The only assessment of yours I agree with. Paris has the range and should have sung the song an octave higher.
Catherine, Paris, Ace and Chris all move well on stage and look GREAT as well as sing GREAT. Ace and Catherine have the best stage presence. Taylor who delivered the best performance of all HIS performances, falls WAY short in all categories by comparison, his voice has no range (and is good for only the simplest of songs) and as Simon said, he looks ridiculous.
BTW, I LOVE Queen. I disagree with the judges about Ace's performances. For once his voice wasn't nasal. It was strong and on pitch and this was his best evening. I agree with Ace's own self-assessment. He ROCKED!
I am not the only person on this thread who saw Ace as doing BackStreet Boys. Did you not hear the Major Key change where there was a Dim key change in the original? I suspect the Queen band didn't know about it.
Sadly, tis was Ace's chance to USE that gawdawful falsetto. He demured and blew his opportunity.
OK, I have to ask -- you like what I think are the bottom 3 -- who is gone?