Posted on 10/27/2020 11:30:50 AM PDT by Heartlander
I grew up in a socialist society, but I’ve found it hard sometimes to talk about socialism in America. When people like me identify the blatant failures of socialism, its advocates often argue that the socialist countries we’re talking about are “not really socialist.” In other words, no true socialism has ever existed. Hence, there is a need to practice true socialism here in America.
I think socialism should be defined based on historical facts, not on utopian fantasies that exist only in its campaigners’ heads. It’s like a mirage: it only looks good from a distance. That’s why its advocates are usually those who have never lived in a socialist place. But I have. I know what socialism is like because I did not view it from afar. I was in it.
In socialist societies such as, China, Cuba, North Korea, Poland, Romania, the Soviet Union, Slovakia, Ukraine, Venezuela, just to name a few, past and present, everything belongs to the centralized government, which directs and plans the economy. There is no private property.
The purpose of the system is to distribute wealth equally and to end inequality and poverty. On paper it sounds very attractive. In reality, all socialist countries end up in one place: shattered economies, poverty and the destruction of civilization. My own childhood experience illustrates this.
But the most devastating effect of socialism is not economic. Power corrupts human beings. People inevitably abuse and misuse it.
(Excerpt) Read more at stream.org ...
Reading about it is one thing ... experiencing it firsthand (over the past eight months as the governors continue to suspend the Constitution without challenge) is something else. It should be eye-opening to any American except that many American women and “men” keep their eyes closed from abject fear of the Chinese flu.
“Everything and everyone must support the Party!”
The Democrat Party.
Nations hostile to the US are using the Democrat Party to weaken the US.
Look at how the Chinese communist leaders treat people.
Who wants that in the US?
After the collapse of the USSR, life was pretty bad for most of it’s citizens in the 1990s as they worked toward the Russian version of capitalism.
There’s a guy on Youtube who was born and raised to early adulthood in the USSR (Kiev) before coming to the US. He has a lot of interesting insights on the realities of life under socialism, for example:
“Five reasons why the Russian people still miss the USSR”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-p3IxqcDRM4
The writer starts from the WRONG premise. This is NOT the purpose of socialism. The purpose of socialism is to coalesce all economic and political power in the hands of a few oligarchs. They may state the above premise along the way, but that is just for the benefit of the stupid people who think this way.
I took a business trip with a died in the wool Democrat and had a lot of discussions with him. I recounted how my parents home had stabilizing bars on their showers and bathtub. He thought that was such a good idea that he proposed that builders be required to install them when a house was built. That way everyone would have the bars.
Later, I realized that there was an immediate comeback which I should have employed: I totally agree with your proposal, except, the my short mother used the tub and my tall father used the shower. The bars were installed with their height in mind. How is it that the builders are to know this in advance??
The essence of the socialist fallacy is in all situations: One size fits all. Choice by the consumer is unnecessary and wasteful.
Thus, in 1999, we had a Polish foreign exchange student living with us in Arizona. Poland was still recovering from the Soviet occupation. She was taken aback at the grocery store by all the choices that could be made. When we took her to a sports store to get a tennis racket, it took her forever to pick one out. She was not used to the idea of comparing products in order to make a purchase.
To a socialist, or a Democrat, One Size Fits All! Rejection of that idea was the primary reason that President Trump left the details of handling Covid-19 to the states. Some used draconian measures which resulted in killing people while a few others were closer to the Swedish model. But it was their choice!
Great article.
I would also say, that Socialism kills iniative and innovation. People will reject that when they see they are sinking towards poverty. So to maintain power, the socialist system must begin to censure and promote a history that didn’t exist in order to promote a reality that seems better than it is.
Maintaining a socialist system requires totalitarianism or it will be eventually rejected when people realize it failed to deliver on it’s promises. And will probably sooner than later.
The only question is how long the populace will tolerate the totalitarianism and how much blood will be shed to overthrow it.
Why is this always so easy for all of us to understand on our side and yet the other side is blind? There has to be some biological and psychological makeup of those who think a certain way. Socialism and all associated “isms” should horrify people but these leftists watch their cities go up in flames and they celebrate. They teach all of this leftists crap in our polluted education system.
Do you agree with this:
I think socialism attracts people who want and love power. The people who get the power love to control others. The people at the bottom just want to be cared for, but they learn that their love for security is slavery.
I’ve always lived in America; my family helped start America. And even though I have never lived in socialistic country, I HATE socialism
I would heartily recommend that YouTube channel, The Ushanka Show.
It’s creator grew-up on Soviet Ukraine before emigrating to the US and settling in Michigan. His videos are very well-produced and presented in a very straightforward, factual way.
It’s been 30 years since the wall came down. This stuff is going to disappear down the memory hole if people like this fellow don’t start recording it.
” ... can’t afford a thing on TV. “
Ever notice that no one ever says “’Nationalist Socialism (Nazi)’ has never been done right, but we’ll do it right the next time!”
Once was enough!
The true purpose of socialism is the redistribution of wealth to the redistributors, their goons, cronies, minions and families.
Because some people insist on keeping their stuff, socialists require goons to take it by force. The goons then keep the stuff and get rid of the socialists too but continue to call themselves socialists. The “right people” don’t get to run socialism because they are dead.
Yep. One of the most arrogant and evil things a person can say. But they always say it.
Has a hillary vibe?
He is interesting and has a lot of history to tell from experience.
The only thing is the Russian/Ukraine accent - to my ear it always sounds like the speakers are complaining when they speak in a normal conversational voice, heh.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.