American Idol 2006--Live Thread (Part II)

FOX ^ | 3-25-06

[silent_jonny]

still for Tammy

[luv2lurkhere]

I'm hoping the shocker isn't Elliott going home. I used the second line and got only 2 busy signals in 15 minutes. I am trying to prepare myself for the possiblilty. He certainly does not deserve to go before Paris or Kelly.

[Howlin]

Chris, for sure.

[AmusedBystander]

Apparently Ryan said that Nigel said that a "shocker" is to come tonight - someone with a huge fan base going home.

Could be Katherine. The judges savaged her pretty well last night.

[Netizen]

DialIdol
Rank

Idol

DialIdol Score

Margin Of Error

Actual Rank

1-3

Taylor Hicks 05

26.01

1.581

-

1-3

Chris Daughtry 06

25.954

1.582

-

1-4

(B3)

Elliott Yamin 02

23.721

1.605

-

3-5

(B3)

Katharine McPhee 01

22.467

1.619

-

4-6

(B3)

Kellie Pickler 03

19.421

1.65

-

5-6

(B3)

Paris Bennett 04

17.36

1.671

-

[over3Owithabrain]

Elliott definitely deserves to stay. And he will.

[luv2lurkhere]

"Elliott definitely deserves to stay. And he will."

I hope you're right!

[Republican Red]

I thought Kellie was the last, sorry!

I do not like Paris but at this point Kellie is an embarrassment. The Pickler is so outclassed. I hope Kellie gets the boot tonight.

Still think Kellie was the person Nigel was describing with her Huge fan base.

[silent_jonny]

shame on jonny. :)

[LA Woman3]

http://pop.wizbangblog.com/2006/04/26/katharine-mcphees-american-idol-wardrobe-malfunction.php

[Netizen]

Still think Kellie was the person Nigel was describing with her Huge fan base.

I guess in the event of ties the votes being so close AI reserves the right to make the final choice of who goes. Which might be why we never learn how many votes each one gets. Or how close is close enough for AI to decide? :)

[TonyWpi]

"Apparently Ryan said that Nigel said that a "shocker" is to come tonight - someone with a huge fan base going home."

If that's true it would have to be Kellie. She's NEVER been in the bottom 3 so it would be a "shocker" if she goes home.
Based upon Tradesports, Dial Idol and some of the other site...Paris is predicted to go home. She had her best week last week and was STILL in the bottom 3.

It should be interesting...

[TonyWpi]

"Katharine: Lovely face. Flabby body."

Huh??? Katharine has a GREAT body!! Oh...you must be one of those guys who like your women to look like Holocaust victims.

[Netizen]

Kellie's long overdue for going home so it wouldn't be a shocker. It would be justice.

[TonyWpi]

Mutt is a genius!

And he goes home to Shania every night to boot!

As Glenn Beck would say...
AAAHHHHH YEAAAAAAHHHHHH

[SunnyUsa]

OH, please let it be that embarressment to dumb blondes everywhere...... KELLY .....gets the BOOT!

[Wolfstar]

Oh...you must be one of those guys who like your women to look like Holocaust victims.

LOL! I'm not a guy, but a happily hetero gal, so I don't see her the same way guys do. :)

[silent_jonny]

Hi, Wolfstar :)

Katharine: Lovely face. Flabby body

Ouch, I have to disagree with that. She may be a little wide in the hips, but I wouldn't call that flabby. (I just left Walmart and I saw plenty of flabby! :)

If Pickle doesn't go home tonight, the point will be made most clearly that this is no longer a singing contest.

If she's not at least in the bottom two (or three) then something is very wrong.

Paris will probably be the one leaving tonight--even though it should be Pickler. Just as long as it's not anyone else.

[TonyWpi]

Now I know many of you guys on this thread love to bash Kellie....but think about a few things:

Katharine (and I like her best of all the girls this season) has a mother who's a voice teacher and she's been singing all her life. She's got plenty of training under her belt.

Paris has a grandmammy who's a recording artist. She's had all the breaks and training. You don't think she just woke up and could sing like that at 17 do you?

Now Kellie...she's just a country girl from a small hick town in NC. She's had no formal training and would be considered the only "amateur" contestant in the mix.

You've got to at least give her SOME credit.

And if her "dumb Blondie" routine was an ACT don't you think there's be plenty of people (mostly ex-boyfriends) coming out and writing "tell all" articles to National Enquirer? I haven't seen one yet.

She MAY go home tonight but I still give her credit. And if she stays, she still won't win so it's not too big of a deal.

[Wolfstar]

Grin...Tony here's a "peace" offering, since you and I disagree about Katharine's ummmm, flab.

[TonyWpi]

"LOL! I'm not a guy, but a happily hetero gal"

oops...sorry about that one...

Anyway....good analysis in spite of the "flabby" comment!