Reaction a shock to Dixie Chicks

(Mansfield, OH) News Journal ^ | May 22, 2003 | John Benson

[fightinJAG]

It is somewhat ironic that the Dixie Chicks, one of country music's biggest acts over the past five years with nearly 25 million albums sold, decided to call their latest disc "Home," a place they were not welcome earlier this spring.

[friendly]

And his paper obviously is unable to distinguish between a correspondent and a columnist

NY Times potential!!

Just typical liberal deceit.

[MWS]

Does America understand the concept of free speech?

Apparently yes! The mindset that "free speech" applies only to the proponents of liberalism and not to those who wish to protest liberals never ceases to amaze me!

Personally, I am getting quite sick of those who are trying to censor conservative protest on the grounds that we are censoring them!

[mewzilla]

Maybe this guy's bucking for Blair's old job. Benson sure writes like a Timesman.

[TrebleRebel]

When contemplating Maines' opinionated statement and her subsequent apology, the problem that arises surrounds free speech. If artists aren't going to speak out and raise awareness of issues, that they feel -- right or wrong -- are close to their heart, then who will?

She just won't shut up, will she? She just rambles on like some disjointed whiner. She wasn't 'raising awareness,' she was indulging in commerce. She began her comment with 'just so you know'...in other words, 'in case you're waffling on whether or not to buy an album, t-shirt, tickets to our next concert, or any other item that will put money in our pockets, listen to what I have to say next and it may change your mind...' This could have blown over weeks ago, but its this bird-brain that won't let it die. And as long as she keeps squawking, they're going to continue to be maligned. Someone should teach them the saying 'least said, soonest mended.'

[Rightly Biased]

F.U.N.M.

[jwalsh07]

I sent the author a link to this thread. Hopefully he will come away with the knowledge that speech is a two way street.

But I have my doubts.

[75thOVI]

"Does America understand the concept of free speech?"

I think "America" understands free speech just fine. That's what irritates the living daylights out of our elite citizens. They are quite put out when the lower classes act like they have rights too. For people like Dixie Chicks, Pearl Jam, Bill O'Riely, and all politicians, We The People have the right to buy their music, watch their tv shows and movies, and vote for them. Criticizing their "betters" has never been a right afforded to the lower classes.

An excellent example is our bright shiny new "Campaign Finance Reform Act" The entire concept behind this new law is that we poor peons shouldn't worry our poor pointy little heads about how our elected representitives perform. Ads pointing out their failures and foiables only "muddy up" our lower class thinking. It would be so much better if those far more capable and qualified told us what to think, and who to vote for. In what "free country" could such an abomination be signed into law. And by a president we are supposed to "thank God" for every day.

[BillCompton]

We clearly need a new constitutional amendment:

The right to be free from responsibility for one's actions shall not be abridged.

Were this to become an amendment, then the Dixie Chicks would have a constitutional arguement and we could, most of us, feel like McCarthyites.

[jwalsh07]

Benson's email address

[Free_at_last_-2001]

like it

[4mycountry]

Reaction a shock to the Dixie Chicks

Shocked.

[Neenah]

Source

Keith: "If she makes it a big war, I’ll bury her." (Part 2 of 2)

Craig Shelburne

In Part Two of CMT.com's exclusive interview, Toby Keith confronts the so-called "feud" with the Dixie Chicks' Natalie Maines, reveals what Alan Jackson whispered to him at the CMA Awards and talks about his touring plans for the future.

CMT: I know that fame can be hard to deal with. I was wondering if you could give any insight about how fame can mess with your head, or how it can affect you?

TK: It's what you make of it. If you put people around you at ease, then they'll be that way most of the time. You just can't avoid trouble sometimes, but most times, if you put people at ease around you, and act like your feet are on the ground and let them know that you're pretty squarely grounded, then they'll treat you decent. But if you act like a jackass, they're going to treat you like one.

CMT: Earlier this year, Natalie Maines said in an interview that she hated your song "Courtesy of the Red, White and Blue." Our CMT.com message boards went crazy after that. Do you think comments like that can get blown out of proportion?

TK: I think the only thing that got blown out of proportion is that they said there was a feud. I barely even commented on the situation. I've been told that she went in some major publications and made four or five [comments] like we were lobbing the ball back and forth. But it's America. She can think what she wants to about me; I don't care.

If she makes it a big war, I'll bury her. She can think about my song what she wants to. If she wants to get personal about it, then I'll be her Huckleberry. She said what she said, and hey … . The greatest thing that I find in it that's funny is that usually when somebody says something about this song, they open their blowhole and something flies out. They realize real quick, in just a few days, that they probably bit off more than they could chew. Because they start feeling the heat from the military, from families who have sons and daughters preparing to go to Iraq and who are in Afghanistan already and all the conflicts that we're in.

That's where I underestimated this song when I wrote it. It was just feelings that I felt, but I didn't realize that it was an anthem for the military people and how much it's meant to them. You step on their ground, they starting fighting back at you. So when somebody steps up and throws something out there at random just out of their blowhole that's really unnecessary, the next time you hear a statement out of them, it's a little lighter and then it's retracted a little lighter and a little lighter. Then Country Weekly comes out that we've got a feud. We don't have no feud. I haven't made it a feud yet.

It's a great way to sell magazines, but there's no truth in it. Somebody asked me one time what I thought about it. I said, 'Look, you're asking Barry Bonds, a super hit-maker songwriter. That's what I do, I write songs. I've had a string of No. 1's that I don't think anybody can take away from me, no matter who you are. I have been BMI songwriter of the year. I am a big-time songwriter, and first and foremost songwriter, so I'm in the big league of that. By you asking me my opinion on what I think of what she said about me, that's like asking Barry Bonds what he thought about what a softball player said about his swing. You don't do that. She's not a songwriter, so we can't discuss the mechanics of the song. Why don't you just go down on Second Avenue and pick one of those homeless guys and ask him what he thinks about it? To me it's the same. And that's all I've commented on. I haven't said anything about her song "Goodbye Earl" or any of that stuff.

CMT: Is there anything that you would want to say? You've got a platform now.

TK: I'm not into making it a war. I said all I'm gonna say about it. I repeated exactly what I told the Atlanta Constitution when they asked me. I said, 'Man, you're asking me to respond to something below the radar.' I'm a songwriter, she's not, and so she can say my song is ignorant, but it's ignorant for her to say that because she's not a songwriter. She said anybody could write 'boots in your ass,' but she didn't. She has never written anything that's been a hit, so it's ridiculous for me to have to respond to that. Now if Hank Cochran or Merle Haggard or somebody responds, then we'll sit down and discuss what I could have done better on that song. But I'm not going to get into a cat fight with somebody who can't write a song.

CMT: That song was a No. 1 hit in July, and you've been touring for months and months after that. Are you still getting the same reaction you did this summer?

TK: I dare anybody with a big mouth to show up at my show and just stand out there. I'll give them the stage. I tell you what, I'll go out and sing "Courtesy of the Red, White and Blue" and anybody that wants to call it ignorant can walk right out on my stage, and I'll give them the mike and they can address the audience. I dare them. Bring it on, buddy.

CMT: I don't think they would live to tell the story.

TK: No, just bring it on. It's an emotionally moving [song]. It disturbs me every night how emotional people get over that song, and I think it's just real serious when you respond in a negative way to this song -- unless you're just trying to get a little heat off the hot man.

CMT: That song has been a big story for you, but what's been the toughest part of this last year, would you say?

TK: I've had everything my way. Answering questions about the award shows gets old because they mean more to the fans and more to the people that work behind the scenes. Those are their rewards for their hard work, and when you don't get them, you know why you don't get any. Alan Jackson was a very, very gracious winner. He paid me a huge compliment on the way up to one of his awards. He stopped and paid me a huge compliment.

CMT: What did he say?

TK: He said, "You deserve this award." Entertainer of the year.

CMT: Wow, what does that mean, when he says that? How does that make you feel?

TK: It's just him being a very gracious winner, man. He recognized that I work hard, and I recognize he works hard. I don't know who [said] I look pissed because I told everybody going in -- if you look at the interviews prior to the show -- I said I doubt we get out of here with anything. Because there's a huge powerhouse in Nashville that energizes that, operates that system, and I don't have no control over that. Just say your serenity prayer and move on. You can't change anything about that.

CMT: What's it gonna take for you to win that award?

TK: I don't think I'll ever win it, but it means more to the people around it than it does me. I promise you -- and I mean this with 100 percent of my heart -- if I'm selling out shows and I'm in either the top or one of the top grossing concert tours of the year … The numbers are still coming in, but I think we had one of the top-grossing tours -- if not the top grossing tour. If you put me there, give me my albums sales I'm having and go on with my career and I get to write my own songs and sing them … . I don't ever have to go back except just for the face of maybe my label or my manager or whoever would think we need to be there. You have to understand that, and unfortunately the fans don't.

CMT: So what can we expect from you touring next year -- any big surprises or big news next year for your tour?

TK: No, we're gonna do more of the same. I'm not gonna load my tour up with a whole bunch of acts trying to sell tickets. I think if the headliner goes in thinking he needs to sign a bunch of acts to sell tickets to make his tour go, then he probably needs to rethink his headline situation. I think you have to be confident enough that when you show up, people are going to want to come see you. I took one act out last year. I took a friend of mine on the acoustic guitar, Paul Thorn, and he did 20 or 30 minutes, and Rascal Flatts came on. It helped launch their careers some more, and we put some numbers up in some places that had never been put up. I wouldn't trade that for anything, and you can capitalize every letter on ANYTHING.

CMT: Is there anybody that you would open for?

TK: No. I don't have to open for anybody anymore. I do my own thing, and I've worked real hard to get it that way. If it gets to where I have to start opening for somebody again, I'll rethink my position and hang it up.

CMT: Even outside of the country world? Is there anybody that you would think your audience and maybe a rock performer's audience would fit?

TK: I don't know about that. I've got one huge offer to constantly do movies for one of the largest agencies in Hollywood. Then I have two or three other companies offering up to do sitcoms, and they're all major ABC, CBS, NBC, FOX kind of stuff. That's another hill I may want to go climb someday, but right now I'm telling them no, because music is too important to me, and it always will be. But at some point ... I have a daughter that's going to want to pursue a music career, and I could stop and help her with that and retire, at least from the music business. I may still make a couple of albums, but as soon as people quit wanting to see me and hear my music, I'm not gonna beat a dead horse. I'm going to move on.

CMT: So are you going to make a big retirement announcement like Garth did, or are you just going to step aside?

TK: I'll just step aside. I can't say that I'll ever retire. I don't know. I'm just saying when it gets to where you go out and you don't sell tickets and you have to start piecing stuff together to make it work, or you quit selling albums and all that, I may just. ... If somebody wants to cut a record on me out there, I may bring my top 10 songs in and do the album, but I won't do much touring or any promotion work to promote it. As long as there is an album and a place, a market which I hope there is, I'll always being doing this.

CMT:Any New Year's resolutions this year? TK: No, man. Just more of the same. Give me back more of the same -- let's go.

___________________________________________________

As far as I am concerned, when NM, after all the press and the lame interview with Diane Sawyer, put on that FUTB t-shirt on the Awards Show....she sealed her fate. She wants the press, and I hope she gets it.

"BIG TIME"

[tuna_battle_slight_return]

Tim Duncan is ashamed that the Dixie Chicks are from Texas.

[rintense]

Another Bush basher is also feeling the pinch. Sheryl Crow is coming to West Michigan to perform at the Muskegon Air Show- a military air show. She's only sold half the tickets. There was a movement in the area to have her removed from the show because folks thought it was inappropriate that she’d be performing at a military air show, given her anti-war stance. Well, that didn't happen. And now folks are expressing their freedom of speech- by not going to her show.

[poindexter]

Chick looks like David Bowie!

[Richard Kimball]

Which is especially ironic when one notes the guy writes for a newspaper. Notice his editor didn't catch this, either...

Whenever I pick up newspapers anymore, I notice how poorly formulated arguments are in the editorials, and how frequently they use convoluted and improper logic. The average Freeper writes as well as the average editorial writer, and the best Freepers blow the editorial writers away.

[TSgt]

The Chicks can say what they want when they want HOWEVER:

They should not disrespect the honor or memory of those who have given their lives or are/were currently giving their lives to allow the Chicks to spew their hate talk.

This is not an issue of free speech and I'm continually perplexed by those who think it is. Saying what she said in another country during a war was treasonous.

The Chicks need to learn how to be more accepting of other people's free speech when they tell them to go to hell.

Piss on them.

[Snuffington]

... which means the two biggest free-speech moments of 2003 (Dixie Chicks and Pearl Jam) found the participants capitulating faster than the Republican Guard.

Um... yeah, right. These were great "free-speech" moments. Celebrities mouthing off about geo-politics, only to discover they misread their usually sycophantic fan-base. Then they frantically back-track so they don't end up destroying their pop-culture careers. Heady and deep stuff.

[Becki]

Like Emily (Robison) said, we never use the stage as a place to preach our political beliefs or spiritual beliefs. And we still won't.

Then what was F.U.T.K?

Becki

[wingnuts'nbolts]

No one is questoning the right of these "important" people to free speech, they can say whatever they like whenever they like, we however, the beneficiaries of their utterings, do not have to be pleased with what we hear, or agree with what we hear, or even care about what they think.

We can voice our rights and call radio stations and complain about the DChick's verbal droppings and refuse to listen to their music, we can stay away from their performances in droves if we so wish, and we can opine at thier individual and collective stupidity without in any way hindering their constitution right to say what they want, known as free speech.