I don't know what you're talking about...Every store I go to has christmas themed wrapping paper. I think you guys are really getting carried away with this stuff. Last week, all I wanted was a menorah. The ONE symbol for Hannukah. There are literally thousands of Christmas decorations and symbols one could buy. For Hanukkah, there is but one. I went to every store in my town and there was not ONE sign of hannukah. The WalMart Superstore did not even have Hannukah cards. I finally found a Hallmark card store that had Hannukah related items (right when you walked into the store too!). the point is I'm not whining about it, and neither should you.
Petco has a couple hannukah items! Very sweet indeed.
...goes on and on...and they bring it right to your door....
Yes there are many symbols for the secular commercial Christmas. Once there were many religuous symbols too. Now our religous symbols have disappeared...and we feel marginalized and robbed.
"Christmas-themed" is very generic. There are lots of wintertime-themed papers out there, but the selection of Christmas wrap with specific religious motifs is indeed rather limited. These would include the Nativity scene, angels, scripture quotes, etc. Yes, you're correct about the fact that there are lots of papers out there with Santas, ornaments, snowflakes, toys, nutcracker soldiers, etc. all over them, but very few are specifically printed with Christian-symbols and/or artwork.
Another concept: some enterprising amongst us might look on your situation as an entrepreneurial opportunity, where you could open up a storefront, even short-term, that would carry Judaica-related items, including Menorahs and Hanukkah cards.