Posted on 11/17/2026 5:39:00 AM PST by Red Badger
The City of Charlotte has filed a motion to dismiss the wrongful death lawsuit brought by the family of 23-year-old Ukrainian refugee Iryna Zarutska, who was fatally stabbed from behind on a Lynx Blue Line train in August 2025.
On Monday, attorneys representing the City of Charlotte filed a motion to dismiss the wrongful death lawsuit brought by Zarutska’s family, invoking governmental immunity under North Carolina law.
The motion was filed at 3:08 p.m. in Mecklenburg County Superior Court, according to The North Carolina Beat.
Rather than accept responsibility for the security failures that preceded the horrific attack, city attorneys argue that Charlotte’s policing and public safety responsibilities are government functions shielded from civil liability.
The city further argues that it owed a general duty to protect the public but had no special obligation to provide individual protection to Zarutska.
Charlotte is also arguing that the alleged killer's intentional criminal conduct, rather than the city's security practices, was the legal cause of her death.
Even if the lawsuit survives, the city is seeking to limit its financial liability to $1 million.
Perhaps most infuriating is that the city acknowledged in its filing that:
Zarutska was a paying passenger.
Her accused killer, Decarlos Brown Jr., appeared to have boarded without presenting a ticket or pass.
The City is correct as to its claim of Constitutional immumity, but the legislature should appropriate funds for victims of thugs who should have been in jail.
R.I.P. Iryna. “Who will protect us from our protectors?” R.I.P. Mark Scott
The claim was worthless regardless of the political composition of the city’s leadership.
There’s no reasonable means of making transit systems 100% secure from criminals, nor can riders have a guarantee of security anymore than pedestrians on a city sidewalk.
My understanding is the judge who sentenced this monster to “treatment” had a financial interest in the treatment provider.
She was murdered by government Wokeness. Government wickedness.
I agree with the first part. Harsh as it seems in some cases, the ancient principle of sovereign Immunity prevents a vast number of lawsuits and drain in public funds. I disagree with your second because it guts the first
When three cities control the state, Sen. Cooper first became Governor because Charlotte banned men in women’s bathrooms, and all of that, of course they hope for sympathetics.
btt
They built the whole light rail system WITHOUT TURNSTILES, so the transportation system itself is unsafe as it’s become a free homeless transportation service.
What is a "general duty to protect" other than the cumulative result of protecting everyone individually?
The city had a duty to provide a safe seat to e anyone who sat in that seat, not a specific duty to protect Iryna no matter where she happened to be. It could have been be just as likely that the person who took that seat before her would be the victim.
-PJ
RIP IRYNA
.
Sorry we Failed you.
That fund should be filled with fines paid by criminals as well as sweat equity from prison labor.
The murderer was acting as an agent of the State. /s
Isn’t walking on a sidewalk just as unsafe? Can a city be sued by a stabbing victim for getting knifed outside a Walgreens?
"Shelly Headen, posted a photo of herself smiling in front of crematorium ovens at the Dachau concentration camp memorial. She captioned the post, 'This is where Trump supporters belong implying they should be subjected to the same fate as Holocaust victims."
I suspect the killer of Iryna Zarutska - who has not yet been sentenced in over a year - will be set free.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.