Mclellan was one of the finest training officers in the history of the US Army. However, being a good trainer doesn’t translate into being a good battlefield commander.
That's right. Just take the case of Capt. Sobel as another example.
The USMC officer's Mameluke Sword was first adopted (officially) in 1825, but was dropped from the uniform for a period between 1859–1875 before again becoming part of the uniform.