Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

How the Founders Sowed the Seeds of Civil War
history.org ^ | W. Barksdale Maynard

Posted on 01/09/2016 8:11:03 AM PST by Citizen Zed

American slavery was a hybrid of seventeenth-century English mercantilism, colonial labor shortages, and what we call racism. It was an evil which, in the interests of revolutionary unity, the Second Continental Congress declined to eradicate in the Declaration of Independence, and which the Articles of Confederation left to blight the Constitution.

Slavery's taproot was the three-fifths clause, cultivated in the steamy Philadelphia summer of 1787, as a nation struggled to be born. After weeks of debate, the delegates to the Constitutional Convention faced an impasse, and it seemed the fragile project of national reorganization might collapse. Then, on July 16, they reached the Connecticut Compromise, a deal that broke a deadlock and cleared the way for the arrival of a strong federal union to replace a loose confederacy of states.

What was central to that deal? The agreement that membership in the House of Representatives would be apportioned according to the white population of each state—plus three-fifths of their slaves.

Thus was a nation founded on quicksand, some historians say.

(Excerpt) Read more at history.org ...


TOPICS: Chit/Chat
KEYWORDS:
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-40, 41-60, 61-75 next last
I wonder if a Convention of States might conflates states' rights with political agendas, deconstructing bedrocks that have affirmed states' rights. Also might a convention delve into areas better suited for absolute federal power? And then could a president call a con con a coup and use his powers to put it down? Could we be headed for a Mexican standoff between the three branches? Could we be headed for civil war?
1 posted on 01/09/2016 8:11:03 AM PST by Citizen Zed
[ Post Reply]

To: Citizen Zed

And South Caroline and Georgia would refuse to join the Union unless concessions to the slave trade were made in the Constitution. More seeds planted.


2 posted on 01/09/2016 8:16:49 AM PST by SkyDancer ("Nobody Said I Was Perfect But Yet Here I Am")
[ Post Reply]

To: Citizen Zed

If so, let it be. That tree of freedom is only watered by the blood of patriots.


3 posted on 01/09/2016 8:18:27 AM PST by shankbear (The tree of Liberty appears to be perishing because there are few patriots willing to refresh it.)
[ Post Reply]

To: Citizen Zed

It wasn’t the three-fifths compromise that sustained slavery. It was the fugitive slave clause. One could argue that the three fifths compromise led to the war since the yankees saw it as a check on their mercantilist ambitions.


4 posted on 01/09/2016 8:18:55 AM PST by SeeSharp
[ Post Reply]

To: SeeSharp
FTA: "...although southern delegates wanted to count slaves equally with whites. Northern delegates wanted slaves not to count at all. It was about regional power, not the humanity of the enslaved.”
5 posted on 01/09/2016 8:30:00 AM PST by ex91B10 (We've tried the Soap Box,the Ballot Box and the Jury Box; ONE BOX LEFT!)
[ Post Reply]

To: SkyDancer

That is true, but it was the vote of Massachusetts which put slave trade over the top. They wanted the lower cost trade from the South.


6 posted on 01/09/2016 8:32:04 AM PST by impactplayer
[ Post Reply]

To: impactplayer

Yep. They wanted it but didn’t want it.


7 posted on 01/09/2016 8:33:10 AM PST by SkyDancer ("Nobody Said I Was Perfect But Yet Here I Am")
[ Post Reply]

To: Citizen Zed

BernStein is a sophmoric fool. Everything is much simpler in retrospect. The entire concept of a Republic with citizens instead of a monarchy with subjects was a new thing, as was the concept of equality. So Bernstein, typical liberal dog in a Manger, should go pound salt.


8 posted on 01/09/2016 8:38:04 AM PST by ZULU (Mt. McKinley is the tallest mountain in N. America. Denali is Aleut for "scam artist.")
[ Post Reply]

To: Citizen Zed

They need to stop it with the racism aspect of slavery. The Irish were the first slaves in the New World. I believe Irish slavery existed here for longer than African salvery, too.


9 posted on 01/09/2016 8:39:23 AM PST by 5thGenTexan
[ Post Reply]

To: Citizen Zed

At least the author is honest in admitting that the slave states wanted to count slaves as one person for purposes of representation. He leaves out the other side of the equation—that slaves would also be counted as 3/5 for purposes of taxation. And everyone forgets that Indians weren’t to be counted at all.

He manages to find fault with the Northwest Ordinance which banned slavery north of the Ohio because settlers didn’t like black people. What? And even though Congress banned the overseas slave trade as soon as it was Constitutionally able to do so (20 years), the Founders don’t get credit for that either.

I do agree that slavery looked like a dead-end for economic reasons in the late 1780s. Why tear apart the country over something that was clearly on the way out? They didn’t foresee the money to be made by the slave-based cotton industry made possible by the simple cotton gin.

The fugitive slave law stems from the Constitutional idea that states have to respect the official acts of other states. If a Coloradan gets busted for pot in Kansas and flees back home to Colorado, Colorado is obliged to return him. (Yes I know slaves weren’t criminals, but running away from slavery was a crime in slave states).

I think the Founders did the best they could with a very difficult dilemma. They banned slavery where they could.


10 posted on 01/09/2016 8:46:32 AM PST by hanamizu
[ Post Reply]

To: ex91B10

Of course their humanity was a factor but if they were to be treated the same as cattle and not actually allowed to be represented why should they be counted?


11 posted on 01/09/2016 8:56:27 AM PST by rockrr (Everything is different now...)
[ Post Reply]

To: hanamizu

Bingo.


12 posted on 01/09/2016 9:03:31 AM PST by ZULU (Mt. McKinley is the tallest mountain in N. America. Denali is Aleut for "scam artist.")
[ Post Reply]

To: SkyDancer
"And South Caroline and Georgia would refuse to join the Union unless concessions to the slave trade were made in the Constitution."

Not the "slave trade" but slave ownership.

What were the alternatives at that time? "Free" a bunch of savages with stone-age skills and socialization, or load them all on ships and return them to Africa?

13 posted on 01/09/2016 9:07:01 AM PST by Redbob (#BlackCoffeeMatters)
[ Post Reply]

To: Citizen Zed
Slavery was the original crack the Liberty Bell.

I wonder if the Founding Fathers, whom I read made a Covenant with God in creating this new nation, saw that crack as being prophetic.

Because the FFs sacrificed their integrity by violating their own stated Bill of Rights, I see African slavery as the reason the Liberty Bell cracked.

I see that crack in our Liberty Bell as a prophetic warning of things to come.

We've gone through two civil wars since, about 100 years apart, trying to heal our broken Liberty Bell, but we got a politically correct Great Society, instead.

In our latest attempt to heal our original sin, we elected a community agitator who immediately began to beat that broken Liberty Bell to pieces.

How unexpected. obamacare hasn't healed our broken Liberty Bell.

14 posted on 01/09/2016 9:08:08 AM PST by GBA (Here in the matrix, life is but a dream.)
[ Post Reply]

To: ZULU
"BernStein is a sophmoric fool. Everything is much simpler in retrospect. The entire concept of a Republic with citizens instead of a monarchy with subjects was a new thing, as was the concept of equality. So Bernstein, typical liberal dog in a Manger, should go pound salt."

Very nicely put!

Love your tagline too.

15 posted on 01/09/2016 9:08:50 AM PST by Redbob (#BlackCoffeeMatters)
[ Post Reply]

To: GBA

Almost every comment posted above makes perfect sense.

Almost...


16 posted on 01/09/2016 9:11:30 AM PST by Redbob (#BlackCoffeeMatters)
[ Post Reply]

To: 5thGenTexan

No one mentions that ....”Irish need not apply”..... just a blip to the intellectuals I suppose. Also the fact that the islamists are and were some of the biggest slave traders going?...Note the use of the word “ARE” who do you think builds up the middle east?....It’s not the citizens of the country that’s for sure....in all of natures strains of life there is a definite pecking order in each.....what makes us any different?


17 posted on 01/09/2016 9:11:39 AM PST by mythenjoseph (Separation of powers)
[ Post Reply]

To: Redbob

My only excuse is that I got up late and haven’t finished my first cup of coffee yet.


18 posted on 01/09/2016 9:18:33 AM PST by GBA (Here in the matrix, life is but a dream.)
[ Post Reply]

To: hanamizu

Nice post, hanamizu. Some actions in history, really are the result of the totality of circumstances. Second guessing is pretty easy two centuries down the road when the facts don’t get in the way.

I’ve recently read again James Flexner’s “Washington, The Indispensable Man.” Brings a full sense of reality to what our Founders faced at the time.

Oldplayer


19 posted on 01/09/2016 9:20:35 AM PST by oldplayer
[ Post Reply]

To: Redbob

Not sure. It was just those states holding up the ratification of the Constitution. All states had to agree and sign otherwise no Constitution. It was blackmail of a sort.


20 posted on 01/09/2016 9:26:46 AM PST by SkyDancer ("Nobody Said I Was Perfect But Yet Here I Am")
[ Post Reply]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-40, 41-60, 61-75 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson