[Southack]

"There is no requirement to return home for a renewal of a permit" Fatal flaw, I sugggest Southack reread the end of his post paying special attention to the mischaracterize opponets position part of it."

Indeed, See Post #260. Fatalis blew it. Illegals have to return home under Bush's plan in order to get a renewal, contrary to her claim.

[jpsb]

OK time to dig in and google.

[Torie]

I don't see any requirement to depart to renew. What I see is the word "end" after presumably the renewal(s) are exhausted, unless the number of renewals is limitless.

Assuming there is a right to but one renewal, what we have is a program, where the illegals get to work for six years, in the meantime having gotten in the queue for a green card, and if still in the queue at the end of six years, then they need to pack their bags, and wait for their turn elsewhere. Is that really workable? Is that what will really happen?