I am shocked.
Its similar to the drink 8 glasses of water a day. I never once heard that phrase in Med School but every layman seems to know it.
I worked in the telecom business. There is a measure called service level. It has been a standard for decades. Billions of telephone calls have been measured against it.
How did it come about?
The engineers who installed the first system had to enter a default. So they stuck in a variation of the Pareto ratio. And for about the past forty years, the staffing of call centers have been calculated to a standard not based on any reality. And it hasnt changed much to this day.
For those that stepped off the edge of the Grand Canyon, they took one too many.
This is such a flawed study. If you are already in poor health you aren’t walking 4000 steps no matter what. What the study shows is people who are in good health are going to live longer.
Minimum of 6,500 steps a day keeps my rhm at 50-55 bpm.
Who needs 10 extra years in a ‘facility’?
“They didn’t need to go the gym or invest in a personal trainer or exercise equipment,” she says. All they had to do was walk.”
Nor will most of them not need knee or hip replacements due to running on the streets.
One of my younger female siblings cracked this code decades ago after her youngest child was born.
She started walking 2-3 miles, 5 days per week. She, also, gets up every hour during the day, for about 5 minutes of standing/walking instead of sitting for hours at a time.
She is in her mid 70’s and weighs the same as she did at age 18.
Her walking gear: good walking shoes and sweats or jeans and a T or sweatshirt. She gets a new pair of walking shoes every year on her birthday. She buys a pack of all cotton socks at Costco about every 3 months.
Her lab values, ekg’s and bp measurements look like those of a young female athlete.
She, like us, lives on the Mediterranean Diet with zero processed foods and artificial flavorings. Carbs are minimal in her diet.
She loves dogs and is on their 5th dog. Those dogs walked with her every day.
We have a neighbor, who is the same age and looks like a 20/30 year old. She is on her 3rd walking dog. They walk every day up and down the hills for 3-4 miles. Her mother recently died at age 96 and was a walker.
I’m doing almost two miles a day, seven days a week. I don’t know how many steps that is. Two of my sisters have passed away, both my parents are gone from heart failure and my two brothers have had heart surgery and at least one has had a heart attack.
I guess I’ll know soon if it’s working.
Why, Ward Cleaver used to walk 20 miles per day!
“It turns out that women who took about 4,000 steps per day got a boost in longevity, compared with women who took fewer steps. “It was sort of surprising,” Lee says.”
Did they adjust for other factors, such as diet, genetics, initial health condition, etc.?
Thanks for posting. This is one of those examples where statistics tell us one thing but the results can vary widely. And in this case, it’s because the increase in heart rate is what likely causes the benefit not the steps themselves.
Many decades ago I was a very successful nationally ranked endurance athlete. In the early 1980s heart rate monitors which were battery powered and could be used to monitor and record your training performance became available and were an amazing development.
For maximum training benefit it is best to keep your heart rate above a certain level that varies from individual to individual but also depends on your fitness level and other factors. It is not surprising to me at all that no statistical benefit was found for women who walked more than a certain ammount, but I would not make the same assumptions as to why, as some here do.
If someone is walking at a place that raises their resting heart rate from 60 up to 90 while walking... there may be no training benefit at all other than it is better not to be sitting all day. When I was training for endurance events I typically preferred to keep my heart rate above 70% of my maximum heart rate for an extended period of time. Walking would have had no benefit to my training regimen at that time. Now that I am a fat old man, walking has some benefit to me. how much depends a great deal on ones fitness level and age.
Enough exercise to keep the blood flowing and the joints moving is great for older folks...trying to do it like when you were 25 or 45 or 60 can be detrimental.
My 69 year old wife was trying to do some serious training on the treadmill and had to stop every mile or so to catch her breath...I finally convinced her to slow to a pace (and elevation) that allowed her to do at least 3 miles w/o being worn out and she has lots more energy these days...
I keep my heart rate around 120 to 130 (supposedly between endurance and athletic training for my 66 years) instead of the 140-160 I was doing and have started skipping 2 days between weight training and I also have more energy.
Between football, track, delivering mail, the military, walking to work, jogging into my 70’s, etc I’ve probably trod the circumference of the globe. All it got me is a collapsed arch, an ankle foot orthoses and a handicapped parking placard.
I’m 58 and do some crossfit type classes for an hour. I try to go at least twice a week. Drenched with sweat at the end of each class. Starting to walk around the block with the wife for some extra movement.
I’m a hostess in a Las Vegas buffet. I average about 15,000 steps a day! Yesterday after walking the dog and work, over 20,000.
This is an app you can get for your phone. Reminds you to move when you have a sedentary desk job.
FitTime5
Get it at the app store. I think its free.
The secret to longevity - remain breathing.