Beneath the Gold: Exploring Gilded Age Extremes

NY History ^ | 2023 | Gina Modero

[CondoleezzaProtege]

New York City has long been a place of extremes. During the Gilded Age (about 1870 to 1900), the contrast in the way the wealthy and the poor lived in New York was drastic...

Photograph of William K. Vanderbilt’s home on the corner of Fifth Avenue and 52nd Street, where the lavish costume ball was held in 1883.

In stark contrast to lavish balls and mansions of the city’s wealthiest citizens, photojournalist Jacob Riis captured the shocking living conditions of New York’s poverty-stricken population in How the Other Half Lives: Studies among the Tenements of New York (1890). His photographs reveal in remarkable detail the hardships of poor New Yorkers and the misery of their living conditions...

“‘Poverty Gap’ family in their home. An English coal heaver’s home,” ca. 1872-1900.

[CondoleezzaProtege]

When the extremes become more stark, so too do the calls for socialism.

Capitalism thrives best when there's a healthy, thriving "in-between" aka: middle class.

[Cronos]

Correct, a healthy middle class is key

[Theophilus]

No matter how bad the living conditions ofvthe tenements may have been, millions upon millions continuously flocked to them, away from the tyrannies of old worlds to the liberties of the United States.

[Cronos]

Correct.

The USA succeeded because it built a middle class society where you could pull yourself out of poverty

[Chickensoup]

There was a book by a man called Samuel Levinson called EVERYTHING BUT MONEY which described living in the tenements of NYC in the 1880s 90s iirc

[mairdie]

Greatgrandfather's 3rd wife was part of that same NY 400 but, from what I heard, it sounds just as wild and nasty then as much of what you read about now.

Luckily, I descend from the second wife. Grandmother spent her life working in social work and for animal welfare. Bless her heart.

[CondoleezzaProtege]

Wow thank you for posting those exquisite photos and for sharing about your grandmother!

There are hard lessons to be learned from every era, and much to celebrate about the Gilded Age as well. I for one am encouraged by the increase in efforts to preserve and restore its architecture.

[CondoleezzaProtege]