Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

The Mystery of Britain's Irish King [29:29]
YouTube ^ | November 1, 2024 | Cambrian Chronicles (25,497 views!)

Posted on 11/01/2024 12:41:00 PM PDT by SunkenCiv

A strange and unknown story exists within the history of Wales: an Irish king in Wales, Serygei, and his defeat by the Welsh king Cadwallon on Ynys Mon (Anglesey). This video will trace the story across 1,500 of myths, legends, and rumours.
0:00 - Britain's Irish King
1:14 - Cadwallon
4:08 - Caergybi
6:15 - The 1700s
10:30 - The 1800s
14:14 - The 1900s
18:53 - The Irishman's Monuments
21:37 - Ynys Mon
24:02 - Serygei | Sirigi
26:36 - Maelgwn
The Mystery of Britain's Irish King | 29:29
Cambrian Chronicles | 201K subscribers | 25,497 views | November 1, 2024
The Mystery of Britain's Irish King | 29:29 | Cambrian Chronicles | 201K subscribers | 25,497 views | November 1, 2024

(Excerpt) Read more at youtube.com ...


TOPICS: History; Science; Travel
KEYWORDS: cadwallon; caergybi; cambrianchronicles; cerrigygwyddyl; cunedda; darkages; fartyshadesofgreen; godsgravesglyphs; ireland; llanygwyddyl; middleages; serygeiwyddel; wales; ynysmon
Transcript
·Britain's Irish King
0:04·1,500 years ago, in the west of Great Britain, we can find a reference to
0:08·an extremely unusual event. A man named Serygei 'Wyddel' is
0:14·slain in battle by a local king, who had apparently instructed his men to shackle
0:19·themselves to their horses before the fight, so that they wouldn't think about fleeing.
0:23·And while this is a bit odd on its own, what's weirder is that this story is the only mention
0:28·of this battle in any contemporary source, and the only mention ever of this name: Serygei.
0:37·Even stranger still, is his epithet, 'Wyddel', which is Welsh for 'the Irishman'.
0:44·An Irish king, with a name never found anywhere else, who ruled,
0:49·fought, and died… in Wales. Strange! Over the next millennia and a half, this
0:56·story would be transformed and adapted, leading to arguments over who the men involved really were,
1:01·where this battle really took place, or if it even really happened at all, until eventually,
1:06·it was almost forgotten entirely. This is the mystery of Britain's Irish king.
·Cadwallon
1:25·I am going to ask you to do a monstrous task: remember two people.
1:31·We've met the first one, Serygei, the Irishman. The second is his rival king,
1:36·Cadwallon [7], the "long arm". According to a 14th century bard, he received this epithet because his
1:44·arms could touch the ground when he was standing upright [2]... which I'm not sure is true.
1:50·Regardless, these men did apparently do battle, but the only medieval source ever mentioning this
1:55·is a Welsh Triad [7], a trio of short sentences designed to help a bard or poet's memory [6].
2:02·Basically, they were summaries, grouped with two other, similar summaries.
2:06·In this case, the men that fought in this battle were one of the three fettered,
2:11·or shackled, or torqued warbands of Britain, and they apparently fought Serygei at a place
2:17·known as Cerrig y Gwyddyl, the "Irishman's Rocks" on the island of Ynys Mon [7].
2:21·A place which is most commonly thought to be here [7][5], a field with the same name,
2:28·although both the rocks and the Irishman are no longer present.
2:33·And that's it. We have the summary, two men, a place, and nothing more.
2:39·And it's not unusual for these stories to be forgotten, plenty, if not the majority,
2:43·have been, but Cadwallon is a bit different, because he's claimed as one of the earliest
2:49·ancestors to the kings of what would become the most powerful kingdom in Wales [2]… you'd
2:54·think that would give him a bit of credit, but they didn't care about Cadwallon.
2:59·In the 9th century a big piece of propaganda for this kingdom, Gwynedd,
3:03·was produced [14]. They gave themselves a new ancestor: an apparent, and historically dubious,
3:09·grandfather for Cadwallon named Cunedda [18], and he was better than his grandson in every way.
3:16·Because while Cadwallon might have defeated an Irish king on Ynys Mon,
3:19·Cunedda supposedly defeated and drove out the Irish from the entire country [8][18].
3:25·Cadwallon was subsequently relegated to a name in a genealogy [2], his battle against an Irish
3:30·king was deemed chronologically impossible [8], left out of the royal origin stories, and then
3:36·completely forgotten by everyone. Sorry Cadwallon, maybe you should try being better next time.
3:47·Except… in one place. One place preserved the memory of Cadwallon and Serygei, but it wasn't
3:56·some village near the site of the battle, in fact it wasn't even on the same island.
4:01·Instead, the people of Caergybi, Holyhead in English, had a much
4:05·more unusual memory of these events.
·Caergybi
4:17·Near the very start of the 16th century,
4:19·a Welsh poet named Lewys Mon included an odd passage in one of his works.
4:25·He references this ancient battle between Cadwallon and the Irish,
4:28·a piece of history that, as we've seen, hadn't been popular for over 700 years.
4:34·One problem though, he doesn't mention Cerrig y Gwyddyl at all, instead he claims that the
4:40·battle was fought near Caergybi [9]. The historian Rachel Bromwich notes that
4:45·Lewys was from this area, so what we're seeing here is very likely a local story,
4:49·one that adopted a forgotten bit of history from centuries prior, and
4:52·moved it 1,931,208 cm north… or 12 miles [9]. And by the end of the century, we would see this
5:02·reinforced. In David Powel's 'Historie of Cambria' from 1584, the following passage is included:
5:09·"The Irish… did overrun the isle of Mon, and were driven thence by
5:13·Cadwallon Lawhir… who slew Serygei their king with his own hands at Llan y Gwyddyl,
5:20·which is the Irish church at Holyhead [46][5]". So here, we're introduced to another location,
5:26·the 'Church* of the Irishman', apparently the name of a church in Caergybi, and the new location of
5:32·Cadwallon and Serygei's fateful battle. So, these were both likely drawing on some
5:38·sort of local legend [9], moving this battle from Ynys Mon to Caergybi, and specifically to a church
5:44·named after the Irish. It was prominent enough to be featured in a book about the history of Wales,
5:50·which is more consideration than it ever got from the kings of Gwynedd, but unknown enough
5:54·for no one to question the final battle being at the previously unmentioned Llan y Gwyddyl.
6:01·And from here, the story would get picked up, by my count, 12 more times across the
6:07·next 4 centuries, which is one mention, on average, every 33.3 years, the same
6:12·amount that I mention my son that I hate.
·The 1700s
6:19·Now, if you've watched this channel before,
6:22·you won't be surprised to learn that, whilst researching this topic,
6:25·I got a little sidetracked asking: "How many times did this story come up,
6:29·where did it come up, and how much did it change over the course of approximately 400 years?"
6:34·And after spending an entire day researching it, I might as well tell you all about it,
6:38·otherwise this will all have been for nothing. …all….. for nothing…..
6:43·Although, this is an important question. As I said, the kings of Gwynedd didn't care about
6:47·this story at all, for the next four centuries it was entirely left to the folklore of a town that
6:52·wasn't even at the original battle site. Seeing how much Serygei's story changed can give us
6:57·insight not only into the local legends, but it may provide some clues into this lost event.
7:04·After 1584, the next time this story comes up is in an alleged account of Sir Richard Wynn
7:10·sometime in the 1600s that closely agrees with the 'Historie of Cambria', only adding the detail that
7:14·the Irish were "destroyed completely" [9]. I could then find nothing for about a century,
7:20·until the historian Peter Bartrum brought up a letter from 1733,
7:24·which mentioned that the "Bedd Serigin Wyddel" was one of the "marvels of Cybi" [5].
7:30·Now, "bedd" means grave, which is a very interesting detail because now Serygei
7:34·seems to have just been defeated at Caergybi, but apparently he had a grave, and a famous one.
7:41·But 42 years later is when we hit the real jackpot: 'A History of the Island of Anglesey',
7:46·which adds a lot of new details, some of which are a bit… questionable.
7:51·We're first told Cadwallon went to fight Serygei in the year 450, because these Irish had recently
7:57·invaded Ynys Mon and slain numerous people near a "strong fort" called Din Dryfol, at a
8:04·place that was now known as Cerrig y Gwyddyl. Cadwallon defeated them, and pushed them back
8:09·to Caergybi, where their fleet was docked, and slew Serygei with his own hands. He then built
8:15·a fortress, the walls currently around the church at Caergybi, which were apparently known as "Mur
8:20·Cadwallon", "Cadwallon's wall" [42]. The first detail that stands out is that
8:26·the author of this text brings back Cerrig y Gwyddyl, but instead of the site of their battle,
8:31·it seems to have commemorated a random slaughter. Cadwallon's actual first battle
8:43·location isn't named, but the final defeat is once again at the familiar Caergybi.
8:49·One more oddity is that the author claims these walls around the church were built by Cadwallon,
8:54·but in reality they're Roman, this was a Roman fort [aw]. Granted, the author probably didn't
9:00·know this, but the extra detail of the walls being named after Cadwallon is very interesting. Unless
9:06·they're mistaken, we can assume that it was again another local story, perhaps connecting
9:11·our Cadwallon to this fortress, although there's always the chance that it's named after someone
9:16·else. The walls were restored in the 17th century [aw], they could've picked up this name then.
9:23·The second piece of intrigue that this author tells us are the alleged details
9:26·of Serygei's grave. We've seen that this tradition already existed by 1733,
9:31·but we're now given much more detail. Apparently, Serygei was buried in the corner
9:36·of this Roman fort, and a chapel, called Eglwys y Bedd, the chapel of the grave,
9:41·was built on top of him. According to the author, this chapel was often
9:45·known to the Welsh… as Llan y Gwyddyl [43]. Finally, he claims that Serygei was made a
9:51·saint by the Irish, but that his shrine that used to be in the chapel was carried off by
9:57·Irish raiders, according to a… "chronicle" [43]. [show google earth, since wind sounds playing]
10:01·What we've seen here then is an odd marrying of the original Triad to the local folklore first
10:06·brought up in the 1500s. Cerrig y Gwyddyl is the site of a defeat, but Cadwallon isn't said to have
10:12·fought here. When he finally vanquished him, it was in Caergybi, in Llan y Gwyddyl, which
10:18·this author tells us is another name for this chapel of Eglwys y Bedd, finally
10:22·locating this previously unspecified place.
10:29·We have a few more texts in the 1800s.
·The 1800s
10:35·In 1824 we see this story again, although by now it's been acknowledged
10:39·that the walls of Caergybi are Roman [37]. But in 1833 we got a few more interesting details.
10:45·In this 'History of the Island of Mona', Cadwallon for the first time since the original Triad,
10:51·slays Serygei at Cerrig y Gwyddyl [39]… sort of. Because 152 pages later, we're back at Caergybi.
11:01·The author cites a letter from 1693 claiming that the ancient name of this place was Llan y Gwyddyl,
11:08·and that the chapel of Eglwys y Bedd got its name because of all the Welsh and Irish
11:12·that died during Cadwallon and Serygei's final encounter [40]... simultaneously claiming that
11:17·Serygei died twice, at two separate locations. Two sources from 1844 and 1879 both compound the
11:26·idea of Serygei being made a saint, with the first claiming he was canonised by the
11:30·Irish [47], and the latter by the Welsh [41]. And strangely, a book from 1852 then again claims
11:36·that Serygei was slain in two locations, Cerrig y Gwyddyl [48], and Llan y Gwyddyl, although
11:41·they claim that Cadwallon himself founded this chapel after his victory [49].
11:47·Finally, for this century, we have one more major lore drop. As we saw before, Cadwallon
11:52·was deemed less cool and propagandistic than his historically-dubious alleged grandfather Cunedda,
11:58·and if Cunedda drove out all the Irish, how could his grandson have defeated an Irish king?
12:05·Well, the historian R. Rees, in 'An Essay on the Welsh Saints' in 1836 answers this question,
12:11·by saying that Cunedda just… left Ynys Mon out, that the Irish retreated there, and that Cadwallon
12:17·dealt the final blow [44][45].
12:24·Wow. That was a lot of reading, and quite the work out for a guy like me who only learnt how to read 2 weeks ago.
12:30·But, to summarise what we've seen: The Welsh Triads tell us, briefly,
12:35·of an ancient battle between king Cadwallon of Gwynedd, and Serygei "the Irishman".
12:40·Cadwallon apparently defeated Serygei at Cerrig y Gwyddyl on Ynys Mon, but unfortunately for him,
12:44·by the 9th century, no one cared. However, by the 1500s, we find that the
12:50·town of Caergybi, 12 miles to the north, did actually care, and that they adopted
12:55·Cadwallon and Serygei's battle, moving the location to the nearby Llan y Gwyddyl.
13:01·From the 1500s to the end of the 1800s, we're told that the local chapel of Eglwys y Bedd is
13:06·the mystical Llan y Gwyddyl, and that Serygei was buried underneath. We're told that he was
13:11·canonised by the Irish, and maybe the Welsh too, but that his shrine was lost to Irish raiders… at
13:16·some point. We're finally told again that Serygei did die at Cerrig y Gwyddyl… but at the same time
13:23·they claim that he also died at Caergybi. It's a mess really, it's what you'd expect
13:27·from looking at 300 years of local stories, myths, and unsubstantiated claims. It's worth
13:33·acknowledging that these writers from centuries ago likely had access to sources we don't have,
13:38·but it's also worth noting that none of them have expanded on the details of the original Triad,
13:44·they seem to only have information on the more contemporary local legends,
13:49·and while some of their claims seem reasonable, a lot of them are unfortunately completely
13:53·unprovable, which we'll come to later. Finally, we come to the 20th century,
13:58·where this story was scrutinised further, but also covered in a very important work, just before
14:04·mentions of Serygei stopped almost entirely, as you can see from this almost comical graph.
·The 1900s
14:19·1903, 'A Book of North Wales' by S. Baring-Gould.
14:24·After reading so many texts inadvertently arguing with each other over whether Cadwallon
14:28·won at Cerrig y Gwyddyl, or at Caergybi, it was a massive relief to finally see something different,
14:34·because Baring-Gould claimed this king won several battles at Irish strongholds before
14:40·pushing the them back to Caergybi, and the example he gives is a battle at Din Sylwy [32]… over here,
14:48·all the way to the east. Of course by "reliving",
14:52·I mean massively confusing. I spent ages trying to find where else had this battle been mentioned,
14:58·or been called an Irish fortress? I couldn't find anything, and the reason
15:02·for that will become clear in a few minutes. Moving on for now, the rest of the details are
15:07·mostly what we've seen already. Cadwallon slays Serygei by his own hand in Llan y Gwyddyl, which
15:12·was constructed on the spot that he died [32]. Baring-Gould calls the Welsh "freaky"
15:16·for glorifying an enemy commander, compares this to the glorification of the Boers [32], and says
15:21·that the walls of Caergybi are so uncouth that they cannot possibly have been Norman, or Roman,
15:26·so therefore must have been Welsh [34]... rude! Finally, he claims that this beautiful depiction
15:34·on the church is of Serygei holding a short sword [34]. Unfortunately this isn't provable, it could
15:43·be him, although no one else has ever mentioned this, and I think he might be holding a trowel.
15:49·Or at least that's what I first thought, because towards the end of my research I found a book
15:54·from 1913 that was quite critical of some elements of the local legend,
15:59·particularly of those brought up in the 'History of the Island of Anglesey', and they also claimed
16:04·that this was a statue of Serygei [35]. Asides from that, they also question if Serygei
16:09·was actually ever made a saint, there aren't any other references to him in Wales, and apparently
16:14·the Irish don't ever mention him either [35], and in another blow they point out that the author of
16:18·the original claim that Serygei had a shrine that was carried off by Irish raiders, never specifies
16:23·where he got this information from, casting doubt on the entire idea of him being canonised [35].
16:30·Their criticism of the 1775 source is great, but seeing another claim that this statue was
16:34·Serygei caught me off guard, because I wasn't expecting to find an actual depiction of him,
16:38·let alone two claims of one… until I noticed the author of the book… S. Baring-Gould [35].
16:46·Nice try, he almost got me, but in the end Mr Baring-Gould is still the only person to
16:51·ever claim that this statue is Serygei. Finally, we come to the last text I want
16:58·to mention, and the last major appearance Serygei and his story ever really made.
17:04·The 1912 publication 'A History of Wales' by John Edward Lloyd, a man
17:08·nicknamed the "father" of Welsh history [19]. Lloyd's work is different to everything we've
17:13·seen so far, because this was a proper historical book with sources and citations and analysis,
17:18·rather than local stories with unsubstantiated claims, and of all the claims made over the
17:23·centuries, Lloyd relays very, very few of them. He brings the story back to the original Triad,
17:30·one of the very few authors who did, by telling us that, according to tradition,
17:34·Cadwallon completed the conquest of North Wales from the Irish, that he shackled his men to their
17:39·horses so that "victory and death" were the only outcomes, and finally that he defeated
17:44·Serygei at… Cerrig y Gwyddyl, not Caergybi [38]. Sweeping away the evolving tale that we've just
17:50·seen woven over the past 300 years. He does, however, reconcile one of the
17:56·oldest details I mentioned, Llan y Gwyddyl, an unspecified chapel near Caergybi that was
18:01·eventually claimed as an alternate name for the local chapel of Eglwys y Bedd.
18:06·Lloyd notes that in the parish of Tywyn, 55 miles to the south, there is a stone circle
18:11·with the name "Eglwys y Gwyddyl" - "chapel of the Irishman". He reasons that, if these stones can be
18:18·known as an Irish chapel… who's to say that our "Irishman's Rocks" and "Church of the Irishman"
18:23·aren't two names for the same place [38]? The source he cites also makes a very unusual
18:29·point that I'd never heard before, the author here claims that apparently it's quite common
18:34·in Wales to name "traces of ancient houses or walls" after the Irish [36]. And while
18:39·that isn't very specific, I think I found what he was talking about, because while there are a few
18:44·examples of medieval structures being named after the Gwyddel… the vast majority of the
18:49·objects bearing their names...
18:51·are ancient.
·The Irishman's Monuments
18:57·Cerrig-y-Gwyddyl [5], Cerrig-Gwyddyl [5], Craig-y-Gwyddyl, Crugyn Gwyddel
18:59·[23], Tomen-y-Gwyddel [24], Bryn-y-Gwyddel, Bedd-y-Gwyddel,
19:03·Eglwys-y-Gwyddelod [20], Eglwys-y-Gwyddelod 2 [22], Muriau'r Gwyddelod [25],
19:07·and Irish Joe's Cafe in Rhyl
19:09·… wait.
19:14·All across Wales we can find
19:16·ancient monuments named after the Irish. Although looking at this map I think
19:20·you'll be able to see a very interesting pattern. There are only 2 in south Wales,
19:25·2 in Powys, one in Ceredigion, and 5 in Gwynedd. What's even more strange is that this isn't all of
19:32·them, because there are 7 more that are not only named after the Irish, but that all have the same
19:37·name: Cytiau'r Gwyddelod, "Irishman's huts". And of these 7 Irishman's huts,
19:44·all of them are located in western Gwynedd [27][29][21], and 3 of them
19:48·are found in the vicinity… of Caergybi [9]. These huts are a series of roundhouses that
19:54·are at least 2,500 years old [26][30]. There are the remains of 20 to the west of the town today,
19:59·but there could have once been as many as 50 [26][30], not to mention the ones found
20:03·to the south [29] and the east [27]. And these circular huts are the reason
20:07·why Baring-Gould thought Din Sylwy was an Irish fortress! Do you remember when I said
20:12·we'd come back to that? Well after I spent ages trying to find where he got this from,
20:17·I eventually discovered it was his own theory. He claimed that there are faint traces of these
20:22·cytiau within the ancient fort, and despite the various Roman-era findings, he believed
20:27·that it must date to the post Roman Irish [33]. You may not be surprised to learn that that isn't
20:32·considered very historically accurate nowadays. There is apparently a circular structure inside,
20:38·but the place was full of Roman artefacts, and Iron-age one [28], meaning the fort was
20:42·very likely built by the Britons, not the Irish, and that Cadwallon probably didn't
20:46·besiege an Irish king here.
20:52·But what we can say for certain,
20:54·is that there is a prevailing mythology across Wales, particularly in western Gwynedd,
20:59·that associates several ancient stone monuments with the Irish, and Cerrig-y-Gwyddyl, whatever
21:05·these 'stones' once were, is no exception. This isn't a story you can read about, it's one
21:11·that I found accidentally while researching this topic [36][9] and spending the day going through
21:15·archeological databases, but it is there. And it is especially dense around Caergybi,
21:22·right where local tradition would claim Cadwallon slew Serygei, right where the Irish king of
21:27·Ynys Mon was supposedly defeated, and buried.
21:36·Is this why these stories became connected? The
·Ynys Mon
21:39·Irish king dying in the town surrounded by the Irishman's huts? Maybe, or maybe not,
21:46·we don't know. And to be honest, we can't know. The details, as we've seen, are extremely difficult to parse.
21:55·The historian Rachel Bromwich points
21:57·out the connection to these Irishman's huts, but she also says that the location of Caergybi is
22:02·a "probable enough" site for the battle [9]. A historian in 1904 theorised that Serygei was
22:07·a corrupted Norse name, and that this story must be from way later, and just… randomly
22:12·connected to an otherwise unknown 5th century king [10]. The modern historians Bartrum and
22:17·Bromwich both disagree with this though [10][5], with the former stating that there probably is a
22:21·historical basis for this story, and the latter suggesting that Serygei was instead some sort
22:25·of corrupted Irish name, which would make sense, although as I said at the very start, this is the
22:30·only time this name has ever occurred, we have no idea what it originally was in Irish [5].
22:37·And it's no wonder that even the name of Cadwallon's opponent was forgotten,
22:40·because as I've already said, none of the details of this story survive. In the minds
22:45·of the 9th century kings of Gwynedd, Cadwallon's historically dubious grandfather did all the work,
22:50·driving out the Irish, giving Gwynedd a totally unbiased claim to the entire country [18], and
22:54·leaving these people as nothing more than the apparent creators of these ancient monuments.
23:01·This does, of course, disagree with a lot of historical evidence… actually any historical
23:06·evidence. It's completely chronologically possible that Cadwallon fought an Irish king
23:11·around the year 500, according to Bromwich [8], as inscribed stones have been found across Wales
23:16·bearing Irish names that continued into the 6th century [8][17], both in Latin,
23:20·and in the old Irish alphabet Ogham [11]. In fact, according to the historian T.
23:25·Charles-Edwards, their presence on Ynys Mon is particularly noticeable,
23:29·where we have four definite Irish inscribed names, and no definite Welsh ones [12][13].
23:37·The Irish were prominent in Wales, both here in Gwynedd and beyond, despite what their kings would
23:42·have you believe. They left inscribed stones [13], they left place names [14], and in the south,
23:46·they even had an entire dynasty [16][14][17], so it's not at all out of the question that at around
23:51·the year 500, a Welsh king could have fought and defeated an Irish one on Ynys Mon [8][5].
·Serygei | Sirigi
24:02·But that's all we can really know, that the Irish were here,
24:07·and that the kings of Gwynedd soon made their home
24:09·on this island for the next 700 years [18]. Cadwallon apparently had his court here in
24:15·northern Ynys Mon [2], and the chief court of the kings of Gwynedd would be here at
24:19·Aberffraw [15], to the south. Cadwallon's alleged son, king Maelgwn, also apparently possessed the
24:25·Roman fort at Caergybi [3]. His great-great-great grandson was buried on this island, and his
24:31·gravestone rests in a church that was rebuilt and named after his son, Cadwallon's alleged
24:37·great-great-great-great-great grandson [1]. Gwynedd's link to this island was also
24:43·strengthened in their own 9th century propaganda, where Cunedda not only drove the Irish out of
24:48·all of Wales, but his almost certainly mythical sons also founded numerous kingdoms in the area,
24:54·covering what was at the time all of Gwynedd… giving them an ancestral claim
24:58·to almost all of their lands... except for the territories known as Arfon,
25:03·and the island of Ynys Mon [14][18]. Their hold was clearly strong enough here, that they saw no
25:09·need to fabricate some sort of ancient claim. So, did Cadwallon conquer Ynys Mon from an
25:16·Irish king? It seems so, at the very least it's plausible [9][5]. Was there
25:21·a battle at Cerrig-y-Gwyddel? Probably, but was it at this field? We don't know,
25:26·there was a Cerrig-Gwyddyl on the eastern side of the island [5], and the original location
25:31·easily also could've just been lost. By the 16th century, Cadwallon had also
25:36·supposedly slain Serygei at Llan y Gwyddyl in Caergybi, but we don't know where this came
25:40·from. Is it a lost detail from the original story? Was it really just an alternate name
25:45·for Cerrig-y-Gwyddel? Bartrum points out that in a 13th century genealogy, the battle takes
25:51·place at Llam y Gwyddyl, "Irishman's leap", and he suggests that Llan y Gwyddyl was just a later
25:58·mistake [5]. If that's the case, then where's Llam y Gwyddyl? Where did this detail come from?
26:04·Was this a place near Caergybi, where the tale then could've easily been adopted by the locals,
26:09·or was Llan y Gwyddyl really a local chapel, allowing the two names to easily conflate?
26:15·We don't know, we can't know, in fact… we might never know,
26:20·this is a story from 1,500 years ago, it's a miracle we know anything about it at all.
26:35·All we can say then is that Cadwallon probably slew an Irish king named Serygei at a place called
·Maelgwn
26:41·Cerrig-y-Gwyddel somewhere on Ynys Mon. Were there more battles? Almost certainly,
26:54·the existence of this Triad proves that there was a story that needed to be remembered,
26:59·but whatever that story was, has been forgotten. Maybe there was a final encounter at Caergybi,
27:05·and while Serygei probably wasn't slain there, and he almost certainly wasn't buried underneath
27:09·Eglwys y Bedd, for a very long time, to a lot of people, this story was important,
27:13·and that's worth something. Cadwallon's alleged son held this fortress [3], who's
27:18·to say that his father's final victory wasn't in the Roman walls of Caergybi?
27:25·We don't know exactly what happened to king Cadwallon. The rulers of Gwynedd claimed him
27:29·as their ancestor, and according to them his successor was a man named Maelgwn,
27:34·who they claimed was his son, but as I've alluded to throughout the video, history
27:39·can be a lot more complicated than that [2]. In the mid-6th century, a monk wrote an angry
27:45·sermon, blaming the Briton's problems on their violent and tyrannical kings,
27:50·which included Maelgwn, who the monk claimed had come to the throne at a young age…
27:55·by killing his mother's brother [4]. Was Cadwallon really Maelgwn's father,
28:02·or was he his uncle [31]? Was Maelgwn's ancestry rewritten to include descent from a known figure,
28:08·the man who conquered Ynys Mon, rather than whoever his real father was? Or was
28:13·Maelgwn really his son? Did Cadwallon's unknown brother-in-law just rule upon his death until
28:18·Maelgwn took the throne from him? We don't know. All we have on Cadwallon is essentially a blurb,
28:25·the kings of Gwynedd were happy to claim descent from him, happy to claim that his
28:28·potentially murderous nephew was really his son, and happy to rule from the island he conquered,
28:34·but his story, his legend, wasn't good enough, except for the people of Caergybi.
28:42·These Roman walls contain a church today, dedicated to the eponymous St Cybi,
28:47·who was given the fortress in the 6th century by king Maelgwn [3]. Cadwallon's supposed son,
28:53·at the site of his supposed victory. And in 1748, having gone disused for many years,
29:03·Eglwys y Bedd was partially torn down [34].
29:07·Thank you for watching.

1 posted on 11/01/2024 12:41:00 PM PDT by SunkenCiv
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: StayAt HomeMother; Ernest_at_the_Beach; 1ofmanyfree; 21twelve; 24Karet; 2ndDivisionVet; 31R1O; ...
The transcript must have been provided, since the footnotes are actually in the YouTube transcript. I wish more of the content creators would do that.

2 posted on 11/01/2024 12:47:59 PM PDT by SunkenCiv (Putin should skip ahead to where he kills himself in the bunker.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: SunkenCiv

Interesting


3 posted on 11/01/2024 1:00:38 PM PDT by ComputerGuy (Heavily-medicated for your protection)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: SunkenCiv
The legendary King Arthur was Cornish, from Tintagel Castle, Cornwall. So that would make Arthur a Celt.

4 posted on 11/01/2024 2:05:10 PM PDT by Governor Dinwiddie (O give thanks unto the Lord, for He is gracious, and His mercy endureth forever. — Psalm 106)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Governor Dinwiddie

Tintagel’s true scale wasn’t understood until the 1980s. After centuries of denial, a drought led to a grass fire so intense it burned away the apparently thin turf covering over 200 ruined buildings. No one had noticed them before. :^)

If indeed there was a King Arthur, it’s more likely that every distorted piece of folklore referring to various post-Roman local lords (Romano-British at best, probably) wound up grafted into a single quite recent (15th c) legend.

Vortigern was historical, and probably wasn’t rival or archenemy of Arthur, but formed a good bit of the basis for the King Arthur composite. There’s actually a very old medieval burial monument in England (a part that used to be Wales) that states that the historic king buried there is a descendant of Vortigern.

Another part of the composite seems to be Magnus Maximus, a 4th c Roman governor of Britain who also vied for the emperor’s job, went to the mainland (as one story has Arthur doing), and died in battle trying.

Even in what is now Scotland there’s an Arthur’s Seat, which probably has nothing to do with the rest of the legend and was given the name much later on.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Excidio_et_Conquestu_Britanniae

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Arthurian_literature_in_Latin

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nennius

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matter_of_Britain

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vortigern#Pillar_of_Eliseg

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geoffrey_of_Monmouth

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chr%C3%A9tien_de_Troyes

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welsh_Triads

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mabinogion


5 posted on 11/01/2024 2:58:12 PM PDT by SunkenCiv (Putin should skip ahead to where he kills himself in the bunker.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: SunkenCiv

This guy has the best videos on Youtube. I have watched several of them numerous times, not just for the history, but, his take on Information.

I’m a Librarian(retired). Getting information correct is a passion for me.

I’d rather admit I was wrong, than defend bad information every time.


6 posted on 11/01/2024 3:02:07 PM PDT by Conan the Librarian (Conan the Sailing Librarian)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Governor Dinwiddie

Watch this guys video of King Arthur.

There WAS no King Arthur. Anything close would have either been Irish or Roman, but, there wasn’t one man.


7 posted on 11/01/2024 3:03:17 PM PDT by Conan the Librarian (Conan the Sailing Librarian)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: Conan the Librarian

Hell, ya haven’t lived until you’ve defended bad information, else, why be interested in politics? :^)


8 posted on 11/01/2024 3:19:12 PM PDT by SunkenCiv (Putin should skip ahead to where he kills himself in the bunker.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 6 | View Replies]

To: Conan the Librarian

Also see my #5 above. :^)

British figures about whom the most books have been written probably (not sure of the order) are Shakespeare, King Arthur, and Robin Hood. :^)

I read this one years ago, it’s still in print, but I like cheap.

https://www.thriftbooks.com/w/king-arthur-the-true-story_graham-phillips_martin-keatman/422768/


9 posted on 11/01/2024 3:23:20 PM PDT by SunkenCiv (Putin should skip ahead to where he kills himself in the bunker.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

To: Conan the Librarian

I’d watched other vids of his, probably even posted at least one, but hadn’t saved the link to his video YouTube channel. Just added it.

https://www.youtube.com/@CambrianChronicles/videos


10 posted on 11/01/2024 3:29:48 PM PDT by SunkenCiv (Putin should skip ahead to where he kills himself in the bunker.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 6 | View Replies]

To: SunkenCiv

bump


11 posted on 11/01/2024 3:46:36 PM PDT by Albion Wilde (“Did you ever meet a woke person that’s happy? There’s no such thing.” —Donald J. Trump)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SunkenCiv

Bkmk


12 posted on 11/01/2024 7:55:58 PM PDT by sauropod ("This is a time when people reveal themselves for who they are." James O'Keefe Ne supra crepidam)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

The name Camelot appears to have been taken from Camulodunum, the Roman name for modern Colchester, and their provincial capital. Probably was invented for the relatively modern Arthurian legends.

Mary Stewart’s take on it (if memory serves) was that it was built along the River Camel. The better known one is in Cornwall, but there are streams that are called rivers known as Camel, apparently.

There’s also the River Cam that flows through Cambridge, so the name Camelot would mean something like Ford of the Camel.

Geographically Cambridge is more centered in the apparent core of a post-Roman realm which had Hadrian’s Wall on the north, so-called Offa’s Dyke on the west, the Wansdyke on the south, and the Cardyke — a Roman canal — either as its east frontier or the core of the polity.

https://wikishire.co.uk/wiki/River_Camel

https://wrt.org.uk/project/river-camel/

https://www.wadebridgemuseum.co.uk/river.html

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/River_Cam

https://peterborougharchaeology.org/car-dyke/

http://www.lincsmag.com/Lincolnshire/001_LINCOLNSHIRE_ROMANS_Bruce_Barrymore_Halpenny.html

Britain’s oldest canal in Lincolnshire is up for sale
https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-lincolnshire-48908186


13 posted on 11/01/2024 8:20:54 PM PDT by SunkenCiv (Putin should skip ahead to where he kills himself in the bunker.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: SunkenCiv

I have a hard time of it. I got my MLS back in the day when they taught you about Primary resources, and, ethical actions.

I fear that has left the discipline :(


14 posted on 11/01/2024 9:17:21 PM PDT by Conan the Librarian (Conan the Sailing Librarian)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 8 | View Replies]

To: SunkenCiv

Great! My only complaint is that he doesn’t post often enough.


15 posted on 11/01/2024 9:18:56 PM PDT by Conan the Librarian (Conan the Sailing Librarian)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 10 | View Replies]

To: Conan the Librarian

It has left pretty much every discipline, in that it’s widely tolerated.


16 posted on 11/02/2024 5:39:15 AM PDT by SunkenCiv (Putin should skip ahead to where he kills himself in the bunker.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 14 | View Replies]

To: Conan the Librarian

He probably requires more time for research, it’s not like Simon Whistler, he’s just the face of that multi-channel operation.


17 posted on 11/02/2024 5:49:16 AM PDT by SunkenCiv (Putin should skip ahead to where he kills himself in the bunker.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 15 | View Replies]

To: SunkenCiv

I am sure. But, his videos are VERY entertaining and compelling.

The King Arthur one is a lecture on proper sources all by itself.


18 posted on 11/02/2024 9:39:56 AM PDT by Conan the Librarian (Conan the Sailing Librarian)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 17 | View Replies]

To: Conan the Librarian

Definitely. I think I’ve posted a couple before.


19 posted on 11/02/2024 9:59:27 AM PDT by SunkenCiv (Putin should skip ahead to where he kills himself in the bunker.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 18 | View Replies]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson