[SunnyUsa]

I was going nuts trying to remember who Alex was ...I think you meant Andrew (I was thinking I really don't remember Alex) lol you made me look all their names up again....

I totally agree with you about Siobahn I really liked her- not I'm just "eh" about her...

Don't really like Andrew that much

I like Tim just because he irks the judges with his staying power....and he's cute - no doubt about it!

I don't like Mike - he's got a decent voice, but I'd never be a fan

Bowersox was good last night but she's not my cup of tea for a singer....too much like Joplin - ick

Katie is amazing to me for her confidence at such a young age

Aaron my daughter just loves (teen)

Casey is pretty cute - I like him ...eye candy etc and would maybe buy his record

Lee....I love him, would buy his record if he wins/or doesnt win

I think Andrew or Mike should go tonight

[Palladin]

Who should go: Tim or Garcia

Who will go: Katie or Aaron

[freedumb2003]

>>.too much like Joplin - ick<<

I believe you may be the first human being to put “(Janice) Joplin” and “ick” in the same sentence.

You could do worse than channel Joplin. And Crystal’s interpretation was very unique while respecting the original material.

But to each his/her own.