Posted on 11/09/2004 12:46:24 PM PST by JCEccles
KSL Radio "Unofficial" Online Poll
Q: Would you like to see Orrin Hatch replace John Ashcroft as U.S. Attorney General?
73% : Yes
27% : No
No. He wants to be loved by the New York Times and is teddy Kennedy's "best friend".
The rumor is, Ashcroft has had enough and wants to step down. I can understand that. He's been brutalized by the left.
Probably more truth to that than you know -- it's almost like an inside-Mormon-joke. Both Hatch and Flake are old-line Mormon names; and many of them are blood kin.
The thing I've noticed about Mormon politicos is that, as they get older, they tend to get more dovish, less punitive. But that may be an overgeneralization.
You make a good point, that he would be out of the senate before he mangaes to get his legislation passed. But I am also worried about how he would enforce current laws as attorney general. I think the situation we have currently with the movie/music industry suing teenagers, is pretty unacceptable.
The point of this thread isn't whether we like or dislike Hatch, but whether conservatism overall would be better served if he leaves the Senate (and Senate Judiciary Committee) immediately.
No. Hatch is spineless and is influenced by questionable friends (Teddy Kennedy).
You would rather that Hatch remain in the Senate, authoring legislation with Ted Kennedy and compromising with liberals on the choice of SCOTUS justices for two to eight more years?
Wasn't it Orrin Hatch that reported the U.S. had compromised Osama Bin Laden's satellite phone and were listening to his conversations.(Just before the war in Afghanistan) This was just after a high level security briefing, and was a MAJOR intelligence gaff.
Good question. I don't remember which senator it was. Are you sure it wasn't "Leaky" Leahy?
NOOOOOOOO!! NOOOOOOOOO!! NOOOOOOOOO!! and NOOOOOOOOOO!!
"The clearest suggestion of successful US monitoring of Al Qaeda communications?and the closest to the September 11 attacks?was the statement by Utah Senator Orrin Hatch, a conservative Republican with wide contacts in the national security establishment. He told the Associated Press on September 11 that the US government was monitoring bin Laden?s communications electronically and had overheard two bin Laden aides celebrating the successful terrorist attack. "They have an intercept of some information that included people associated with bin Laden who acknowledged a couple of targets were hit," he told AP. (Source: Associated Press, September 11, 2001, "World Trade Center collapses in terrorist attack," by David Crary and Jerry Schwartz)"
I'd like to see Hatch retire. Joining him would be John McCain and a number of others if I had my way.
If Hatch takes over the AG slot, it will be for four years and he will retire from public service at the end of it.
If he doesn't take over the AG slot, then he remains in the Senate (and on the Judiciary Committee) for two and very possibly eight more years, authoring legislation with Ted Kennedy and compromising with liberals to put justices on the SCOTUS in the mold of Ruth Bader-Ginsberg (which appointment Hatch boasted of in his biography).
Which scenario do you prefer?
This would have the effect of retiring him from the Senate immediately and from public service altogether in four years.
NEVER!! He's afraid of his own shadow and his lips are on Teddy Kennedy's arse! He'll also be writing LOVE SONGS....just like Janet Reno writing PLAYS and MOVIES!!
See my post #114.
I hope the President doesn't start re-treading worn-out old wussies who are nothing more than walking mouths.
We need some dynamic new-blood type who won't fold like a deck of cards when the liberals start attack and smear pressures. Hatch should be appointed music professor at Brigham Young University.
Leni
DOUBLE NO!
Hatch pushed for a similar patriot act bill when Klinton was in office. Too statist.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.