[RummyChick]

here is joan
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NkyYHYUcGgo

cheezy music from dolly

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GdqOiCvNXBQ

[bert]

Thanks for that. I rolled the thought around all night and concluded the version I remember best was by the Kingston Trio. That would be my salad high school days. I have a good but very conservative friend who was and still might be a Joan clone

Following your lead I looked this morning but couldn’t find the Kingston Trio music so we could listen to what in my mind is the definitive version.

Joan sang it in the first person, Haley sang it in third person. I thought she could have made it very personal and more Idolish in first person recounting her own woe