Posted on 02/07/2004 7:41:20 AM PST by mtbopfuyn
I've had requests to get this safety list out there. It's just some quick notes so any additions and comments are welcome. Admin can move it as they wish.
Smith, who murdered Carlie Brucia, had once before been up on attempted kidnapping charges on a young woman. Miss Stinson escaped due to quick thinking.
SARASOTA --- Stinson, who was 20 at the time, struggled, lost her footing and fell down, then offered Smith $50 to leave her alone. He jumped on top of her. "If you don't quit screaming, I'll cut you," Smith said, according to records. Smith pulled her up by her shirt, but she squirmed away, landing in oncoming traffic. A van stopped to help her, she said. The people in the van jumped out, armed with golf clubs to fend Smith off, but he fled.
Smart gal for struggling, screaming and getting out of her shirt to get away. She called attention to herself which saved her life. We've all seen the horrible video of Carlie Brucia's kidnapping. I'm certainly not blaming Carlie, but she did have options she failed to act upon. Please take the time to talk to and role play with your children and give them skills to avoid or get away from predators.
1) Be aware of your surroundings. Indiana Jones has added - when you have a head set on (listening to MP3 players etc.) your ability to be aware of what is going on around you is greatly compromised.
2) Carlie let Smith get too close. Never let anyone get within arm's distance so they can't grab you. Don't let strangers enter your "space". If you take a step back and he moves closer, that's a red flag to run.
3) Listen to that inner voice telling you something isn't right. She seemed to have hesitated and almost stepped back but didn't follow through. That voice was telling her to back away but we teach our children to be polite and mind adults. Fml adds - Its is also very important that children know that good gown-ups don't ask for help or approach them. Only the bad come near them, and if there is a mistake, a good adult will understand.
4) Never talk to strangers. She stopped and allowed contact. Doesn't matter if he had an ID showing he was a security guard for the car wash. Doesn't matter if he had a gun or a knife. He doesn't want to fire the gun, as it will draw attention. A running target is hard to hit. Your odds of dying from a gunshot wound in a public place are much better than the 99.9% chance of being killed at his hands later.
5) In the video we see Carlie walking directly toward her murderer. She didn't avoid him, walk around him, or run away, and she allowed him within her space. This signaled to him she was vulnerable and an easy victim.
6) Carlie had a weapon - her backpack. She may have had time while he approached her or was talking to her to take off her backpack. Just the act of removing the backpack may have signaled Smith that she wasn't an easy target. Once she was grabbed or in the car, use the backpack to hit him.
7) After she was grabbed - NEVER ALLOW YOURSELF TO BE TAKEN TO THE SECOND SCENE! Time and time again we've been told the second location is where victims are killed. Once he grabbed her arm - twist, kick, hit, scream your lungs out, whatever it takes. If you can't get away then go limp and fall to the ground to gain time. It's hard to pick up 120 lbs of dead weight quickly. If he does pick you up then start fighting again. He will have his hands occupied by holding you but you have your arms and legs free to gouge eyes out and bite. 8) We see Smith quietly leading Carlie away - Scream, kick over trash cans, kick the building, kick the car, whatever makes noise to draw attention. 9) NEVER GET IN THE CAR! Your legs are stronger than your hands so kick the sicko or use legs to delay him putting you in the car. Block the doorway however you can. 10) He has you in the car - A car is a weapon. He tells you to sit still, be quiet or he'll kill you - screw him. Go crazy!!! Hit him, kick him, kick his driving leg especially, grab the steering wheel, put it in reverse, turn on radio loud, kick windows, roll windows down, start pulling wires under the dash, honk horn, hit him with the back pack or whatever you can get out of the backpack (pencil, sharp cornered book, toy with pointy edges). Do NOT be afraid of wrecking the car. You have a much greater chance of surviving an accident than you do at the second deadly location scene. An accident will draw attention, people will come, police will come, and an ambulance will come. The sicko will be more concerned in saving his hide than taking you with him. Most likely he will quickly escape the scene and you will be safe.
If you are being put in the trunk, try to leave the straps of the backpack or shirt tail hanging out to draw attention from other drivers. Have your kids get in your trunk and show them how to pull the signal wires and how to release the lock. It may also be possible for them to kick out the tail light and wave to attract attention.
11) Role play. Review, review, review. Think of scenarios and what you would do. The more you can think of the more automatic you can be in your reactions and avoidances of dangerous situations. Carlie had mere seconds before he got her to the car and probably only an hour before she was killed. If you've gone over and thought about what to do in those precious few moments, it may save your life.
Again, I'm NOT putting any blame on Carlie however our children can learn from her mistakes. Prayers for Carlie and the other children who have been taken from us.
Please add to the list.
Threads like this are a good reminder.... thanks
It's not the kind of thing I'd have ever thought of giving my young daughters to read, except that I inadvertently left my paperback copy lying in the living room. A couple of days later my ten-year-old approached me and asked, "Daddy, what's a 'blood-gun?'" I asked her where she picked up a term like that, and she told me, "In the Ted Bundy book." Obviously, the word she had misinterpreted was "bludgeon"--Ted's favorite method of getting control of his victims.
At first I was mortified that she should have been reading such a horrible book, but upon reflection I thought that perhaps it was better that she should have a good, first-hand account of the evil to which human nature is susceptible. In a perfect world, this wouldn't be so. But our world is far from perfect.
For those of you with little ones, ask them what a "stranger" or "bad guy" looks like. You might be surprised by the answer. We heard things like "they look mean," "they wear black," etc. We explained that a "bad guy" will NOT want them to know he's bad, so he will act like he's very nice.
I hate that we are having to teach our kids these things, but I believe it's a necessity. My brother-in-law and I are in disagreement about it being necessary. He's a police officer in San Diego and he told me that stats show the number of abductions is actually down. I looked him right in the eye and said, "To the parents of an abducted child, those numbers mean NOTHING and your brother and I will do everything possible to help keep our kids safe." The funny thing is that our conversation took place in Venice, FL, which is very near Sarasota, when we were there this past Thanksgiving.
This book is written by a FBI profiler and helps parents discern when to really worry about your kids, and what to do about.
I have two young boys and found some good, practicle advice in this book.
The problem with never talk to strangers is that if a child needs help, or is lost they are afraid to ask anyone for help. I have had this happen to me twice, where I found a lost child, one in a parking lot, one in a store.
They were both young and scared to death, but ran away from me because they looked at me as a stranger.
It is a better approach, IMO, to teach children to look for someone they can trust to help them, know when to avoid strangers and what to say if one does approach them.
the book I recommend above gives the example of "look for a Mommy", because chances are that a woman with children is going to help a lost child. Of course not in every single case is that true. But I think it is better than Never, ever talk to strangers.
Just my .02. It is a scary world out there, sometimes, for those of us with young children. We all do the best we can to protect them.
If you want children, you should have a few. The world is not all bad and scary. There are nice, kind people everywhere.We just have to have better skills at recognizing them these days and more prepared to teach our children those skills as well.
Of course terrible things do happen to good people. But the risk is much lower of something bad happening to you , than the joy you will miss out on if you really want kids and don't have them
There are more good guys out there than bad.
This is a terrible, heartbreaking case. But let's remember there are more people in this country who would help a child, rather than hurt a child.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.