Posted on 02/19/2008 11:03:14 AM PST by rjp2005
Caruso was a singer, hence Publius6961’s tongue-in-cheek question to Soliton about it being a musical.
It was a little funny...
I've read all the Harry Potter books and enjoy the series. I just thought it was a great line.
I have to admit I was disappointed after reading book 7, although the book itself was well-written. If it's okay to talk fantasy on a sci-fi thread, here goes:
Several of the plot devices were very clunky. in Prisoner of Azkaban, Dumbledore, Snape and Lupin all knew the Shrieking Shack was a hangout with a path directly to Hogwarts, but nobody thought to check to see if Sirius was using it. In Goblet of Fire, anything could have been used as a portkey, but Voldemort and Crouch work out a plan that requires Harry to win a tournament in order to get him to touch the Triwizard cup? Why didn't Moody (Crouch) just give Harry a detention one night and make him go out to dig onions and make the shovel a portkey? Even in small things, there are irritating inconsistencies. For example, in Order of the Phoenix, the twins are in Harry's room, and they hear Mrs. Weasley trying to sneak up the stairs, so they apparate, which creates a loud crack. Why can't she hear a loud crack when they can hear a soft step on the stairs?
Despite the flaws, Rowling writes characters brilliantly, and that's the strength of her work. The reader believes her characters are alive, even the minor ones are incredibly well fleshed out.
By the way, another thing that bugged me, besides the whole Dumbledore is gay thing, is that I read an interview where Rowling was relating a conversation she had with Daniel Radcliffe. It was after she'd seen him in Equus, but before she'd written book 7. She said she told him she was writing him a nude scene in HP 7. She ended up writing three nude scenes, one involving seven Harrys. She's like 40, and he just turned 18. That's a little creepy to me.
Finite Incantatum on that hex, retrokitten...
I disagree. The opening sequence where (is it Blair?) surveys the MacArthur's damage would be a great opening for the movie. The stuff with Bury is central to one of the sub-plots.
Then there's Battlestar Galactica (new one). Around 5,000 years ago, something happened and humans were evicted from a world and settled in a solar system with 12 inhabited planets (and the Earthlings).
Although fiction, both have some ancient history that is vague and not fleshed out, and more and more of that history is revealed as the story progresses.
Haven’t heard anything about a movie project based on the Foundation series. Try Googling and you may find something on it.
Okay, having read the prior posts, this has been a fun thread.
I remember being weened on Sci Fi as a kid, watching Outer Limits and The Twilight Zone. Lost In Space was a favorite, but the movie remake was horrible. The first Sci Fi movie to make an impact on me was The Andromeda Strain. I don’t know if it holds up as well, but I recall it was Critchon’s first movie?!!!
I hear they are making Speed Racer into a movie. A movie I would love to see would be Jonny Quest. It is a spy movie with a lot of sci fi technology. The remake in the 90’s was blah.
As for books yet to make it into movies would include Foundation Trilogy, Ringworld, Ender’s Game. I remember with great anticipation when the Dune the movie was being made and how disappointed I was. Then Sci Fi network did their own in a series of movies covering the first 3 books. It was much better. I think this was so because of the advances in CGI and film making. For this reason, I think most Sci Fi movies can now make the transition to film.
I really enjoyed the War of the Worlds remake and though it was Sci Fi, it was Tom Cruise as the dad that made the movie compelling. The ‘50’s version still holds up well and I was totally into the Blob the first go around. Very scary as a kid and gum chewing was never the same afterwards.
As others have commented, The Incredibles is a great flick, capturing Bond and FF in great reverence and parody. It even had some great lines paraphrased from Kurt Vonnegut’s Harrison Bergeron short story.
That picture of Ricardo Mountalban (sp?) as Khan is scary on many levels. I really can’t believe he was the inspiration for the business up front, party in the back hair style. I will never look at him, the movie, or mullets in the same way. Further, he obviously “borrowed” his pecs from Ahnold, perfection at a price.
Lastly, Terminator, the Sarah Connor Chronicles has held up very well. I especially like the ode to James C in naming the female terminator Cameron. Nice touch.
Nicely done. What medium did you do it in?
If Firefly had been written science fiction, it probably would have done nothing for me. As a TV series, OTOH, it bordered on brilliant. Now, the first episode I saw on Fox was the one with the shipment of cattle, and I was like “WTH?”, but it grew on me. Then I got the DVD box set (for something like $20 - a bargain) and got to watch it in the intended order, without interruption. The more I watched the more I liked it - the characters made the show.
Staedtler permanent liners 01, 03, 05 and 07 — the lovely disposable ones — on smooth bristol.
Pilot is one case where my drafting background came in handy. I still don’t want to think about how long it took me. I have a print of my “Aeryn Sun” that I got signed by Claudia Black in NYC...2 days before 9/11.
Spelling is optional on FR.
I Like it with a ZZZZZZZZZZEEEEEEEEEEEEE!
I declare a Fatwa!
Yeah! That was a really complicated show. I’d like to see those episodes again. I may have to order the DVDs!
Actually, it makes perfect sense... None of the women are "shrinking violets," dependent on a macho guy... In fact, every one of those women could kick your ass, and some do on a regular basis. Even River, the "victim," is actually found to be quite possibly the most dangerous human around.
More importantly, let's face it. For most guys, it's a winner if there are guns, explosions, and nubile women wearing wholly inappropriate, and far too scanty, costumes. Women, on the other hand, seem to be interested in characters, story, and plot. And Firefly has those covered in spades. Coupled with Joss Wheedon's sense of humor, and demands that his characters have GREAT one-liners, you've got a show that would have been the biggest hit Fox had since The Simpsons. I have yet to meet someone who's actually seen a few episodes of Firefly who hasn't fallen in love with it.
Mark
The first 10 minutes of Starship Troopers I was horrified. One of my all time favorite adolescent novels was being destroyed before my very eyes. Then I started laughing, had a beer, and enjoyed the hell out of the babes, bombs and body parts. Love the over-the-top patriotism.
Shepherd Book was probably my favorite character. A holy man with a vast knowledge of weaponry and enough inside information to know exactly how an operative works. He was truly an enigma worth trying to figure out. It is a pity that we won’t see his character fully developed.
I know exactly what you mean... I just love looking at Dina Meyer. I don't think that I've ever actually seen her in a "good" movie: Well, Dragonheart was one of the better ones, but she's done a fair number of SF/Fantasy movies, Including Johnny Mnemonic. And she was in that "Batgirl spin-off" TV show too... On the other hand, the other one (Charlie Sheen's ex-wife) does nothing for me. Heck, I can't even remember her name.
Mark
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.