American Idol 2006--Live Thread (Part II)

FOX ^ | 3-25-06

[silent_jonny]

still for Tammy

[silent_jonny]

Welcome back :) You came back on a good night!

[misterrob]

Elliott just passed Pickle on Dial Idol. He's #2!!!!

[buckeyesrule]

****Pickler hasn't had one standout performance in the entire competiton.****

LMAO!

[silent_jonny]

I happen to have loved Motley Crue and resembled that remark. LOLOLOL!

:) Did you own a denim jacket with fringe? (I'm painting a mental image here :)

[I'm ALL Right!]

He's the anti-Ace.

LOL

[Shelayne]

It's kinda strange, but I rarely get busy signals when I vote. This week I have gotten through every single time for both Kat and Chris (MY #1 & 2, respectively).

But it has been that way since last year. The first year I tried to vote I got a constant busy signal, so I just wouldn't do it again until the final four last year.

Anyway, if I were to guess I would say that Ace is probably going home tomorrow. Kellie has too big of a fan base, and I think she endeared herself when she admitted that she "stunk up the farm" (my words, not hers), though it is not inconceivable that she is in the bottom three, and she should be if it is based on tonight's performance. I just don't think most people vote that way. I think they have overall favorites and vote for them even if they "stank". ;^)

[retrokitten]

Guilty.

{Hanging my head in shame}

[TonyWpi]

I credit Simon...he was "hard" on Elliott tonight and that gave him enough sympathy vote (along with Seacrest's comments last week about him being in the bottom 3) to save him.
I'm going to throw Katherine Zeta-McPhee some votes too because she's losing some steam. She was very good tonight so a lot of people will "ASSUME" she's safe.

[silent_jonny]

LOL! If I didn't love you, I'd beat you.

Haha (you know I'm only teasing ;)

[Ohioan from Florida]

That is, if you can get through. I haven't on Katharine so far. Got through for Elliott once.

[Echo Talon]

Pickler hasn't had one standout performance in the entire competiton.

She did good 2 weeks ago, I didn't like the original but thought it sounded good.

[TonyWpi]

"LOL! If I didn't love you, I'd beat you."

That's what Paula said to Simon last week! *hic*

[silent_jonny]

I am getting to the point where it is going to be hard for me to watch

That's the best time TO watch, LOL :) Did you watch last year? When they got down to the final three it was almost as stressful as Florida 2000 :)

[TonyWpi]

I've liked Pickler's tunes over the past 2 weeks.

She bombed out on Stevie Wonder night and didn't do very well tonight.

She's not "bad," she's just "drawn" that way.

[silent_jonny]

Night, CB :) Tonight was a lot of fun!

[andyssister]

Or an extra in a Motley Crue video :)

Oh,I hated Motley Crue!! Three cheers for The Clash!:)

[silent_jonny]

Trace Adkins ... He's the anti-Ace.

You mean Trace Adkins is ugly and can't sing!!?? (/sarc ;)

[I'm ALL Right!]

Aside from Ace's hair and Kellie's singing a whole measure ahead of the music, I can't think of what American Idol Park will make fun of from this week's show. It was really the best one I've seen.

[Senator Goldwater]

"Pickler hasn't had one standout performance in the entire competiton"

That Melliisa Etheridge number was hot.

And I've never used all of THOSE words in a complete sentence before.

[TonyWpi]

LOL...

Good one!