[jpsb]

"There is no requirement to return home for a renewal of a permit"

Fatal flaw, I sugggest Southack reread the end of his post paying special attention to the mischaracterize opponets position part of it.

[Southack]

"There is no requirement to return home for a renewal of a permit" Fatal flaw, I sugggest Southack reread the end of his post paying special attention to the mischaracterize opponets position part of it."

Indeed, See Post #260. Fatalis blew it. Illegals have to return home under Bush's plan in order to get a renewal, contrary to her claim.