journalism! It's a direct arm of the Republican National Committee! They meet with the Republican National Committee every morning!" Even Nicco from the Dean campaign looked uncomfortable.
Turns out the fellow was a blogger with "The Raw Story," a vehemently pro-homosexual blog and webzine, which specializes in "outing" Republican members of Congress. While not a member of the panel, he took it upon himself to insert his opinion on just about everything discussed or mumbled by anyone in the room.
"If you're a rightwinger, you are a fascist," he vociferated to no one in particular.
"I'm a rightwinger," I responded. "Am I a fascist?"
"Pretty much."
It dawned on me: this clown's free speech was more of a nuisance in this, a public setting than in electronic form on his blog. At least when it's on his blog, I need neither to hear nor read it.
Garance Franke-Ruta from the American Prospect suggested out loud that the blogging industry impose "community norms" to prevent libelous postings, like the ones recently revealed to be the handwork of Maryland Gov. Bob Ehrlich staffer Joseph Steffen, which cruelly implied Baltimore Mayor (and potential Ehrlich rival) Martin O'Malley was unfaithful to his wife. (Steffen's comments, I should point out, were posted on the aptly named Free Republic, which is not a blog, per se, but a message board.)
I spoke to Franke-Ruta after the session and her concerns are well intentioned. But politicians ought to have no more protections from salacious blog posts than they do from sandwich boards. In the end, the government should no more do anything about them than John Adams should have imposed the Alien and Sedition Acts in 1798.
Blogs don't libel people. People libel people.
Patrick Hynes is a Republican consultant and a freelance writer. He is the proprietor of the site AnkleBitingPundits.com.
Why is it that we uneducated louts of the internet know the difference between a tabloid and a broadsheet, yet the literati of the MSM can't be bothered to learn the distinction between a blog and a forum?
Offhand, I'd say the inability to make the distinction is telling...
Oh for pity's sake. :-(
mark to read at home
Ahhhhhhhhhh...but I, OTOH,do NOT pardon most. LOL
You heard it here first, I am really an 80 year triple murderer loggin on from prison.
The part that cracks me up is that people hear that this is a "blog", so they sign up and start posting vanities in an attempt to jump onto the blogging bandwagon.
Then they start wondering why everyone flames them and posts pictures of cats in viking helmets and lightning bolts... it never fails to provide a good laugh or two.
Am I the only one who found the use of this word peculiar in this context? Is there even a definition of the word "exercised" which extends it to be used as an adjective?
While we're confessing, I'm not from Florida. (Then again, I never claimed to be.)
Like me.
I'm actually a 9 year old girl from Topeka, Kansas.
I'm very mannerly and I curtsy, and I don't have the hairy, nasty body of a man or thick, fumbling sausage-like fingers that routinely break the handles off of coffee cups at all. No no. I'm actually a sweet little girl in a paisley dress who says "Please" and "Thank You" and who's mother just ADORES me.
Sounds to me like their fat mouths were being exercised.
LOL
The Dinosaur Media just can't accept that their monoply (read: stranglehold) as gatekeepers of information is slipping away. Since they have perfected the hard mentatlity that no fact seems able to penetrate, they simply cannot fathom the notion that there are others outside "the club" who not only can, but WILL, challenge their versions of the day's events. The "great unwashed" are beginning to light torches and gather pitchforks, and suddenly the castle walls don't seem so impregnable.
Those who blog best will survive the shakeout, the rest will fade away. But all will serve the purpose of stirring things up, and transforming the stale glop that the Dinosaur Media feeds us.
Blog on!
Criminy. I think Jim Robinson is going to have to change the name to "FreeRepublic: not a blog". =^/
From what I've seen lately in the LSM ninety percent of the people with journalism degrees can't do any of the above. Most of the time I see better reporting from the folks on this forum than I do from our 'esteemed' press.
Well, I have to admit I can be that way, too, sometimes-but usually only when I first wake up.
BTW, I'm really a nine-year-old child prodigy named Olaf from Sweden.
We are much more than virtual public restroom tile grout.
Another left wing loon who doesn't know the meaning of fascist.
Thomas Paine lives.
One thing about this forum: If you post something, you damn well better have your facts and arguments straight.
Post something on here that isn't on the up and up and your ass will be handed to you by at least three posters who are experts in the field, regardless of which field it is. And also by at least a dozen people who can "Google" the Hell out of something and find in-depth expert analysis, discussion and books on the subject both pro and con.
An in addition, your grammar, punctuation, syntax, will be scrutinized until every dangling participle is exposed for the world to see.
Oh. And at least 10 posters will tell you that it has already been posted.....three times...and give links to the other threads.
We're self-policing.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.