BROADER INCOME TAX BASE IN ‘ALL-OUT’ REVENUE PLAN IS URGED BY MORGENTHAU (8/9/41)

Microfilm-New York Times archives, Monterey Public Library | 8/9/41 | Turner Catledge, C. Brooks Peters, Daniel T. Brigham, Cyrus L. Sulzberger, David Anderson, more

[CougarGA7]

This sure is a long response that says nothing. All this has in it is a bunch of “I know you are but what am I” comments, and more proof that you are not even willing to do a slightest amount of work yourself. All you do is repeatedly parrot other people’s work and show no initiative or signs that you can think for yourself. Now I will give you one last hint for where you should look, but that’s it. I’m shocked on how much you must be babied along in the most simple matters. Look in July’s threads. Lastly, if you want to keep discussing it, put it in the current thread so everyone else can read it too.

[BroJoeK]

CougarGA7: "This sure is a long response that says nothing."

Referring to your own comments, of course I agree.

[CougarGA7]

Lol. Whatever makes you feel good about yourself kid.

[BroJoeK]

CougarGA7: "Lol. Whatever makes you feel good about yourself kid."

Sorry pal, but you lost this particular debate, because you can't, or won't, provide a coherent analysis of McCollum's Eight Actions.

Instead, you want me to make your side of the argument for you, which is ludicrous to the max.
If I made your argument for you, I'd do a better job of it than you've done here, but it would still be false.

Anyway, better luck next time -- hey, I got an idea, how about you don't start a debate you're not willing to finish?

;-)

[CougarGA7]

I told you were to go find it. All you have to do is get off your lazy butt and look.

[BroJoeK]

"I told you were to go find it. All you have to do is get off your lazy butt and look."

In fact, you have never produced a coherent analysis of McCollum's memo.

Of course, if you think I'm wrong, then provide the link to your words which show a detailed & coherent understanding of what McCollum's memo was all about.

I personally don't think you understand anything about this -- instead you have a list of talking points, and that's all you can deal with.

But, hey, prove me wrong -- show me the link.

;-)

[CougarGA7]

In fact I have. And I have told you were to go find it. Now show some initiative boy, I want to see if you can actually do something on your own.

[BroJoeK]

CougarGA7: "Now show some initiative boy..."

Assuming I'm older than you, I'll take "boy" and "kid" as compliments, old man.

;-)

[CougarGA7]

See, I knew you couldn’t do it. You are either too lazy or too incompetent. I’m leaning towards the later.