Posted on 12/26/2004 3:08:03 AM PST by Lindykim
ping
Last year I moved to the Puget Sound area, and driving into Seattle one day I noticed a large cathedral on a hill overlooking the city. I love sacred spaces, so I went to see what it was. It was St. Marks, the Episcopal Cathedral.
I went in the bookstore first to ask if one could go into the cathedral, and while there I noticed Christian books were easily outnumbered by books from other faiths.
Inside the Cathedral looked like an abandoned warehouse, and had all of the sacredness of one. It felt entirely bereft of any semblance of Divine presence. An empty shell. I'd never felt that way in any sacred structure before. It was hideous, and very disturbing.
Don't know if the whole Episcopal Church is dying, but that part of it sure has.
With respect, I ask anyone who still belongs what the attraction is or was?
BUMP & PING
ping
"With respect, I ask anyone who still belongs what the attraction is or was?"
The same attraction the unitarian univeralists and the aetheists offer: unconditional acceptance, disguised as unconditional love, as long as the attendee denies the existence of any absolute truth.
Psalm 14:1 suffices to describe the truth of what is happening w/ Vicky and his friends....
I mean, Jeeesh - Sounds like the annual per store statistics of Wal-Mart - Totally devoid of any intimation of the real objective of any church.
By my last post don't mean to imply that I in any way support what these idiots in New Hampshire did. IMO This deserves the reduction in attendance that has been measured.
You're right, especially about the cynicism. If I understand correctly, the Unitarian Church is for people who have to belong to a church to be upstanding members of the community, but don't really believe in anything.
The Episcopalians are becoming the same thing.
BTW, I used to have an Episcopalian friend who referred to himself as a Whiskeypalian.
I went to Episcopal schools from nursery school through 10th 9th Grade. If I could join a traditional Episcopal church, I would (the Presbyterian church near me is hopelessly lost in a liberal pose). Unfortunately, all the tradtion is gone and I am left with nothing to attract me to these institutions. I am seriously thinkg of becoming a Catholic.
It's an early, formal, Protestant church that, in my town, was also attractive to those who belonged to Armenian, Russian, and Greek Orthodox sects, but who had no local church. Friends from other denominations who went to church with me a few times joined, because they sought formality. At the time, we were just teenagers, but one Baptist friend joined becase he thought a question asked after communion, "Anybody left out?" was flippant and irreverant.
In local New England tradition, the popular people went to the Congregational church, the "Swells" went to the Episcopal. The National Lampoon did a series once of various "hells" for different denominations-The Episcopalians were sent there "For eating oysters with the Dinner Fork."
The "High" version of the church maintained monastaries (Soc of St.James, among others) about which my RC friends would exasperatedly exclaim, "If you want to BE Catholic, why not BE Catholic???"{{Because Papal Infallability and the Veneration of Mary were rejected-Can't do much with that!!}}
All that said, I loved the Church as it once was, the Book of Common Prayer, the 1940 Hymnal ( I sang in the choir) , and if it ever returns to it, so shall I.
The short answer is that at one time, it was a formal and respectful service, highly nonsecular, and it meant business. It was also, IMO, a beautiful and moving service.
I feel like an old friend has died.
My brother visited one and had to hurridly leave, lest he disrupt the (travesty) of a service by losing self-control and laughing out loud. Some speaker was offering a weird mixture of imported Eastern philosophy, contemporary CorrectThink , etc.- The "G-d Optional" stuff.
But alas, as with so many of the mainline denominations, the Episcopal church has left its first love. It has a form of godliness, but denies the power therein. It is, as you observed - a collection of dead-men-walking.
The Episcopalians that know their Bibles and regard homosexuality as an abomination are voting with their feet.
lj will be gone from FR for a short while. I'm the volunteer until little jeremiah gets back online.
If you want on/off the list let me know.
"Could someone, anyone, please tell me what the attraction of the Episcopal Church is, what does it offer beyond a tradition for those raised in it?"
Well, it is a liturgical church (like the Catholics), but without the rigid hierarchy, without the Pope. Like Catholics, we take communion every Sunday, whereas most Protestant churches rarely do. The prayer book (particularly the 1928 version, but even with the new language) is widely acknowledged to contain some of the most beautiful language ever written in English. And, I like it because Episcopal priests are almost always very well educated, and almost always they truly understand the world, having had secular careers prior to coming to the priesthood. Plus, since the priests not only can marry and have children, but are expected to, I believe they have a broader understanding of the human condition than Catholic priests.
I was raised in the Episcopal church but left not only the church but faith as a teen, only coming back to both in my early forties. I love my church, and don't want to leave, so I am just waiting to see what happens. Pretty much the only thing I could do would be to become a Catholic, and since I think the Catholic church is also wrong on a number of issues (although not as wrong as the Episcopal church), I would prefer not to do that. How can I abandon the church of John Donne, George Herbert, and C.S. Lewis to people so wrong-headed?
Regardless of denominational differences, though, it is important to remember that the Body of Christ has members in every church-- and that every church also has members who are not true believers. Whether we stay or go, whether we are of this church or that one, or have only a small circle of faithful friends, we are charged with being the salt and the light. Christ's church is eternal, no matter the rise and fall of any particular form that a segment of it may take.
African Methodist Episcopal Church
The African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church
Alliance of Baptists
American Baptist Churches in the USA
The Antiochian Orthodox Christian Archdiocese of North America
Diocese of the Armenian Church of America
Christian Church (Disciples of Christ)
Christian Methodist Episcopal Church
Church of the Brethren
The Coptic Orthodox Church in North America
The Episcopal Church
Evangelical Lutheran Church in America
Friends United Meeting
Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America
Hungarian Reformed Church in America
International Council of Community Churches
Korean Presbyterian Church in America
Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church
Mar Thoma Church
Moravian Church in America Northern Province and Southern Province
National Baptist Convention of America
National Baptist Convention, U.S.A., Inc.
National Missionary Baptist Convention of America
Orthodox Church in America
Patriarchal Parishes of the Russian Orthodox Church in the USA
Philadelphia Yearly Meeting of the Religious Society of Friends
Polish National Catholic Church of America
Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.)
Progressive National Baptist Convention, Inc.
Reformed Church in America
Serbian Orthodox Church in the U.S.A. and Canada
The Swedenborgian Church
Syrian Orthodox Church of Antioch
Ukrainian Orthodox Church of America
United Church of Christ
The United Methodist Church
See also: The Standing Conference of Canonical Orthodox Bishops in the Americas (SCOBA)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.