"I am Gandalf the White and I come to you now at the turn of the tide."
Posted on 04/30/2008 1:56:53 PM PDT by JenB
Ring ping please?
Wouldn’t be the same with any other actor.
Nope, not the same. Which is why I was happy to see this.
"I am Gandalf the White and I come to you now at the turn of the tide."
I’d just as soon he didn’t. After reading his comment about Gandalf being a homo, I lost all respect for him.
McKellen was indeed a perfect Gandalf, in spite of his personal evils.
I’d be just as happy if they lost Andy Serkis, though, but doubt that will happen. I don’t think he quite “got” Gollum; I know he didn’t get what “gollum” was (i.e. swallowing, not coughing).
I was wondering about that too. Plus, I sort of feel that the whole book The Hobbit has a very different feel than LOTR. Its a much more innocent little story, and Gollum, scary as he is, is almost a comical figure. It really is much lighter fare. I wonder if Del Toro gets that. His Pan’s Labyrinth was truly dark.
Yes; “Pan’s” shows he’s quite the artist, but it is a miserably unhappy story.
However, Hellboy is (paradoxically) much lighter, more comic.
So, I’m not gloomy about it.
(c:
I have had Pan’s Labyrinth on my DVR for some time now. I was wondering if I should take the time to watch it or just delete it to make room.
Do you recommend it? Is it worth my time?
Ohhhh, boy; I don’t think I know you well enough to answer usefully. It’s very artistic, has a lot of imagination and humanity and beauty — but it’s also very violent and, in the end, VERY unhappy.
Artsier types will give you a different answer. It really depends on what you like and are looking for. Creative, artistic, well-crafted, horribly depressing: that’s my summary.
Hope that’s of some use.
Dude. You just gave me a chill.
I hope McKellen signs on. It will be an awesome film.
Thanks.
Sounds like my kind of flick.
Artsy and depressing.
No.
Yes, he is an outstanding actor.
I wonder if the guy who did Gollum’s voice for the BBC radio dramatization is still around. Can’t remember the name - but his voice is what Goillum should sound like.
Visually stunning, but a dark, violent, brooding and melancholy fantasy. If you are into graphic novels and adult fantasy, then definately see it.
Who wants to be a wizard when you can be fabulooooso
Yes, that actually is Sir Ian.
You mean Grandolf the Gay?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.