Posted on 10/01/2026 9:39:39 AM PDT by Red Badger
The first sign that Tennessee’s execution of Christa Pike had gone badly wrong came from Pike herself.
She was strapped to a gurney inside Riverbend Maximum Security Institution. The drugs had begun flowing.
Reporters were watching from behind glass.
Then Pike looked at her arm, smiled, and asked a question that left the witnesses rattled.
According to WKRN anchor Tori Gessner, Pike said her arm felt like it was about to burst open. She then looked at one spot and asked, “Does this happen like that?”
Her spiritual adviser told her to relax. Pike answered, “I’m trying.”
It only got worse from there.
Pike received two rounds of pentobarbital Wednesday night and remained alive. Witnesses heard her breathing, moaning and eventually snoring as prison officials repeatedly lowered the curtains and blocked the chamber from view.
The New York Post highlighted the unnerving account Thursday morning:
Gessner had witnessed five previous executions in Tennessee. She said nothing about this one was normal.
The curtains first closed at 7:46 p.m., with Pike still plainly breathing. They reopened three minutes later while she snored loudly with her mouth open.
Officials closed them again shortly after 8 p.m. This time, they stayed closed. Reporters could hear Pike but could no longer see what the state was doing.
Gessner’s account is captured in the witness briefing shared below:
The state never completed the execution.
The Associated Press documented a sequence that appears to have no modern precedent in Tennessee. Pike remained alive after officials administered both doses permitted by the state’s protocol, leaving prison staff without another authorized injection to administer.
Her lawyers filed emergency motions while the attempt was still unfolding, arguing that continuing would subject her to needless agony.
Witnesses were removed from the viewing area around 8:53 p.m. Pike was later taken by ambulance to an off-site hospital. Her condition was not immediately made public.
The failed attempt came after a day of legal whiplash. Pike had been scheduled to die at 10 a.m., but a federal appeals court issued a stay about an hour before the execution.
The U.S. Supreme Court later lifted that stay, clearing Tennessee to proceed Wednesday evening.
The delay stretched for hours before the chamber doors finally opened.
Pike, 50, was sentenced to death for the 1995 torture and murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer. Pike was 18 at the time of the crime.
Had the execution succeeded, she would have been the first woman put to death by Tennessee in more than 200 years.
Instead, the night ended with Pike alive, an ambulance leaving the prison and Tennessee’s execution system under a new cloud.
Gov. Bill Lee responded by halting the state’s only remaining scheduled execution for 2026. He also ordered a comprehensive third-party review to determine exactly what happened.
Lee said carrying out a lawful sentence is among the state’s gravest duties. He acknowledged that Tennesseans expect an execution to meet three basic tests: it must be legal, constitutional and effective.
The Tennessee Department of Correction insisted that its staff followed every step of the execution protocol approved by the attorney general’s office. The agency said pentobarbital had consistently been effective in prior uses.
The statement also exposed the protocol’s hard limit. It did not authorize prison officials to attempt anything beyond the procedures already carried out Wednesday night.
That meant the state had administered both permitted doses and still had no lawful next step when Pike remained alive. Officials could stop, close the curtains and move her to a hospital — but they could not complete the sentence they had begun carrying out.
The protocol describes a second round of chemicals if the prisoner remains alive after the first. It does not explain what happens when the second round also fails.
That gap is now at the center of the review Lee ordered.
Conservative commentator Matt Walsh argued that the debacle exposed a deeper problem with lethal injection — a process built to look clinical even when it becomes anything but:
His conclusion will be controversial. The underlying point is harder to dismiss.
Lethal injection is often presented as controlled, medical and predictable. Witnesses on Wednesday described a woman complaining about her arm, a room hidden behind curtains, loud snoring after two massive doses of sedative and state officials with no remaining procedure to follow.
Tennessee has already had another execution failure this year. In May, officials abandoned the attempted execution of Tony Carruthers after medical workers could not establish an IV line.
Now Lee has ordered an outside review, and the state’s remaining 2026 execution is off the calendar.
Whatever comes next, the question Pike asked from that gurney will hang over the investigation.
Was that supposed to happen?
I wonder why they don’t use fentanyl.
I wonder why they don’t use fentanyl.
Another reason we should do it like they do in Japan, only announce the execution 2 weeks after the fact.
I wonder why they didn’t put her in the electric chair 30 years ago.
I read somewhere that she possibly had problems with circulation or her veins and that was why she didnt want the needle. Is it possible her vein burst?
If she hasn’t already, another chance to repent and get saved...
How much OJT does an executioner get?
That is between her a God. I want her to suffer here for what she did.
The pharmaceutical companies block its use in executions.
A candy stripe nurse could be doing this for practice.
Canada has become quite skilled in “assisted” suicides. One in 10 Canadian deaths are by that.
Unless there is a tariff on suicide assisters, import someone from up North, eh?
They need people with technical skills to do these bizarre rituals, and we are not trained in the most effective way to kill people with unlicensed drugs.
Assisted suicide is legal in Canada, and the people who do it can obtain licensed drugs of certified potency, following a protocol based on evidence.
It’s horrible - but it’s not similar to what happens in a US State execution.
Maybe they used the generic pentobarbital. Save money!!
Maybe they used the generic pentobarbital. Save money!!
Well it just cost the taxpayers a lot of money.
My guess is that this is similar to the political activists who manage to get themselves on juries, knowing ahead of time that they would never find a woman or a black person guilty of anything.
The guy doing this lethal injection is, I bet, against the death penalty and botches these things on purpose. I believe this is the second time he screwed up. He’s trying to appall people so that executions are outlawed.
I am not pro-death penalty. In this case, however, even with the botched execution, her situation is still more merciful than what she subjected her victim too.
Are we reserving fentanyl for unconvicted undesirables to off themselves?
Shotgun. Head. No time for pain.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.