[So Cal Rocket]

Hey... when Pascal got his torch snuffed, do you remember if Probst said, "The Tribe has Spoken"? Or did he say "The Purple Rock has Spoken"?

[AxelPaulsenJr]

I think Jeff actually said: "The tribe has definitely not spoken".

[AxelPaulsenJr]

My apologies. I will get my mind in gear here. Not sure at all what Jeff said.

[cuz_it_aint_their_money]

Jeff said “The tribe has spoken.” when he snuffed Pascal’s torch. I distinctly remember this because I screamed at the TV screen “No you Jackass, the damn purple rock has spoken!”

But look at this another way:
Jeff told the group, when they were picking tribes, that the last two players remaining (i.e. not selected) would be eliminated. They knew ahead of time, so in effect, when they were not picked to be on a tribe, they were voted off the island.
If Jeff had NOT told them that the last two would be eliminated, then I would concede your point. But since he did tell them, I contend they were in fact voted off by not being picked.