[dirtboy]

Maybe if we can put together some good suggestions on how Defkalion should enable independent verification of the 1 MW reactor we can pass this along to them. Ideas?

My gut feeling is that if this were a truly viable and real system, they wouldn't need suggestions on how to verify it. Good science operates in the open.

[cripplecreek]

So far all its produced are promises and hype.

[Liberty1970]

I largely agree, but what I'm hoping to avoid is something where Defkalion offers "X, Y and Z" as evidence, and skeptics say "But what we really wanted to see is A, B and C!" for proof. If there is a sort of shared concensus amongst the various parties of what steps need to be taken then this can be avoided.

Of course, once an E-cat finally ships to a private customer none of this will be necessary. The problem is with any financial risks being born until that point.

[aruanan]

My gut feeling is that if this were a truly viable and real system, they wouldn't need suggestions on how to verify it. Good science operates in the open.

Obviously said by someone who has never worked in a research lab on something the PI is hoping to score big on.