Now if were talking about a games box, you got me Linux will never be the gaming platform that windows is, Ill give you that.
There is just no reason to get pengified. Except for an irrational fear of Bill Gates that most UNIX people seem to exhibit. How about the fact I wanted to set up a web server/ftp server and outside access to my computer and not have to pay more than a thousand dollars to do it. I am willing to say that yes if your looking for a gaming station go with windows, if you just want a box to get on the web do email, and type reports Linux does just as well as windows and is just as easy. You on the other hand say if you dont use windows its because your a nut, who here is being irrational.
I think it is because of Open Source. When you get free software, who do you complain to to get it fixed? With the sourceforge site that you blew off you can complain right to the darn people writing the code. My company does tens of thousands of dollars of business with MS do you think I could get a hold of one of their developers?
If you dont think there has been an improvement in Linux over the past five years youre on crack or have not used it. I was totally a windows user until redhat 7 came out because redhat 5 was a pain to use. Now I have a windows desktop (from my office), and my home PC is Linux because its just as easy, does not cost me a dime, and is more stable.
When you say Linux sucks more you are not talking about stability, speed, lifetime, or scalability.